Market Announcement: AwardOptions for the Oscar nominees will halt trading Sunday at 1 pm Pacific Time.

HSX Forums: Movies Board

Ooh! A cherry-picked bad review, one that coincides with your opinion. Most critics (and viewers) disagree with you.

Posted by: Tanker (a.k.a del_QFM_Tanker) on May 07, 10:30 in response to DTXbro's post The 93 rating is a point in Avengers' favor, but perhaps...

But they are only opinions and in the grand scheme of things, what does it really matter?


I'm sorry the movie didn't work for you. Did you short it or something? Did Joss Whedon run over your dog? You seem to be taking this a bit too seriously, IMHO.

There are still 90M shorts on AVNGR. It's gone up. Some brave souls. {nm}   elchan on May 07, 07:43

Have you researched the record of shallow, spectacle-laden films with monster openings fueled by midnight showings? Knowledge is good. {nm}   DTXbro on May 07, 07:49

Have you noticed that The Avengers has been understimated at every turn? {nm}   Tanker on May 07, 07:51

Yeah, the Best Picture Oscar is probably in the bag. {nm}   DTXbro on May 07, 07:53

Oh, I'm sorry, I thought we were talking box office figures and not nominoptions. Please carry on then. {nm}   Tanker on May 07, 07:54

Content quality appears to influence the half-life of movies.At least, that's the general record. See: Transformers, Twilight, etc. {nm}   DTXbro on May 07, 07:57

Would you consider Dark Knight to be a shallow, spectacle-laden film? {nm}   BionicMoron on May 07, 08:04

No. I believe it transcended its genre to substantial degree, thanks in large part to Heath Ledger. {nm}   DTXbro on May 07, 08:16

Heath Ledger won (and, I believe, deserved) an Oscar for Dark Knight. Which Avenger is most likely to win an Oscar? Plus, Buffy The Vampire   DTXbro on May 07, 08:29

You do realize Joss Whedon didn't direct Buffy the Vampire Slayer, don't you? Not that it matters. {nm}   Tanker on May 07, 08:43

The difference here is that The Avengers is quite entertaining good action/comedy movie likely to have good legs. {nm}   Adriii on May 07, 08:08

Though I don't think using its quality as an argument here, I'm in flippers' team. At least in short tearm. {nm}   Adriii on May 07, 08:09

Which Transformers should I see? The one with 57% fresh, 35%, or 20% fresh on RT? Avengers holding at a paltry 93% fresh, BTW.   Tanker on May 07, 08:13

Did not fanboys (& girls) inflate Transformers and Twilight fan ratings for a (brief) time? Historically, that subsides, and numbers at IMDB   DTXbro on May 07, 08:24

Oh, I didn't bother with the viewwer's %, just the critics. Fanboys & fangirls skew things too much.   Tanker on May 07, 08:35

The 93 rating is a point in Avengers' favor, but perhaps a misleading one. The reviewer in Pittsburgh, for example, wrote this:    DTXbro on May 07, 10:01

Ooh! A cherry-picked bad review, one that coincides with your opinion. Most critics (and viewers) disagree with you.   Tanker on May 07, 10:30

I am comfortable relying on Ebert, especially when The New York Times has his back. Quality is readily distinguishable from quantity.{nm}    DTXbro on May 07, 10:33

The movie worked great for Deltas. We made millions. The point was that predicting delist>adjust, esp. without support, was lame.   DTXbro on May 07, 10:36

His comment is about how huge openers do post adjust historically...and the lack of research done by the poster   alfpaulytd2012 on May 07, 08:17

Really?! Do you think that any research could have predicted the AVNGR performance?   elchan on May 07, 08:36

Once again....made NO CALL either way of how its going to do...just giving perspective with actual facts   alfpaulytd2012 on May 07, 08:39

Only $8M for TLKAM. {nm}   elchan on May 07, 08:47

Yes...and that's 33-60% higher than your EMPHATIC prediction   alfpaulytd2012 on May 07, 08:54

I said $5M-$6M, so it's more like 25%-36% better. Still won't make the $90M delist that it was at last week. ;-) {nm}   elchan on May 07, 09:15

Hey, enjoy playing and GL....just don't try to make it out like I'm giving out an opinion like that other id and we're cool {nm}   alfpaulytd2012 on May 07, 09:17

DRKSH seems like a descent enough movie, but there's AVNGR has too much momentum.   elchan on May 07, 08:10

I was thinking the same, but then i did look up some other ones that had A+ cinema score. I honestly think its not worth the commission    idrom on May 07, 08:19

Especially Fund Managers, wouldn't you say :) ? Three funds I found long on AVNGR yesterday have all flipped. {nm}   fred_ott on May 07, 08:03

I don't find it unreasonable to think that it won't make the 2.7 multiplier with such a big opening. {nm}   jwammo on May 07, 08:06

Given the competition this week, it's not unreasonable to think that it would have another > $100M weekend.   elchan on May 07, 08:16

yeah, I personally would give it 50/50 on making the multiplier, no conviction either way... {nm}   jwammo on May 07, 08:21

The Dark Knight ended its fourth weekend with a 2.78 opening weekend multiplier - that was in the summer with all the kids out. {nm}   fourstars on May 07, 08:16

Delists: BATM2 $430/Avatar $430/HPOT8 $343/LRDL3 $312/Titanic $42. {nm}   forlorne on May 07, 08:39

Again, AVNGR has been underestimated, even for the adjust. The total domestic gross is $207.1M   elchan on May 07, 08:52

You can't even compare Avengers to HGAME?   Tanker on May 07, 09:08

That's post flip. During halt, there were only about 13.918 (you know, just "about") million shares shorted. {nm}   funnybillypro on May 07, 10:45

So it's the funds doing the shorting. There should be rules against funds doing shorts, unless they're specifically hedge funds. {nm}   elchan on May 07, 11:27

Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!

The Lion King (LIONK) 50000 221.12 (+0.45)         Bright (BRGHT) 100000 1.30 (-0.23)         Bright (BRGHT) 100000 1.30 (-0.23)         Coco (DDLM) 25000 87.15 (-0.46)         X-Men: The New Mutants (NMUTN) 24000 53.22 (-0.58)         Bright (BRGHT) 100000 1.30 (-0.23)         Vin Diesel (VDIES) 20000 114.93 (+1.14)         Rock Dog (ROCDG) 100000 11.07 (+1.60)         The Foreigner (FRGNR) 99999 17.55 (+1.84)         Karen Gillan (KGILL) 20000 89.91 (+0.20)         Everybody Loves Somebody (EBLSB) 40000 3.36 (-0.42)         Captain Marvel (CMARV) 100000 120.53 (-0.25)         First Man (FIRSM) 35000 31.48 (-0.70)         The Kingkiller Chronicle: The Na (KNGKL) 46717 60.73 (+10.73)         Everybody Loves Somebody (EBLSB) 40000 3.36 (-0.42)         John Wick: Chapter 2 (WICK2) 100000 79.65 (+3.45)         Fifty Shades Darker (50SH2) 100000 109.71 (-1.72)         The House of Tomorrow (HOTMR) 99999 5.46 (-0.71)         Bright (BRGHT) 25000 1.30 (-0.23)         I Don’t Feel at Home in This W (IDFAH) 100000 0.01 (-0.04)         The Kingkiller Chronicle: The Na (KNGKL) 99000 60.73 (+10.73)         The Kingkiller Chronicle: The Na (KNGKL) 49500 60.73 (+10.73)         Bright (BRGHT) 100000 1.30 (-0.23)         Bright (BRGHT) 100000 1.30 (-0.23)         Harvey Keitel (HKEIT) 20000 30.48 (-0.32)         Simon vs. The Homo Sapiens Agend (SVHSA) 100000 26.56 (+1.15)         Simon vs. The Homo Sapiens Agend (SVHSA) 100000 26.56 (+1.15)         Nicole Kidman (NKIDM) 20000 13.77 (0.00)         Get Out (GETOU) 100000 77.52 (+6.89)         The Rats of NIMH (RNIMH) 28000 44.61 (+0.16)         Robert De Niro (RDENI) 20000 20.85 (+0.40)         The Zookeeper's Wife (ZKPWF) 1 17.29 (+0.15)         First Man (FIRSM) 100000 31.48 (-0.70)         The Boss Baby (BOSSB) 1 70.88 (-0.20)         When We First Met (WWEFM) 20000 11.70 (-0.07)         Unicorn Store (UNICS) 20000 11.96 (-0.03)         The Kingkiller Chronicle: The Na (KNGKL) 73648 60.73 (+10.73)         Game Night (GAMEN) 100000 35.59 (-0.72)         Game Night (GAMEN) 100000 35.59 (-0.72)         Gambit (GAMBI) 33000 31.37 (-1.02)         The Assignment (TOMBO) 20000 1.34 (-0.05)         X-Force (XFORC) 100000 41.64 (+0.59)         A Foreigner (AFRGN) 99998 4.45 (+0.58)         Collide (ABAHN) 100000 3.12 (-0.07)         Dune (DUNE) 100000 60.84 (+1.18)         Dune (DUNE) 100000 60.84 (+1.18)         The Foreigner (FRGNR) 100000 17.55 (+1.84)         Bright (BRGHT) 100000 1.30 (-0.23)         The Kingkiller Chronicle: The Na (KNGKL) 99999 60.73 (+10.73)         The Foreigner (FRGNR) 100000 17.55 (+1.84)