HSX Forum

Movies

But pirating of any sort is illegal. Viewing of pirated material is a vote in support of pirating and those hits encourage sites to post it.

Posted by: Catzan on Jan 19, 14:39 in response to dsbman's post No, because the trailer will still be released. It's just...

The sites generate revenue from those hits which would have been reserved for the folks getting the "real" released trailer. Point is...the trailer is copyrighted and owned by the distributor for their release how they see fit for profit to those who are able to release it if indeed there can be profit. Unauthorised release of someone else's product is a trafficker of pirated goods. No, those sites won't be prosecuted because enforcement jsut wants to stop it. If the source is a repeat offender then I presume prosecution could follow. My understanding is enforcement wants the source. And while trailers or clips aren't "mortal sins" they do contribute to the mentality of pirating isn't so bad.


I suppose even the photos we see from on-set are a form of pirating but I haven't seen where that is as much an issue as clips or torrents.  

To each his own. I can't watch 'em. 

Bootleg trailer for Piranha 3D [PIRAN] on Youtube. Antibody Jan 19, 13:14

why is it ok to advertise a copyright violating trailer but not watch a torrents? :/ {nm} adrenalin112 Jan 19, 13:29

oh snape maceodkat Jan 19, 13:39

Am I missing out on a gif featuring the lovely Scarlett Johansson... ??? {nm} Toruk Facto Jan 19, 15:01

no. just popcorn. {nm} adrenalin112 Jan 19, 15:07

Ok, it's just copy/paste onto a URL. It's ScarJo munching on popcorn, alright, looking thoughtful or involved... {nm} Toruk Facto Jan 19, 15:38

Because watching a copyright violating trailer does not result in a decrease in revenue. {nm} dsbman Jan 19, 13:43

it may if it looks really bad and its not the material or quality that the studio intended to release. so keep going, try again... {nm} adrenalin112 Jan 19, 13:45

No, because the trailer will still be released. It's just being held for a specific date. {nm} dsbman Jan 19, 14:23

But pirating of any sort is illegal. Viewing of pirated material is a vote in support of pirating and those hits encourage sites to post it. Catzan Jan 19, 14:39

actually, it's not. some unauthorized copying may still be legal under the Fair Use Doctrine {nm} mickpix Jan 19, 14:50

I would have to look at the federal statute that was handed to us but I do know that folks are asked to delete even small amounts of Catzan Jan 19, 17:18

Seriously? Online trailers are free anyways. {nm} Antibody Jan 19, 13:54

"hurry before they take it down" this material wasnt officially released. so right now, its stolen. {nm} adrenalin112 Jan 19, 13:57

Go ahead and make yourself feel better if you think that's the same as watching a pirated full-length movie. {nm} Antibody Jan 19, 14:05

LAWLZ - its called PERMISSION you hippogriff. screeners are free, WOM from leaks can help generate intrest.... etc maceodkat Jan 19, 14:07

Uploading a screener is illegal, asked the guy who leaked WOLVE. {nm} Antibody Jan 19, 14:09

and people get their youtube accts for repeat offenses of copyright violations. {nm} adrenalin112 Jan 19, 14:11

"get their youtube accts banned" {nm} adrenalin112 Jan 19, 14:12

so what if i stop the download early of a free dvd screener and watch only part of it? is it ok then? {nm} adrenalin112 Jan 19, 14:08

All you're doing is revealing your ignorance of the law. Do you see anyone going to jail linking to a leaked trailer? {nm} Antibody Jan 19, 14:12

just because one act is less wrong than the other doesnt mean that its right. adrenalin112 Jan 19, 14:18

Where was the outrage when the whole world watched the bootleg ATEAM trailer. :) {nm} Antibody Jan 19, 14:35

you didnt post it up. and that person never gave me a " :-/ face" for watching a movie out of wide release and not yet on dvd {nm} adrenalin112 Jan 19, 14:39

I just asked a question without any emoticon. You outed yourself. {nm} Antibody Jan 19, 14:44

you sir, made a face. adrenalin112 Jan 19, 15:07

im not trying to downplay the illegality of pirating movies. im just saying that the principle is there for all violating footage regardles adrenalin112 Jan 19, 14:14

My MPAA rep has told me that any recording of a movie or part of a movie is illegal. He asked us to stop people from recording trailers or Catzan Jan 19, 14:19

tell them dmac says to chillax on that. snippets dont count :^/ {nm} maceodkat Jan 19, 14:43

01/19/2010 - The day adrenalin112 owned dmac.* adrenalin112 Jan 19, 14:45

Keep believing they're equvalent. The whole movie/blog sites link leaked trailers, but not pirated movies. /Shrug. {nm} Antibody Jan 19, 14:49

theyre not the same. but theyre both wrong. derrrrrrrrr {nm} adrenalin112 Jan 19, 14:54

Wow! Christopher Llyod?!?! Now I wanna see it!! {nm} FabioParme Jan 19, 17:50





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


Man of Tomorrow (SPMOT) 1 270.38 (-0.47)          Dinner With Audrey (DWAUD) 2954 5.04 (+0.83)          The End of Oak Street (FLWVS) 11855 73.42 (+0.18)          Incredibles 3 (NCRD3) 100 390.78 (+1.50)          Hey Bear (HEYBR) 75000 5.46 (+0.74)          Dinner With Audrey (DWAUD) 75000 5.04 (+0.83)          My Darling California (MDCAL) 100 26.10 (+1.10)          Alice Eve (AEVE) 20000 8.56 (-0.08)          Alice Eve (AEVE) 25000 8.56 (-0.08)          My Darling California (MDCAL) 150000 26.10 (+1.10)          My Darling California (MDCAL) 75000 26.10 (+1.10)          The Blair Witch Project 4 (TBWP4) 75000 28.64 (+1.41)          Chum (CHUM) 150000 0.63 (-0.03)          Chum (CHUM) 150000 0.63 (-0.03)          The Devil Wears Prada 2 $200M Bl (PRAD2.BW) 1000 11.54 (+0.07)          Obsession $150M Blockbuster Warr (OBSSN.BW) 1000 7.14 (+0.24)          Moana (MOAN1) 75000 241.79 (-0.41)          Leo Woodall (LWOOD) 110 6.12 (+0.05)          James Badge Dale (JBDAL) 100 2.44 (+0.02)          Club Kid (CLUBK) 100 13.72 (+0.98)          Masters of the Universe (HEMAN) 150000 78.77 (+1.28)          Masters of the Universe (HEMAN) 150000 78.77 (+1.28)          Bad Blood (BDBLD) 100 0.10 (+0.01)          Helldivers (HELDV) 150000 103.43 (+1.82)          Helldivers (HELDV) 150000 103.43 (+1.82)          Avengers: Doomsday (AVNG5) 4 528.90 (0.00)          Teen Titans (TEENT) 62567 31.97 (-0.01)          Helldivers (HELDV) 41989 103.43 (+1.82)          Helldivers (HELDV) 42840 103.43 (+1.82)          Romy & Michelle 2 (ROMY2) 150000 5.65 (-0.47)          Teen Titans (TEENT) 63406 31.97 (-0.01)          Romy & Michelle 2 (ROMY2) 150000 5.65 (-0.47)          Obsession $150M Blockbuster Warr (OBSSN.BW) 25000 7.14 (+0.24)          Barbie Ferreira (BFERR) 25000 37.70 (-0.12)          Club Kid (CLUBK) 149999 13.72 (+0.98)          Above The Below (ABELW) 149999 6.30 (+0.67)          Primetime (PRMTM) 149999 22.81 (-0.60)          Angel and the Badman (ANBAD) 149999 14.33 (+0.66)          Romy & Michelle 2 (ROMY2) 150000 5.65 (-0.47)          The Get Out aka Bear Country (BEARC) 149999 6.04 (-0.04)          Romy & Michelle 2 (ROMY2) 150000 5.65 (-0.47)          Above The Below (ABELW) 100 6.30 (+0.67)          A Minecraft Movie Squared (MINE2) 30000 314.29 (+0.47)          Toy Story 5 (TOYS5) 10000 382.63 (-0.04)          Late Fame (LTFAM) 110 1.03 (0.00)          Bluey the Movie (BLUEY) 50000 138.19 (+0.11)          Ice Cream Man (ICREM) 110 17.37 (0.00)          The Beast (TBEAS) 150000 6.66 (-0.08)          Tony (TONY) 110 20.18 (0.00)          The Beast (TBEAS) 150000 6.66 (-0.08)