HSX Forums: Movies Board






His argument is that they are romantic comedies which don't have the familiar tropes. I'm saying they aren't romantic comedies at all {nm}

Posted by: parthm_ on Dec 01, 10:57 in response to Antibody's post ' Rom-coms that don’t want to be rom-coms."...

MCN: This is the Year of Reconstructed Rom-Com.    Antibody on Dec 01, 10:17

This feels like a huge reach. Pretty much every movie he listed was    parthm_ on Dec 01, 10:29

*remotely {nm}   parthm_ on Dec 01, 10:29

' Rom-coms that don’t want to be rom-coms." That's the point. {nm}   Antibody on Dec 01, 10:34

then they're not actually rom-coms so . . . {nm}   slipping jimmy on Dec 01, 10:44

So Deconstructed Rom-Coms? {nm}   Antibody on Dec 01, 10:58

this is like me saying i'm going to deconstruct the action movie by writing one with no action. if you put your love interest in a coma for   slipping jimmy on Dec 01, 11:01

Well, The Big Sick is basically a de/reconstructed version of While You Were Sleeping, a traditional RomCon. {nm}   Antibody on Dec 01, 11:03

but it didn't play out like a rom com. rom coms skew very female (2/3). Big Sick was closer to 50/50 or like an indie drama {nm}   Moviesnob on Dec 01, 11:14

yeah. which again, i was fairly engaged with (I love a good James Brooks as much as anyone). but i was expecting something else {nm}   slipping jimmy on Dec 01, 11:16

I saw it at Sundance so it was hard not to expect a Sundance film. I should clarify that it was majority female, but not as heavily as most   Moviesnob on Dec 01, 11:24

His argument is that they are romantic comedies which don't have the familiar tropes. I'm saying they aren't romantic comedies at all {nm}   parthm_ on Dec 01, 10:57

Seriously, this is one of the worst articles ever written. I award David Poland no points and may God have mercy on his soul.   JSpicoli13 on Dec 02, 01:33

Honestly DMac, linking to this garbage is beneath you. {nm}   JSpicoli13 on Dec 02, 01:34





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!

Aladdin (ALADN) 10000 307.12 (-0.71)         The Princess Diaries 3 (PDIA3) 100000 49.96 (+8.80)         Tyler Perry's A Madea Family Fun (MADFF) 470 58.94 (-0.45)         Vigilance (VGLNC) 99990 8.36 (-0.09)         The British Fund (BRITS) 10000 20.22 (+0.01)         Shazam! (SHAZM) 50000 122.77 (+1.82)         The Professor and the Madman (PROFM) 25000 3.18 (-0.06)         The Professor and the Madman (PROFM) 99991 3.18 (-0.06)         The Princess Diaries 3 (PDIA3) 100000 49.96 (+8.80)         The Aftermath (AFTRM) 100000 1.48 (+0.02)         A Star Wars Story 3 (SWAR3) 100000 114.16 (+2.92)         Us (US) 10443 156.57 (-1.39)         Ms. Purple (MSPRP) 99999 2.22 (0.00)         Dogman (DOGMN) 99999 1.86 (-0.02)         Dogman (DOGMN) 50000 1.86 (-0.02)         The Princess Diaries 3 (PDIA3) 60000 49.96 (+8.80)         Gloria Bell (GLORB) 99999 5.29 (+0.76)         Us (US) 100000 156.57 (-1.39)         Bermuda Triangle (BTRIA) 100000 26.69 (0.00)         Framing John DeLorean (FRMJD) 99999 1.91 (+0.04)         Long Day's Journey Into Night (LDJIN) 99999 1.25 (-0.18)         Pokemon: Detective Pikachu (PIKAC) 1 250.30 (+0.50)         The Princess Diaries 3 (PDIA3) 100000 49.96 (+8.80)         Beetlejuice 2 (BEET2) 100000 2.71 (+0.02)         The Beach Bum (TBBUM) 19999 11.13 (+0.10)         Falling (FALIN) 99999 3.92 (-0.11)         Jesus Was My Homeboy (JWMHB) 100000 10.64 (+1.40)         Shazam! (SHAZM) 100000 122.77 (+1.82)         Captive State (CAPST) 100000 6.60 (-0.21)         Captive State (CAPST) 100000 6.60 (-0.21)         A Star Wars Story 3 (SWAR3) 7000 114.16 (+2.92)         A Star Wars Story 3 (SWAR3) 7000 114.16 (+2.92)         Jesus Was My Homeboy (JWMHB) 100000 10.64 (+1.40)         Shazam! - Opening Weekend (SHAZM.OW) 1762 50.28 (+1.24)         Last Night in Soho (LNSOH) 20000 19.45 (+1.60)         Last Night in Soho (LNSOH) 3359 19.45 (+1.60)         Hotel Mumbai (HTLMB) 100000 5.44 (-0.22)         Wonder Park (AMUSM) 100000 38.77 (+0.16)         Last Night in Soho (LNSOH) 29999 19.45 (+1.60)         A Star Wars Story 3 (SWAR3) 8804 114.16 (+2.92)         Captive State (CAPST) 10000 6.60 (-0.21)         Pet Sematary H$25 Call (PETSM.CA) 15000 2.82 (+0.02)         Wonder Park (AMUSM) 10000 38.77 (+0.16)         Shazam! H$45 Call (SHAZM.CA) 20000 3.32 (+0.08)         The Aftermath (AFTRM) 10000 1.48 (+0.02)         Young Hollywood Fund (YOUNG) 10000 34.83 (0.00)         Five Feet Apart (5FTAP) 10000 35.98 (+0.26)         The Princess Diaries 3 (PDIA3) 100000 49.96 (+8.80)         Universal Studio Fund (UNIVX) 10000 17.48 (-0.04)         The African-American Fund (AFRAM) 10000 67.96 (-0.07)