HSX Forum

Movies

I think this take needs some work and here's why.

Posted by: RogerMore on Dec 22, 12:42 in response to Filmstardust's post Well, this is for those who said only a "small but...

I know a lot of SW fans. Plenty of them didn't like TLJ. Plenty of them don't like the way the franchise is heading. None of them are the people who get upset about woke-ness and SJWs. I haven't met anyone like that IRL, I only see them on the internet, where they are small but loud.

The people I talk with about Star Wars are upset about other things.

Like, a guy I know who loved TFA because it was fan-service but didn't hated TLJ, because he basically grew up wishing he could be Luke Skywalker and didn't like that happened to Luke in TLJ. A miserable hermit who was tempted to kill his protege? That wasn't the Luke he grew up with.

Or another guy, who wasn't planning to see Solo. "Oh, because of its SJW agenda?" I joked - but he didn't get the joke and I had to explain what an SJW is. He didn't want to see Solo because it seemed to him like a cash-grab - a movie that didn't need to be made, and he didn't want to see a young Han.

So my take is this is what mainstream SW fans think about the franchise. They don't like what has happened with the franchise renewal, but it has little to do with the things that make on-line haters upset. The people who complain about Marey Sues and Soylos remain a "small but loud amount of people".

And it's nearly impossible to have a real conversation about this, because it always gets dominated by those small but loud people.

D: STAR9 $179m+; CATS $6.5m; FAIRB $5.1m tomcat90 Dec 22, 07:47

Wow- all 3 tanking vs expectations. Has to be a new low Hollywood at the holidays.... {nm} Sleprock Dec 22, 07:54

BO: STAR9 $175.50m tomcat90 Dec 22, 08:22

W: STAR9 $175.5m as well...I'm sure D will update shortly tomcat90 Dec 22, 08:31

If it has a similar multiplier as STAR8, that's H$456 delist. {nm} ~JPV~ Dec 22, 09:12

That'd be less than HALF of TFA final...How soon could we expect KK to retire? {nm} Solo Lost Money Dec 22, 10:09

Pretty much no chance of catching TLJ opening. Wow {nm} VictorY Dec 22, 08:41

Next weekends drop will be huge too. Even the rugged RT aud score won't save it... {nm} Solo Lost Money Dec 22, 09:12

What's rigged about the RT score? Just click on All Audience {nm} jamesbik333 Dec 22, 09:29

It's rigged because some people like a movie he doesn't {nm} JDolphin Dec 22, 11:03

Ha! {nm} CSBD Dec 22, 15:06

Its rigid due to not moving.. Disney broke RT over Capt Marvel...easy if Disney buys a few thousand tickets upvotes to counter downvotes. {nm} Solo Lost Money Dec 22, 19:45

The review bombing trolls on CM made RT add verified. Disney buys critics, upvotes, tickets crazy conspiracy theories {nm} jamesbik333 Dec 23, 04:23

Access media intentional throws soft reviews in order to maintain the access, Weinstein was a classic example. {nm} Solo Lost Money Dec 24, 15:33

It'll have less of a second weekend drop than last Jedi bc TLJ had Christmas Eve. MattW Dec 22, 11:27

Well, this is for those who said only a "small but loud amount of people" didn't like TLJ. {nm} Filmstardust Dec 22, 10:16

I think this take needs some work and here's why. RogerMore Dec 22, 12:42

to add to this...IMHO that small but loud group... tealfan Dec 22, 15:32

I agree, my take is that the loudness drives away casual moviegoers. Every fan I know is still going strong, even if they disliked TLJ... {nm} slappydavid Dec 22, 16:19

Ryan Johnson should be very proud for screwed my up a mighty franchisee {nm} bunty_ketti Dec 22, 19:38





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


Abigail - Opening Weekend (ABGAL.OW) 100000 19.88 (+0.17)          Transformers One (TFCYB) 75000 77.34 (+2.43)          Spy x Family Code: White - Openi (SPYFM.OW) 100000 8.35 (-0.09)          Spy x Family Code: White - Openi (SPYFM.OW) 100000 8.35 (-0.09)          The Movie Critic (TMOVC) 150000 44.93 (-11.92)          Sight (SIGHT) 10000 8.14 (+0.08)          Blue Lock The Movie - Episode Na (BLULK) 150000 15.00 (0.00)          Tarot H$15 Put (HRSCP.PU) 25000 2.76 (+0.76)          Blue Lock The Movie - Episode Na (BLULK) 150000 15.00 (0.00)          The Ballad of Wallis Island (TBOWI) 150000 5.68 (-0.32)          Blue Lock The Movie - Episode Na (BLULK) 100 15.00 (0.00)          The Ministry Of Ungentlemanly Wa (TMOUW) 150000 29.64 (+2.00)          The Ministry Of Ungentlemanly Wa (TMOUW) 150000 29.64 (+2.00)          Haikyu!! The Dumpster Battle (HAIKY) 150000 13.53 (+0.28)          Unsung Heroes H$10 Call (UNSUN.CA) 25000 1.64 (+0.13)          Haikyu!! The Dumpster Battle (HAIKY) 150000 13.53 (+0.28)          Unsung Heroes - Opening Weekend (UNSUN.OW) 100000 9.79 (-0.08)          The Ministry Of Ungentlemanly Wa (TMOUW.PU) 25000 4.39 (+0.16)          The Ministry Of Ungentlemanly Wa (TMOUW.CA) 25000 0.45 (+0.06)          The Ministry Of Ungentlemanly Wa (TMOUW.OW) 100000 11.21 (+0.31)          The Fall Guy H$50 Put (FALGY.PU) 25000 2.41 (+0.41)          Just Cause (JCAUS) 40000 0.03 (-0.02)          The Fall Guy H$50 Call (FALGY.CA) 25000 3.49 (+1.49)          The Fall Guy - Opening Weekend (FALGY.OW) 100000 51.86 (+1.86)          Tarot H$15 Put (HRSCP.PU) 25000 2.76 (+0.76)          Tarot H$15 Call (HRSCP.CA) 25000 1.64 (-0.36)          Tarot - Opening Weekend (HRSCP.OW) 100000 13.81 (-1.19)          Spy x Family Code: White H$10 Pu (SPYFM.PU) 25000 2.80 (-0.02)          Spy x Family Code: White H$10 Ca (SPYFM.CA) 25000 0.70 (+0.11)          Bad Blood (BDBLD) 20000 0.12 (+0.02)          Spy x Family Code: White - Openi (SPYFM.OW) 100000 8.35 (-0.09)          Kung Fu Panda 4 $155M Blockbuste (PAND4.BW) 25000 12.60 (+0.53)          Ghostbusters: Frozen Empire $100 (GHST5.BW) 25000 7.99 (+0.39)          Rumours (RUMRS) 150000 7.06 (+0.24)          Dune: Part Two $235M Blockbuster (DUNE2.BW) 25000 17.78 (-0.15)          Rumours (RUMRS) 150000 7.06 (+0.24)          Challengers H$10 Call (CHALN.CA) 1 3.30 (+0.23)          Challengers H$10 Put (CHALN.PU) 25000 1.31 (-0.18)          Andy Warhol biopic (WARHL) 40000 0.12 (+0.01)          Challengers H$10 Call (CHALN.CA) 25000 3.30 (+0.23)          Challengers - Opening Weekend (CHALN.OW) 100000 12.14 (+0.33)          Abigail H$25 Put (ABGAL.PU) 25000 4.97 (+0.10)          Abigail H$25 Call (ABGAL.CA) 25000 0.44 (+0.08)          The Janson Directive (JANSD) 40000 0.12 (+0.09)          Abigail - Opening Weekend (ABGAL.OW) 100000 19.88 (+0.17)          Animal Farm (AFARM) 84001 0.14 (+0.06)          Challengers - Opening Weekend (CHALN.OW) 1 12.14 (+0.33)          Tarot H$15 Put (HRSCP.PU) 25000 2.76 (+0.76)          Belushi (BELUS) 20000 0.11 (+0.03)          Challengers H$10 Put (CHALN.PU) 1 1.31 (-0.18)