HSX Forum
Movies
‘There’s a lot about mental illness that’s really funny’ – How Fringe comedians are starting an important conversation
Australian comedian Ward tells me that she is having the best Fringe she’s ever had, with her most successful show to date, What If There’s No Toilet? An hour about Irritable Bowel Syndrome and mental illness. Hardly most people’s idea of a laugh a minute subject matter. But why not?
Felicity believes that the biggest challenge for her when it comes to performing stand up about a serious subject that can make people feel uncomfortable is to make it more funny than it is alienating:
“I always knew that was going to be the challenge. Because people either don’t want to talk about mental illness or we only talk about it in very serious, respectful, reverent tones – otherwise you’re seen as laughing at mental illness when actually, there is a lot about mental illness that is really funny… If I’m talking about it then I’m giving you permission to laugh about it. I’m not saying that people that don’t have a mental illness can get up and go ‘how about those freaking crazies!? They’re nuts aren’t they?!”
Too bad Will Ferrell pussed out. We'll most likely not see many edgy comedies ever again; there's always somebody out there offended.
goodvibe61
Apr 29, 21:53
Curious, do you have anyone in your family with dimentia?
{nm}
~JPV~
Apr 29, 22:09
Yeah. Also, I doubt whether it would make much difference regarding the making of a good film.
{nm}
goodvibe61
Apr 29, 22:18
EXACTLY.
{nm}
goodvibe61
Apr 29, 22:22
It depends on how it's done. some Leslie Nelsons characters had dementia like defects. Oh and my mom has dementia.. sometimes laughter is
Baron_Darcon
Apr 29, 22:32
And that's the point, it's based on a real person. Heck, I wouldn't care if they did a satire on the Reagan presidency...
~JPV~
Apr 29, 22:37
Comedian Ruby Wax: What's So Funny About Mental Illness?
Captain Obvious
Apr 29, 23:20
And in some of these examples, it's those with the disease that's doing the comedy and thus bringing light to it.
{nm}
~JPV~
Apr 30, 00:18
Hence coming from them, it carries far more weight. In the case of this movie, again, the point isn't to cause attention to dimentia
~JPV~
Apr 30, 00:20
What difference does that make? So, the only person that should make a film about a bank robbery is a bank robber.
{nm}
goodvibe61
Apr 30, 00:28
Nobody else with an imagination could bring any light to it.
{nm}
goodvibe61
Apr 30, 00:35
Apples and oranges. Mental disorder is not the same thing as bank robbery. I'm done.
{nm}
~JPV~
Apr 30, 00:36
Comedian Joshua Walters: On Being Just Crazy Enough.
Captain Obvious
Apr 29, 23:21
SPLITSIDER:The Uneasy Relationship Between Mental Illness & Comedy.
Captain Obvious
Apr 29, 23:27
WOW: There's A Lot About Mental Illness That's Really Funny.
Captain Obvious
Apr 29, 23:32
Not sure if a comedy about or surrounding Reagan's dimentia was to "start a conversation." Seems like it's to mock him more than anything.
{nm}
~JPV~
Apr 30, 00:16
Performing in black face is never funny
{nm}
Kirk Lazarus
Apr 29, 22:52
How does the screenplay handle the material? There are so many people out there who found the screenplay to be exceptional.
{nm}
goodvibe61
Apr 30, 01:11
People seemed to dig Tropic Thunder
{nm}
numbersix_99
Apr 30, 03:21
did not SNL build their Reagan jokes in the 80s on dementia?
{nm}
mattep74
Apr 30, 00:08
Nope.
{nm}
TheEradicator
Apr 30, 00:17
Nope a lot of their jokes were he was this sweet old man for the camera and sharp as a tack behind the scense
{nm}
Dorfman
Apr 30, 03:16
I don't have a problem with comedy related to any subject, including dementia, in a general sense,
shadowking
Apr 30, 07:05
In other words - A fictional president with dementia, played for laughs = potentially funny,
shadowking
Apr 30, 07:10
I don't see Will Ferrel comedies as "edgy". Self-humiliation and potty humor are not "edgy", at least IMO.
{nm}
DTravel
Apr 30, 12:23