HSX Forum

Movies

But that's what the character is meant to be like ...

Posted by: Jane_Citizen on Sep 20, 19:52 in response to lobogotti's post it very well might be, but I stand by my post of months...

if you don't stick with that, you might as well make a different movie.

FWIW, statistically, women read a lot more fiction than men, and probably make up a large proportion of the book's audience, so I would expect a lot of women to be seeing this movie; Mara's attractiveness is probably not going to affect their interest either way ... And surely men's interest in a David Fincher thriller with Daniel Craig in it isn't contingent on his co-star, is it? I guess the role will be a huge challenge for Mara and Fincher to sell - the character is not all that likeable in the book, I'm really interested to see how she translates in this version. I would have thought the film's potential appeal strongly to both men and women is one of its assets.

It will be another of those interesting book to film conversion things too - I would say it was an absolute done deal in terms of converting the book's massive audience, except for the fact that the Swedish films were already reasonably successful (although obviously on a very different scale). Surely a huge proportion of those readers will already have had their appetite for seeing what it looks like onscreen satisfied ... i mean, this is a book that sold like Harry Potter.

Moneyball was a very good film. B to B+ in quality. It plays a little long, but I wouldn't quite know what to cut. lobogotti Sep 20, 19:27

thats awesome {nm} Moviesnob Sep 20, 19:29

:) it was a moment to finally relay what little knowledge I have gained from all these great minds! {nm} lobogotti Sep 20, 19:33

here? great minds? its like 12 monkeys in here! NO MORE MONKEY BUSINESS BUY NOW! {nm} Moviesnob Sep 20, 19:43

:) one of his best roles indeed! {nm} lobogotti Sep 20, 19:44

also, forgot that the audience got a 10 minute preview of The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo......it was easily forgettable. lobogotti Sep 20, 19:32

will say though before they played the Tattoo clip and told the audience what they were going to see, people did cheer a little. {nm} lobogotti Sep 20, 19:34

I am not listening! Dragon Tattoo WILL be great. I am willing it to be so. {nm} Jane_Citizen Sep 20, 19:35

it very well might be, but I stand by my post of months back about its box office potential. they made a mistake making lobogotti Sep 20, 19:37

i suspect Fincher has a great deal of sway over the marketing if not final decisions. Its great art wise, but its turning most people off {nm} Moviesnob Sep 20, 19:41

exactly. art wise ain't gonna get back those dollars at the box office. if Craig can move Dreamhouse maybe that will be more telling, but lobogotti Sep 20, 19:47

But that's what the character is meant to be like ... Jane_Citizen Sep 20, 19:52

... but maybe I'm coming at it too bookishly. :) {nm} Jane_Citizen Sep 20, 19:53

it does have the advantage of getting the holiday legs. that will help. maybe it gets glowing reviews? it is Fincher and he is great at lobogotti Sep 20, 19:59

indeed. Jane_Citizen Sep 20, 20:09

not sure where it was set, UK I think? i know everyone is speaking with accents. found that odd. {nm} lobogotti Sep 20, 20:11

interrresting ... that sounds like an alternative universe anglophone Sweden to me :) {nm} Jane_Citizen Sep 20, 20:14

TGRLW is also set in Sweden. {nm} Antibody Sep 20, 20:17

right there with you! {nm} tealfan Sep 20, 20:09

although I'm not actually a big fan of the book myself, actually Jane_Citizen Sep 20, 20:23

Really? I found it to be a particularly easy, acceptably flowing narrative. No, it's not Cormac McCarthy or Thomas Pynchon, it's pop fiction goodvibe61 Sep 21, 00:25

I think it reads flatly and pulpily. But that may be the translation. Jane_Citizen Sep 21, 01:02

A couple things of note: goodvibe61 Sep 21, 00:37

hehe :) {nm} Jane_Citizen Sep 20, 19:38

I don't understand the comparison between Blind Side and moneyball. Surely dolphin is more like blind.. perply1 Sep 20, 19:38

well early on the only comparison was that the books were written by the same author. but then Yahoo did a story about the comparisons lobogotti Sep 20, 19:42

It's marketed like The Social Network x Major League. I don't get Blind Slide vibe at all. {nm} Antibody Sep 20, 19:39

i gotta agree, i dont see blind side in the marketing {nm} Moviesnob Sep 20, 19:40

I agree, too. I haven't seen Blind Side but I kind of got a straight tearjerker drama vibe from it while Moneyball seems very lighthearted {nm} Ruthian23 Sep 20, 19:46

I also agree no Blind Side. I'm getting more of a Field of Dreams vibe. {nm} Jane_Citizen Sep 20, 19:59

... it would take a lot to get me to watch a baseball movie, but I'm up for this one. Jane_Citizen Sep 20, 20:04

and it is...if you get the chance take it in. i think you'll enjoy it. {nm} lobogotti Sep 20, 20:06

I'm a massive Sorkin fan too of course :) I totally forgot this was his! Der. {nm} Jane_Citizen Sep 20, 20:12

I love Field of Dreams, but I didn't really get that from it, either. I didn't really see Major League in it, either. Ruthian23 Sep 20, 20:18

from the 1st and 2nd trailer it is all over it. the TV spots and recents ads I can agree with your comments on. it's nothing like Major lobogotti Sep 20, 19:44

Out of curioisty, how big of a baseball fan are you, lobgotti? Ruthian23 Sep 20, 19:48

lobogotti*, sorry. Lost an "o" there. {nm} Ruthian23 Sep 20, 19:48

I'm a big fan. I also read the book....a few weeks back actually. They handled it very well. The scouts were what scouts are. lobogotti Sep 20, 19:55

That's good to hear, though slightly disappointing that Hoffman doesn't play a bigger role as Art Howe, as I'm a huge Hoffman fan. Ruthian23 Sep 20, 20:04

he shines in his scenes though {nm} lobogotti Sep 20, 20:05

Gotta disagree. The comedy may not be as broad, but assembling a bunch of cast-off players and reaching the playoffs = Major League. {nm} Antibody Sep 20, 19:48

but it's such a scientific movie. there are no belly laughs and for the most part the film is very serious in tone. {nm} lobogotti Sep 20, 19:53

Hence x The Social network. {nm} Antibody Sep 20, 19:57

yes, I agreed with that aspect of yor post and said so. Sorkin contributes that much to the film. lobogotti Sep 20, 20:01

Always nice to have you around posting, lobogotti. Nice story :) Did she ask if you needed a job? {nm} Paul2k Sep 20, 19:46

thanks Paul, love to be here. just been hard lately. haven't traded a stock in a while....scared to look in the port. lobogotti Sep 20, 19:51

for those in doubt that people early on are comparing this to The Blind Side do a google search for moneyball blind side.......dozens of lobogotti Sep 20, 20:04

That's because it's an easy story to write based on the fact both movies were adapted from the same author. {nm} Antibody Sep 20, 20:06

but my comments that peopel are comparing the two were pulled out of thin air. that's been going down since the trailer first hit. lobogotti Sep 20, 20:08

*weren't pulled out {nm} lobogotti Sep 20, 20:09

look at all these posts, the foums miss you, lobo :) {nm} Jane_Citizen Sep 20, 20:15

yeah and i miss all you guys/gals. movies are my passion. i love to conversate about them and gather feedback from people lobogotti Sep 20, 20:21

Sounds about right thatpj Sep 20, 20:16

first time i have approached them like that. but considering i can go to about any sneak i will start engaging more. {nm} lobogotti Sep 20, 20:22

Trust you to be so specific about its prospects ;). As much as this movie looks good, I don't get a "must-see" vibe. {nm} accountant_4_Jesus Sep 21, 03:05





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


Unsung Hero (UNSUN) 31588 21.88 (+0.55)          The Fall Guy (FALGY) 86 120.49 (-3.53)          Green Lantern Corps (GLAN2) 100000 8.10 (-0.03)          MaXXXine (XTW3) 2000 9.92 (-0.08)          Kraven the Hunter (KRAVN) 7834 103.91 (-0.68)          Separate Rooms (SEPRM) 150000 6.00 (0.00)          Madden (MADEN) 1571 31.50 (+5.58)          Apartment 7A (APT7A) 84468 8.63 (-2.88)          Animal Friends (ANFRN) 16946 55.48 (+2.34)          Boy Kills World (BOYKW) 110594 8.69 (+1.28)          Train Dreams (TRDRM) 150000 6.66 (-0.08)          They Listen (THEYL) 86609 29.25 (+1.64)          Lips Like Sugar (LIPLS) 150000 11.76 (+0.82)          Madden (MADEN) 150000 31.50 (+5.58)          Apartment 7A (APT7A) 150000 8.63 (-2.88)          Madden (MADEN) 150000 31.50 (+5.58)          Kingdom of the Planet of the Ape (APES4.OW) 100000 47.62 (+1.89)          Madden (MADEN) 150000 31.50 (+5.58)          Ilana Glazer (IGLAZ) 25000 22.27 (-0.25)          Animal Friends (ANFRN) 150000 55.48 (+2.34)          Rental Family (RNTLF) 150000 11.78 (-0.04)          East Bay (EASTB) 150000 1.00 (0.00)          Separate Rooms (SEPRM) 150000 6.00 (0.00)          Karate Kid (KKID2) 150000 104.94 (+2.38)          Separate Rooms (SEPRM) 150000 6.00 (0.00)          East Bay (EASTB) 150000 1.00 (0.00)          Kraven the Hunter (KRAVN) 150000 103.91 (-0.68)          They Listen (THEYL) 150000 29.25 (+1.64)          The Fall Guy (FALGY) 150000 120.49 (-3.53)          The Fall Guy (FALGY) 150000 120.49 (-3.53)          Madden (MADEN) 150000 31.50 (+5.58)          By All (BYALL) 10000 5.01 (-0.01)          What You Wish For (WYWF) 659 0.82 (-0.04)          By All (BYALL) 50000 5.01 (-0.01)          Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga (MMAX5) 50000 155.89 (-1.33)          What You Wish For (WYWF) 99341 0.82 (-0.04)          Animal Friends (ANFRN) 115155 55.48 (+2.34)          Animal Friends (ANFRN) 150000 55.48 (+2.34)          What You Wish For (WYWF) 50000 0.82 (-0.04)          They Listen (THEYL) 150000 29.25 (+1.64)          Liam Neeson (LNEES) 25000 6.19 (-0.10)          The Chronicles of Narnia (NARN4) 150000 1.08 (+0.05)          David (DAVID) 15331 88.67 (-0.15)          Mads Mikkelsen (MMIKK) 25000 54.48 (-0.33)          Free Agents (FREAG) 100000 2.80 (+0.01)          Challengers (CHALN) 40 40.56 (+1.46)          They Listen (THEYL) 134181 29.25 (+1.64)          Challengers (CHALN) 38 40.56 (+1.46)          The Chronicles of Narnia (NARN4) 150000 1.08 (+0.05)          The Giant's House (TGNTH) 40000 7.18 (+0.01)