HSX Forum

Movies

I don't see a double standard at all. There's a difference between criticising art and criticising values.

Posted by: RogerMore on Oct 27, 22:40 in response to accountant_4_Jesus' post I wasn't deliberately talking about tolerance, more...

The people who are criticising Shame are doing so because they disagree with its perceived values. They think it is pornographic and immoral and they want it not to be released.

The people who criticise Courageous mostly think the movie is trite, predictable and feeds its target audience exactly what it wants.  There's nothing wrong with that - plenty of movies do the same, and are successful doing it - like The Smurfs, or Cars 2, or The Zookeeper.  Maybe even the upcoming Jack and Jill.  But for me - I really don't see a lot of difference between the disregard for those movies, and the disregard for "Christian movies".

To get a better idea of what I'm saying in this last para, you should have a look at this article "Why Do Heathens Make The Best Christian Films?", which talks about the differences between Christian-themed films made for the mainstream audience and movies made especially for the Christian market.

http://www.catholiceducation.org/articles/arts/al0294.htm

movieguide.org ask Christians to establish a petition to ask Fox Searchlight to not release SHAME Peterlee Oct 27, 17:33

I guess more conservative groups will try to fight against SHAME and NC-17 rating, because SHAME has real chance to help NC-17 to break out {nm} Peterlee Oct 27, 17:37

if you dont like the movie, dont go see it. They probably havent even seen the movie {nm} Moviesnob Oct 27, 17:47

Indeed. {nm} Ruthian23 Oct 27, 17:50

They would never see it, but they would still try to protest it (and NC-17)..... {nm} Peterlee Oct 27, 17:50

I like how the article mentions COURAGEOUS but doesn't say how the filmmakers use their films & message to exploit free labor and talent. {nm} skamanfu Oct 27, 17:59

That's actually called volunteer work. accountant_4_Jesus Oct 27, 19:15

Their description of Black Swan is hilarious {nm} Andre C Oct 27, 18:03

I love that they're directing the petition at Murdoch. I think he's a little occupied these days. {nm} Ruthian23 Oct 27, 18:06

Personally, if I was living in the US, I'm not sure whether or not I would sign that petition. accountant_4_Jesus Oct 27, 18:07

If you don't want to support the movie, then don't see it. Pretty simple. {nm} stevie1der328 Oct 27, 19:11

Yes, I know that, but it does sound like a double standard is being upheld here (on both sides)... accountant_4_Jesus Oct 27, 19:22

The difference here is no one is sending around a petition to pull Courageous from theaters. {nm} stevie1der328 Oct 27, 19:27

You do have a point there. {nm} accountant_4_Jesus Oct 27, 19:29

But I agree with your larger point, the world needs more tolerance from all places. {nm} stevie1der328 Oct 27, 20:14

I wasn't deliberately talking about tolerance, more consistency in the application of each person's thoughts/beliefs. accountant_4_Jesus Oct 27, 20:44

I don't see a double standard at all. There's a difference between criticising art and criticising values. RogerMore Oct 27, 22:40

Thanks for that article, Roger. accountant_4_Jesus Oct 28, 00:45

Another area where people can't decide for themselves. {nm} grammar Oct 27, 19:03

Sigh. It's called "bullying," even if it's done by the members of a large book club. {nm} second gary Oct 27, 19:19

So there are no sex-addicted Christians? {nm} TheWeekendWarrior Oct 27, 22:17

You'd be surprised how many there are, actually. It's just not publicised much, because people are ashamed to admit it. accountant_4_Jesus Oct 27, 23:50

Absolutely ridiculous. If you don't like a movie, don't watc it. Don't impose your views on others. Disgraceful {nm} numbersix_99 Oct 28, 00:55

Go on! Hope the petition works in this case {nm} HarryWarden Oct 28, 08:15





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


The Fall Guy (FALGY) 7600 95.35 (-0.71)          Spaceman (SPACM) 150000 0.04 (-0.02)          Young Woman and the Sea (YWATS) 149999 15.16 (-0.36)          Young Woman and the Sea (YWATS) 149999 15.16 (-0.36)          28 Years Later (28LT3) 150000 53.45 (+0.46)          Nick Offerman (NOFFE) 25000 48.99 (+0.34)          Nick Offerman (NOFFE) 25000 48.99 (+0.34)          Kingdom of the Planet of the Ape (APES4) 25000 140.29 (+4.66)          IF (IMGNF) 50 147.11 (-0.95)          Treasure (TRESU) 150000 3.72 (+0.38)          Despicable Me 4 (DESM4) 150000 236.57 (+1.65)          Deadpool & Wolverine (DEAD3) 50 391.50 (+0.84)          Jesse Plemons (JPLEM) 25000 52.61 (-0.25)          Jesse Plemons (JPLEM) 25000 52.61 (-0.25)          Jermaine Fowler (JFOWL) 25000 12.10 (+0.27)          Jermaine Fowler (JFOWL) 25000 12.10 (+0.27)          Jaeden Martell (JALIE) 20000 125.98 (+0.62)          Jaeden Martell (JALIE) 25000 125.98 (+0.62)          Amy Schumer (ASCHU) 10 68.97 (0.00)          Til Schweiger (TSCHW) 25000 16.87 (-1.09)          Griffin in Summer (GRIFS) 5024 2.00 (0.00)          Riley Keough (RKEOU) 25000 2.78 (-0.13)          The Legend of Zelda (ZELDA) 50 116.84 (+2.59)          Orlando Bloom (OBLOO) 25000 106.26 (-1.36)          Orlando Bloom (OBLOO) 20000 106.26 (-1.36)          Mufasa: The Lion King (LION2) 1 299.69 (+0.54)          Kirsten Dunst (KDUNS) 25000 49.13 (+0.31)          Kingdom of the Planet of the Ape (APES4) 3000 140.29 (+4.66)          Matthew Goode (MTGOO) 5000 19.99 (-1.12)          Kingdom of the Planet of the Ape (APES4) 10000 140.29 (+4.66)          Henry Golding (HGOLD) 25000 44.24 (-1.07)          Nicolas Cage (NCAGE) 25000 4.82 (-2.08)          The Legend of Zelda (ZELDA) 30000 116.84 (+2.59)          Kingdom of the Planet of the Ape (APES4) 150000 140.29 (+4.66)          Barry Pepper (BPEPP) 20000 23.16 (-1.17)          Michael Fassbender (MFASS) 20 33.04 (0.00)          My Penguin Friend aka The Pengui (TPATF) 149999 3.96 (+0.27)          Barry Pepper (BPEPP) 20000 23.16 (-1.17)          My Penguin Friend aka The Pengui (TPATF) 150000 3.96 (+0.27)          Fast X Part 2 aka Fast & Furious (FAF11) 10000 143.26 (+3.85)          Barry Pepper (BPEPP) 25000 23.16 (-1.17)          Materialists (MTRLS) 149999 16.51 (+0.47)          Wagner Moura (WMOUR) 25000 68.12 (+5.63)          Kingdom of the Planet of the Ape (APES4) 150000 140.29 (+4.66)          Sonic the Hedgehog 3 (SONC3) 1 138.78 (+0.44)          Cheech Marin (CMARI) 25000 80.76 (-0.13)          The Fall Guy (FALGY) 9532 95.35 (-0.71)          My Penguin Friend aka The Pengui (TPATF) 150000 3.96 (+0.27)          My Penguin Friend aka The Pengui (TPATF) 150000 3.96 (+0.27)          The Batman: Part II (TBAT2) 99 253.54 (+3.99)