HSX Forum

TVStocks, MusicStocks and Life

I think it's change in policing that will be a lot more effective.

Posted by: RogerMore on Mar 23, 05:11 in response to JDolphin's post Yes, he shouldn't have to die for that, but he shouldn't...

The "community needs to take responsibility" means that onus is put on a large group of people who don't really have much of an organization beyond all living in the same part of town. And things like "better parenting" will take a generation, and aren't really enforceable. It's a bunch of individuals without a structure. Contrast that with what the police - a more organized group with a defined purpose, a chain of command, internal administration, training systems, etc. it's going to be easier to change policing, and it will be more successful in building trust and breaking the cycle in years, not generations.

I brought up the traffic ticketing because even though you think it is petty, it is also a reason why the police aren't trusted and can't make headway in solving more serious crimes. If the police can't be trusted to dispense justice at the trafficticket level, how can you trust them on serious crimes? It's like the broken windows theory, but in reverse.

And I brought up easy examples of wrongful death because it shows that the victims are not criminals, but often ordinary people going about living their lives. And even though these are easy examples, AFAIK none of the police involved have faced criminal penalties, which you'd think would occur. Because they're easy examples. And that perceived lack of accountability doesn't build trust either. It looks more like people protecting their own than a system that provides justice for all.

And it's not just that people won't talk to police because they don't trust them, it's because they don't believe they'll catch the people responsible, and that they'll be threatened with violence or maybe death if they do, and the police won't be there to help them when that happens either.

Finally it's the police who are empowered to use force legally, so it's really on them to ensure that it is used for the right reasons. 

FWIW I live in a big city - maybe a little bigger than the St Louis area. Shootings do happen here, including occasionally shootings by police. But the homicide rate is a lot lower here and far fewer people are shot by police. And that is due in part to better policing - which in turn gives parent a better chance to raise children and communities here breathing space to do the sorts of things you are suggesting.

Washington Post Fact Checker: "Hands up, don't shoot" did not happen in Ferguson edzep - Port Monkey! Mar 22, 06:32

yes, not putting your hands up is a free pass for the cop to shoot you unarmed {nm} professor smartbrain Mar 22, 10:38

'Unarmed' is not relevant when you've gone from robbing a liquor store, to attacking a cop in his car. {nm} edzep - Port Monkey! Mar 22, 11:55

it's totally relevant when you're 150 feet away from the cop when he shoots you {nm} professor smartbrain Mar 22, 14:59

The Justice Dept. report disagrees with you. edzep - Port Monkey! Mar 22, 15:45

yes the law is overwhelmingly in the favor of police shooting first and asking no questions later {nm} professor smartbrain Mar 22, 19:01

It's been a while, so I don't have a link handy, but he was alot closer than 150 ft. I think less than 50 - maybe as little as 20 feet. At JDolphin Mar 22, 16:37

well that's much better. 20 feet = fire away {nm} professor smartbrain Mar 22, 18:58

So if a 6'2"+, 240lb guy that you've already tussled with and you don't know if he's armed comes at you - what do you do - you have 4 sec to JDolphin Mar 22, 20:00

You Unload the Entire Clip on the Sucker .... unless it is a White Guy, then You use Non-Lethal Means. Ferguson Mayor James Knowles III Mar 22, 22:10

Which actually happened to the neo-Nazi who went on a shooting rampage in Arizona and killed one. {nm} Antibody Mar 23, 11:35

At 20 feet you don't have 4 seconds to decide, much closer to 0.4 seconds to decide AND act. {nm} DTravel Mar 22, 22:39

Thanks - I was being generous. That was the police point. And I stil haven't heard what non-lethal means anyone would use {nm} JDolphin Mar 22, 23:09

They don't call that class of weapon "non-lethal". They are "less lethal" (rubber bullets, tasers, beanbag rounds, etc.) DTravel Mar 23, 12:59

Might be new for the rest of the country - but in St Louis, we knew that false a week or two after it happened {nm} JDolphin Mar 22, 12:24

And that report came out 3 weeks ago. {nm} JDolphin Mar 22, 12:28

oops meant to include the link to the actual report JDolphin Mar 22, 12:29

It's still irrelevant to the main point. {nm} RogerMore Mar 22, 16:56

Which main point is that? {nm} JDolphin Mar 22, 17:04

That too many people die from police action, and that the victims are disproportionately African-American. RogerMore Mar 22, 19:46

Okay - I thought this was about the Hands Up part which was false but continually gets perpetuated {nm} JDolphin Mar 22, 19:56

No, I'm just saying it's irrelevant. RogerMore Mar 22, 20:24

What injustice? That the person that robbed a store, then tried to take away a policeman's gun was killed. That's perpetuating that lie {nm} JDolphin Mar 22, 20:35

I'm sorry he died but he brought it on himself. {nm} JDolphin Mar 22, 20:36

There's the immediate injustice that a person shouldn't die for what he did. RogerMore Mar 22, 21:26

Should the officer die for what the robber did? Are the police allowed to defend their own lives, even if the only way to do so is to kill? {nm} DTravel Mar 22, 22:42

Just one of many, how is this not an EXECUTION? RotoHockeyYTD2013MainPort Mar 22, 23:06

I don't think it's as simple as that. You have to look at ways to change things so confrontations like this don't become life and death. RogerMore Mar 23, 04:18

Police have the authority, but the power to make if life-and-death exists on both "sides". DTravel Mar 23, 13:12

By power I mean `legitimate power` {nm} RogerMore Mar 23, 14:39

(sfek - and that legitimate power means greater obligation. Plus, see my post below for why I think change in policing is the more effective RogerMore Mar 23, 14:40

Yes, he shouldn't have to die for that, but he shouldn't have put himself in that position. And yes the community does have to take JDolphin Mar 22, 23:05

I think it's change in policing that will be a lot more effective. RogerMore Mar 23, 05:11

You're Blaming the Victim. Try this - Make Body-Worn Cameras on Police Mandatory - Reduces Use-Of-Force. RotoHockeyYTD2013MainPort Mar 23, 05:55

Yes and that's sad, but his problems like many start with no decent parental figures. I live in St Louis, 10 miles from Ferguson and his JDolphin Mar 22, 20:26





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


Unsung Hero (UNSUN) 150000 21.94 (-0.12)          Dreams (DREMS) 100000 4.99 (-0.03)          Blue Lock The Movie - Episode Na (BLULK) 150000 13.84 (+0.85)          Blue Lock The Movie - Episode Na (BLULK) 150000 13.84 (+0.85)          Fall 2 (FALL2) 150000 6.78 (-0.05)          In the Blink of An Eye (IBOAE) 20000 10.41 (+0.41)          Jay Baruchel (JBARU) 25000 75.96 (-0.25)          In the Blink of An Eye (IBOAE) 55555 10.41 (+0.41)          Untitled Alejandro Gonzalez Inar (UAGIP) 100000 64.39 (+0.35)          Aang: The Last Airbender (ATLA1) 20000 43.42 (-0.37)          Aang: The Last Airbender (ATLA1) 100000 43.42 (-0.37)          Apartment 7A (APT7A) 150000 7.03 (-0.14)          Humane (HUMNE) 150000 0.66 (-0.02)          In the Blink of An Eye (IBOAE) 10000 10.41 (+0.41)          The Movie Critic (TMOVC) 55000 33.26 (+0.12)          Untitled Alejandro Gonzalez Inar (UAGIP) 1000 64.39 (+0.35)          The Movie Critic (TMOVC) 150000 33.26 (+0.12)          Bridget Jones: Mad About the Boy (BJON4) 150000 8.72 (+0.01)          Unsung Hero (UNSUN) 10000 21.94 (-0.12)          Unsung Hero (UNSUN) 150000 21.94 (-0.12)          Untitled Alejandro Gonzalez Inar (UAGIP) 36857 64.39 (+0.35)          The Fall Guy (FALGY) 19999 117.19 (+0.37)          In the Blink of An Eye (IBOAE) 1 10.41 (+0.41)          Untitled Alejandro Gonzalez Inar (UAGIP) 10000 64.39 (+0.35)          In the Blink of An Eye (IBOAE) 10000 10.41 (+0.41)          Challengers (CHALN) 40000 39.10 (-0.17)          Challengers (CHALN) 15000 39.10 (-0.17)          Freaky Friday 2 (FREK2) 60000 54.84 (+0.06)          Blue Lock The Movie - Episode Na (BLULK) 150000 13.84 (+0.85)          The Fall Guy (FALGY) 25000 117.19 (+0.37)          Blue Lock The Movie - Episode Na (BLULK) 150000 13.84 (+0.85)          Jak and Daxter (JADAX) 150000 13.05 (+0.78)          The Fall Guy (FALGY) 20000 117.19 (+0.37)          Jak and Daxter (JADAX) 150000 13.05 (+0.78)          The Crow (TCROW) 50000 23.37 (-0.06)          The Crow (TCROW) 20000 23.37 (-0.06)          Challengers (CHALN) 20000 39.10 (-0.17)          Pirates of the Caribbean 6 (PIRT6) 1477 45.58 (0.00)          The Fall Guy (FALGY) 25000 117.19 (+0.37)          The Fall Guy (FALGY) 15000 117.19 (+0.37)          Challengers (CHALN) 9000 39.10 (-0.17)          Challengers (CHALN) 25000 39.10 (-0.17)          In the Blink of An Eye (IBOAE) 20000 10.41 (+0.41)          East Bay (EASTB) 150000 0.73 (-0.02)          In the Blink of An Eye (IBOAE) 150000 10.41 (+0.41)          Separate Rooms (SEPRM) 150000 5.61 (-0.05)          Untitled Alejandro Gonzalez Inar (UAGIP) 150000 64.39 (+0.35)          Untitled Alejandro Gonzalez Inar (UAGIP) 150000 64.39 (+0.35)          Apartment 7A (APT7A) 150000 7.03 (-0.14)          In the Blink of An Eye (IBOAE) 99800 10.41 (+0.41)