HSX Forum

Movies

I think the issue is the various problems with the verdict and the victim...

Posted by: numbersix_99 on Aug 24, 01:33 in response to DTshakes' post I'm new to the story but wasn't he acquitted in 2001?...

... who committed suicide several years ago and who the family have claimed her mental health deteriorated after the verdict of the case. Plus the film's co-writer was convicted of rape but appealed and won becaue the victim did not want to go through the whole ordeal again. Deadline posted transcripts of a phone call between Parker and the victim that's pretty incriminating, but Parker got off becaue he had sexual relations with the victim prior to the night in question. Which makes little sense.

Ā 

Anyway, it's all up for debate but basically there are many who feel the result of the case wasn't real justice, and that's impacting on people's opinion of both Parker and the film.

V: Some prominent members of black Hollywood are standing with Nate Parker, but they haven't backed him publicly yet. Peterlee Aug 23, 19:18

CNN: Harvey Weinstein defends "Birth of a Nation'" director as a 'good person' amid backlash Peterlee Aug 23, 19:42

Harvey Weinstein is not someone I would want backing me in that kind of situation. {nm} DTravel Aug 24, 09:42

Fox has started their national tv campaign for Birth of a Nation with the Oct 7th date {nm} notfabio Aug 23, 19:49

Why does Hollywood feel rape is no big deal? Not trolling, legitimately asking. {nm} Bubba_Fett Aug 23, 20:37

Who stated that "Hollywood" feels that rape is no bid deal?! {nm} DTshakes Aug 23, 22:52

I don't think it's a matter of "no big deal" as much as it is a complex issue for some to navigate. Some ideas inside: RogerMore Aug 24, 06:26

I'm new to the story but wasn't he acquitted in 2001? Isn't that the definition of having his day in court? DTshakes Aug 23, 22:51

yes, and yes {nm} slipping jimmy Aug 23, 23:10

I think the issue is the various problems with the verdict and the victim... numbersix_99 Aug 24, 01:33

Actually the sexual relations prior likely got him off with reasonable doubt... TwoMisfits Aug 24, 05:50

Acquitted when date rape was barely acknowledged as a crime. {nm} leo21 Aug 24, 06:02

bull****. "date rape" has been acknowledged since the 80s. {nm} slipping jimmy Aug 24, 08:39

And still about as impossible to convict on - the "technicality" that got the 1st conviction thrown out was "inefficient counsel" TwoMisfits Aug 24, 10:04

the rules of evidence and the Constitution are not "technicalities." and unless one of us was on the jury (i wasn't) none of us know exactly slipping jimmy Aug 24, 10:29

Rules of evidence vary by states - in some states, those phone calls would have been admissable - and in all states, they tell us the truth. TwoMisfits Aug 24, 10:40

Well rape isn't exactly a public endeavor--and we know "gentle, nice" public personas can have closets with skeletons. {nm} chosenone2oo5 Aug 24, 09:05

it's not a skeleton in a closet. it was on his own wikipedia page {nm} slipping jimmy Aug 24, 09:07

Look again at Wiki - that was all edited and added this month... {nm} TwoMisfits Aug 24, 09:33

The Wayback Machine's archived page (from April 2016) mentions it. (No doubt the page has been edited since) RogerMore Aug 24, 09:47

Yeah, look at the difference - night and day...one sounds like the victim falsely accused him - now, we know better... TwoMisfits Aug 24, 09:50

Ah OK, I thought you meant that the incident wasn't referred to at all. {nm} RogerMore Aug 24, 10:11

No - one way it was 2 sentences that made it sound like a false accusation... TwoMisfits Aug 24, 10:16

I was coming at it from the "Fox was surprised even though it was on wiki" angle. {nm} RogerMore Aug 24, 10:37

The Devil was in the details... Used2BeTwitterFamous Aug 24, 11:05





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


Lips Like Sugar (LIPLS) 150000 11.52 (-0.42)          Challengers (CHALN) 296 40.16 (0.00)          Anora (ANORA) 75000 3.81 (-0.01)          The Fall Guy (FALGY) 10000 119.61 (-0.87)          Boy Kills World (BOYKW) 149999 8.15 (-0.13)          28 Years Later (28LT3) 5000 52.92 (+0.05)          The Forge (TFORG) 2500 17.79 (+0.11)          Longlegs (LNLEG) 2500 9.67 (+0.15)          Maria (MARIA) 2500 13.66 (+0.19)          Weapons (WEPNS) 2500 22.05 (+0.29)          Trap House (TRAPH) 2500 22.79 (+0.33)          Last Breath (LBRTH) 2500 11.48 (+0.38)          Boy Kills World (BOYKW) 5000 8.15 (-0.13)          Lips Like Sugar (LIPLS) 5000 11.52 (-0.42)          Apartment 7A (APT7A) 5000 7.87 (-0.21)          Madden (MADEN) 5000 30.80 (+0.17)          The Fall Guy (FALGY) 75000 119.61 (-0.87)          The Fall Guy (FALGY) 2500 119.61 (-0.87)          The Fall Guy (FALGY) 12500 119.61 (-0.87)          Monkey Man (MNKYM) 1 23.30 (+0.06)          Monkey Man (MNKYM) 50000 23.30 (+0.06)          Monkey Man (MNKYM) 50000 23.30 (+0.06)          Monkey Man (MNKYM) 50000 23.30 (+0.06)          Fred Hechinger (FHECH) 25000 32.46 (-0.25)          Fred Hechinger (FHECH) 25000 32.46 (-0.25)          Nonnas (NONAS) 20000 8.79 (+0.01)          Julianne Nicholson (JUNIC) 25000 7.55 (+0.05)          Maya Hawke (MHAWK) 25000 55.40 (+0.16)          Ariana DeBose (ADEBO) 25000 31.76 (-0.25)          The Phoenician Scheme (TPSCH) 26000 20.72 (+0.01)          Ariana DeBose (ADEBO) 25000 31.76 (-0.25)          Alex Garland (AGARL) 25000 32.02 (-0.12)          Perfect Days (PRFCD) 49999 3.56 (+0.03)          My Ex-Friend's Wedding (MEXFW) 26000 22.37 (+0.01)          Octavia Spencer (OSPEN) 25000 38.92 (+0.12)          Perfect Days (PRFCD) 50000 3.56 (+0.03)          Perfect Days (PRFCD) 50000 3.56 (+0.03)          Perfect Days (PRFCD) 50000 3.56 (+0.03)          Jason Schwartzman (JSCHW) 25000 81.51 (+0.25)          Ben Wang (BWANG) 25000 26.10 (+0.12)          Diego Calva (DCALV) 25000 6.04 (+0.05)          Russell Crowe (RCROW) 25000 61.96 (-0.50)          The Bride! (BRIDE) 30000 64.31 (+0.08)          Russell Crowe (RCROW) 25000 61.96 (-0.50)          Addison Rae (ARAE) 25000 22.45 (+0.12)          The Exorcism (TGTWP) 150000 1.59 (+0.02)          Spider-Man Untitled (SPID9) 1400 314.99 (-0.25)          Kiki Layne (KLAYN) 25000 23.53 (-0.25)          Kiki Layne (KLAYN) 25000 23.53 (-0.25)          Danny Ramirez (DARAM) 25000 97.51 (-0.25)