HSX Forum

Movies

"Snowpiercer" is getting much better critical reception than "Sunshine". But it is true that original Sci-fi film is always not a easy sell {nm}

Posted by: Peterlee (a.k.a Peterlee (from past)) on Jul 19, 09:03 in response to lobogotti's post by the way, Sunshine is a great example of a solid film,...

rented Snowpiercer through iTunes and watched in my hotel last night on my iPad mini just fine. Great film indeed. lobogotti Jul 18, 19:21

I suppose it's disappointing for strong partisans of the movie to see its cast and crew accomplish its work with imagination. . . second gary Jul 18, 20:06

District 9 is a great comparison for sci-fi, the others though no one knew ahead would balloon gross, but I can see how and why they did lobogotti Jul 18, 20:10

heretic! BURN HIM!! {nm} charlie Jul 18, 21:49

there are so many factors in play with this movie. very complex. and new models are hard for people to accept. Moviesnob Jul 19, 02:51

Screen count changes really threw the stock into ups and down. {nm} mishra Jul 19, 06:44

well said and agreed on Peterlee. {nm} lobogotti Jul 19, 06:48

by the way, Sunshine is a great example of a solid film, solid director, original concept, sci-fi and also has Chris Evans that lobogotti Jul 19, 06:54

"Snowpiercer" is getting much better critical reception than "Sunshine". But it is true that original Sci-fi film is always not a easy sell Peterlee Jul 19, 09:03

I guess Harvey expected "Snowpiercer" to receive mixed reviews; but critical reception is really hard to predict {nm} Peterlee Jul 19, 09:06

ie. "The Quiet American" didn't test well, and Harvey had decided to send that film straight-to-video Peterlee Jul 19, 09:11

Respect Harvey. He's a genius. {nm} goodvibe61 Jul 19, 13:36

part of the reason its getting such great reviews is a reaction to Harvey's threats to cut it. {nm} Moviesnob Jul 19, 11:20

Really? After seeing the movie multiple times, you think that why critics give it a positive review? {nm} goodvibe61 Jul 19, 13:37

some critics like making those kinds of statements, yes {nm} Moviesnob Jul 19, 13:42

Interesting to think about UNDSK as a comp to SNWPC (no spoilers) second gary Jul 19, 13:51

agreed, its been a great year so far. Although I didn't like Snowpiercer as much as some around here, it was pretty good. Under the Skin is Moviesnob Jul 19, 14:18

The "compassion" scene is gripping, and just amazing. And its ingredients are so few but perfectly done. {nm} second gary Jul 19, 17:34

The "compassion" scene is gripping, and just amazing. And its ingredients are so few but perfectly done. {nm} second gary Jul 19, 17:39

Thank you very much, Moviesnob and lobogotti! But i guess if I am a studio exec, I would be worse than Tom Rothman.... {nm} Peterlee Jul 19, 09:00

I think it's time for YOU to let this go lol. I'll play one last time on this. The most important aspect on this is NOT ... goodvibe61 Jul 19, 11:20

It's profitable for CJ cause Radius will be able to pay overages on it because its making money. Overages = profit for both radius and CJ. Moviesnob Jul 19, 11:34

BTW the industry definition for "wide theatrical release" is not the same as HSX's. {nm} Moviesnob Jul 19, 11:36

not really. I'd say maybe 600 screens. Otherwise, for Indies, people confuse "Nationwide" with Wide. goodvibe61 Jul 19, 14:22

you're wrong. its far less. {nm} Moviesnob Jul 19, 14:32

Let's see. Two weekends ago. July 4th weekend. I watched goodvibe61 Jul 19, 13:50

Great. Snowpiercer launched on VOD July 11th. Moviesnob Jul 19, 14:16

Even worse. That was last weekend, and certainly I'd remember seeing SOMETHING. ANYTHING. I saw nothing. ZERO. {nm} goodvibe61 Jul 19, 14:46

And about Bong being "extremely happy". He's ripped Weinstein on multiple occasions now, and has been furious with him for months. goodvibe61 Jul 19, 17:31

I got a chance to meet him again in austin recently. He was pretty happy about the current release strategy. {nm} Moviesnob Jul 19, 17:56

What's he supposed to do? It is what it is, and it'll all be over in a couple weeks anyway when it's gone from theaters. goodvibe61 Jul 19, 18:13





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


Kingdom of the Planet of the Ape (APES4) 600 147.13 (+4.89)          Long Day’s Journey Into Night (LDSJN) 10 1.03 (+0.06)          Cary Elwes (CELWE) 25000 40.03 (+2.76)          Love Me (LOVME) 2000 4.10 (+1.40)          Love Me (LOVME) 30800 4.10 (+1.40)          Kneecap (KNECP) 150000 3.20 (-0.03)          Love Me (LOVME) 1200 4.10 (+1.40)          Riff Raff (RIFRF) 2 10.51 (+2.58)          Didi (DIDI) 3 5.28 (+1.55)          Love Me (LOVME) 2 4.10 (+1.40)          Eiza Gonzalez (EGONZ) 25000 32.18 (-0.07)          Back to Black (BTBLK) 3 16.43 (-0.48)          Back to Black (BTBLK) 3 16.43 (-0.48)          Challengers (CHALN) 10 45.00 (-0.91)          I Used to be Funny (IUTBF) 10 0.33 (+0.01)          Guy Ritchie (GRITC) 25000 21.36 (-21.23)          Challengers (CHALN) 10 45.00 (-0.91)          Barry Pepper (BPEPP) 25000 19.52 (-2.19)          Asphalt City (BLKFL) 5 0.74 (+0.07)          Riff Raff (RIFRF) 150000 10.51 (+2.58)          Sam Neill (SNEIL) 148 80.93 (+1.14)          Didi (DIDI) 150000 5.28 (+1.55)          Andie MacDowell (AMACD) 25000 5.81 (-0.10)          Love Me (LOVME) 150000 4.10 (+1.40)          The Garfield Movie (GRFLD) 3 93.11 (+1.63)          Orlando Bloom (OBLOO) 147 93.42 (-6.78)          The Garfield Movie (GRFLD) 3 93.11 (+1.63)          Homestead (HMSTD) 1 14.75 (+0.23)          Didi (DIDI) 150000 5.28 (+1.55)          Riley Keough (RKEOU) 25000 1.60 (-0.91)          Kingdom of the Planet of the Ape (APES4) 150000 147.13 (+4.89)          Homestead (HMSTD) 150000 14.75 (+0.23)          Homestead (HMSTD) 149999 14.75 (+0.23)          The Fall Guy (FALGY) 150000 83.07 (-2.09)          Jeff Goldblum (JGOLD) 24853 67.10 (-0.65)          The Garfield Movie (GRFLD) 150000 93.11 (+1.63)          Companion (CMPAN) 50000 16.76 (+1.82)          Companion (CMPAN) 50000 16.76 (+1.82)          Wicked (WICKD) 150000 158.32 (-0.74)          Companion (CMPAN) 50000 16.76 (+1.82)          Problemista (PRBLM) 150000 2.38 (-0.01)          Bowen Yang (BYANG) 25000 36.10 (+1.10)          Bowen Yang (BYANG) 25000 36.10 (+1.10)          Henry Cavill (HCAVI) 25000 152.81 (+0.67)          Alex Pettyfer (APETT) 25000 54.91 (+0.28)          Henry Golding (HGOLD) 25000 34.56 (-6.50)          Alan Ritchson (ARITC) 25000 66.26 (-16.22)          Guy Ritchie (GRITC) 25000 21.36 (-21.23)          Challengers (CHALN) 150000 45.00 (-0.91)          Kathryn Newton (KNEWT) 25000 80.42 (+0.66)