HSX Forum

Movies

I guess Harvey expected "Snowpiercer" to receive mixed reviews; but critical reception is really hard to predict {nm}

Posted by: Peterlee (a.k.a Peterlee (from past)) on Jul 19, 09:06 in response to Peterlee's post "Snowpiercer" is getting much better critical...

rented Snowpiercer through iTunes and watched in my hotel last night on my iPad mini just fine. Great film indeed. lobogotti Jul 18, 19:21

I suppose it's disappointing for strong partisans of the movie to see its cast and crew accomplish its work with imagination. . . second gary Jul 18, 20:06

District 9 is a great comparison for sci-fi, the others though no one knew ahead would balloon gross, but I can see how and why they did lobogotti Jul 18, 20:10

heretic! BURN HIM!! {nm} charlie Jul 18, 21:49

there are so many factors in play with this movie. very complex. and new models are hard for people to accept. Moviesnob Jul 19, 02:51

Screen count changes really threw the stock into ups and down. {nm} mishra Jul 19, 06:44

well said and agreed on Peterlee. {nm} lobogotti Jul 19, 06:48

by the way, Sunshine is a great example of a solid film, solid director, original concept, sci-fi and also has Chris Evans that lobogotti Jul 19, 06:54

"Snowpiercer" is getting much better critical reception than "Sunshine". But it is true that original Sci-fi film is always not a easy sell {nm} Peterlee Jul 19, 09:03

I guess Harvey expected "Snowpiercer" to receive mixed reviews; but critical reception is really hard to predict Peterlee Jul 19, 09:06

ie. "The Quiet American" didn't test well, and Harvey had decided to send that film straight-to-video Peterlee Jul 19, 09:11

Respect Harvey. He's a genius. {nm} goodvibe61 Jul 19, 13:36

part of the reason its getting such great reviews is a reaction to Harvey's threats to cut it. {nm} Moviesnob Jul 19, 11:20

Really? After seeing the movie multiple times, you think that why critics give it a positive review? {nm} goodvibe61 Jul 19, 13:37

some critics like making those kinds of statements, yes {nm} Moviesnob Jul 19, 13:42

Interesting to think about UNDSK as a comp to SNWPC (no spoilers) second gary Jul 19, 13:51

agreed, its been a great year so far. Although I didn't like Snowpiercer as much as some around here, it was pretty good. Under the Skin is Moviesnob Jul 19, 14:18

The "compassion" scene is gripping, and just amazing. And its ingredients are so few but perfectly done. {nm} second gary Jul 19, 17:34

The "compassion" scene is gripping, and just amazing. And its ingredients are so few but perfectly done. {nm} second gary Jul 19, 17:39

Thank you very much, Moviesnob and lobogotti! But i guess if I am a studio exec, I would be worse than Tom Rothman.... {nm} Peterlee Jul 19, 09:00

I think it's time for YOU to let this go lol. I'll play one last time on this. The most important aspect on this is NOT ... goodvibe61 Jul 19, 11:20

It's profitable for CJ cause Radius will be able to pay overages on it because its making money. Overages = profit for both radius and CJ. Moviesnob Jul 19, 11:34

BTW the industry definition for "wide theatrical release" is not the same as HSX's. {nm} Moviesnob Jul 19, 11:36

not really. I'd say maybe 600 screens. Otherwise, for Indies, people confuse "Nationwide" with Wide. goodvibe61 Jul 19, 14:22

you're wrong. its far less. {nm} Moviesnob Jul 19, 14:32

Let's see. Two weekends ago. July 4th weekend. I watched goodvibe61 Jul 19, 13:50

Great. Snowpiercer launched on VOD July 11th. Moviesnob Jul 19, 14:16

Even worse. That was last weekend, and certainly I'd remember seeing SOMETHING. ANYTHING. I saw nothing. ZERO. {nm} goodvibe61 Jul 19, 14:46

And about Bong being "extremely happy". He's ripped Weinstein on multiple occasions now, and has been furious with him for months. goodvibe61 Jul 19, 17:31

I got a chance to meet him again in austin recently. He was pretty happy about the current release strategy. {nm} Moviesnob Jul 19, 17:56

What's he supposed to do? It is what it is, and it'll all be over in a couple weeks anyway when it's gone from theaters. goodvibe61 Jul 19, 18:13





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


Companion (CMPAN) 150000 15.57 (+0.63)          Kingdom of the Planet of the Ape (APES4) 150000 146.16 (+3.92)          Hero Fiennes Tiffin (HFTIF) 25000 18.53 (-0.07)          Guy Ritchie (GRITC) 25000 21.36 (-21.23)          Sesame Street (SESAM) 50000 3.30 (+0.03)          Til Schweiger (TSCHW) 25000 14.53 (-1.40)          Den of Thieves 2: Pantera (DENO2) 105556 9.42 (+0.12)          Inside Out 2 (INOU2) 20000 263.49 (+0.95)          Til Schweiger (TSCHW) 25000 14.53 (-1.40)          Nuremberg (NUREM) 150000 18.58 (-1.36)          Companion (CMPAN) 150000 15.57 (+0.63)          Henry Cavill (HCAVI) 25000 152.81 (+0.67)          The Entertainment System Is Down (TESID) 150000 20.53 (-0.15)          Hitpig (HITPG) 50000 4.94 (+3.73)          Hitpig (HITPG) 149999 4.94 (+3.73)          Sesame Street (SESAM) 1000 3.30 (+0.03)          Henry Cavill (HCAVI) 25000 152.81 (+0.67)          Mortal Kombat 2 (MKMB2) 150000 33.58 (+0.26)          Hero Fiennes Tiffin (HFTIF) 25000 18.53 (-0.07)          Henry Golding (HGOLD) 25000 34.56 (-6.50)          Flowervale Street (FLWVS) 500 43.41 (+0.16)          Eden aka Origin Of Species (OSPEC) 150000 23.84 (0.00)          Legally Blonde 3 (BLON3) 150000 17.25 (-0.86)          The Garfield Movie - Opening Wee (GRFLD.OW) 1 43.41 (+0.55)          Legally Blonde 3 (BLON3) 150000 17.25 (-0.86)          Til Schweiger (TSCHW) 25000 14.53 (-1.40)          Lily Gladstone (LGLAD) 25000 11.03 (+0.20)          Til Schweiger (TSCHW) 25000 14.53 (-1.40)          Wicked (WICKD) 99999 158.21 (-0.85)          Kathryn Newton (KNEWT) 25000 80.42 (+0.66)          Eiza Gonzalez (EGONZ) 5000 32.18 (-0.07)          Ready or Not 2 (RONO2) 20000 18.45 (+0.45)          The Memory Police (TMEMP) 150000 14.55 (+0.04)          Melissa Barrera (MBARR) 25000 48.89 (+0.08)          Ready or Not 2 (RONO2) 20000 18.45 (+0.45)          Riley Keough (RKEOU) 5000 1.60 (-0.91)          Matt Bettinelli-Olpin (MBETT) 25000 51.81 (-0.07)          Matthew Goode (MTGOO) 25000 13.14 (-4.36)          Cary Elwes (CELWE) 25000 40.03 (+2.76)          Weapons (WEPNS) 149999 24.92 (+0.12)          The Garfield Movie H$40 Call Fri (GRFLD.CA) 25000 3.04 (+0.09)          Orlando Bloom (OBLOO) 25000 93.42 (-6.78)          Josh Brolin (JBROL) 25000 126.28 (+1.33)          Matt Bettinelli-Olpin (MBETT) 25000 51.81 (-0.07)          Riley Keough (RKEOU) 25000 1.60 (-0.91)          The Garfield Movie H$40 Put Fri- (GRFLD.PU) 1 1.96 (-0.08)          Sam Neill (SNEIL) 25000 80.93 (+1.14)          Benedict Wong (BWONG) 25000 195.52 (-0.50)          Til Schweiger (TSCHW) 25000 14.53 (-1.40)          Companion (CMPAN) 150000 15.57 (+0.63)