HSX Forum

Movies

RT's critical consensus is very positive and its at 84% with 56 reviews in so far

Posted by: Moviesnob on Dec 13, 10:14 in response to numbersix_99's post Seem mixed-positive

"Rogue One draws deep on Star Wars mythology while breaking new narrative and aesthetic ground -- and suggesting a bright blockbuster future for the franchise."

Rogue One embargo just lifted, here come the reviews {nm} <font color="green">RHawk</font> Dec 13, 09:03

Seem mixed-positive {nm} numbersix_99 Dec 13, 09:21

RT's critical consensus is very positive and its at 84% with 56 reviews in so far Moviesnob Dec 13, 10:14

COLBT too, mostly negative. {nm} Antibody Dec 13, 09:44

I'm seeing ENTIRELY negative. People amazed that it even exists as it is {nm} PlayItAgainSam Dec 13, 10:07

84% on RT so far with 64 reviews in. {nm} Fechin Dec 13, 10:13

Dropping under 80% now - getting closer to Top Critic thoughts... {nm} TwoMisfits Dec 13, 10:24

DOOOM! {nm} slipping jimmy Dec 13, 10:26

It's currently around Revenge of the Sith RT's score which is more or less Return of the Jedi's score. {nm} notfabio Dec 13, 10:51

It'll take a few days to stabilize, but safely ahead of Episode I and II. {nm} notfabio Dec 13, 10:53

Some of ROTJedi reviews are from the re-release. Anything pre-internet or even pre-RT are not reliable IMO. {nm} Antibody Dec 13, 10:59

IMO, the more important message from the reviews is that it panders to fans and leaves non-fans in the dust. The fan base will see it as... PlayItAgainSam Dec 13, 11:07

Didn't I say that the last few weeks - that this will play like a supers movie?:)... {nm} TwoMisfits Dec 13, 11:18

The fanbase is $900M huge. {nm} Antibody Dec 13, 12:06

Yeah, but now drop kids 10 and under and spouses...and you drop a lot of potential money... {nm} TwoMisfits Dec 13, 12:08

Since you've turned it from a family movie to a fan movie - not the best move when families want to go to movies at Christmas... {nm} TwoMisfits Dec 13, 12:09

SW16 has the same rating as SATAR7. Parents will still be taking their young kids to SW16. {nm} Antibody Dec 13, 12:13

and I think little girls will eat it up...*pictures them running around saying "blahstah" and "who's with me?"* =P {nm} tealfan Dec 13, 12:23

Not as many...reviews have made it clear this is not a kid movie, like Star 7 was... TwoMisfits Dec 13, 12:34

scientific studies have proven conclusively that watching Rogue One cures all diseases known to mankind {nm} slipping jimmy Dec 13, 12:37

Parents aren't gonna read reviews. It's Star Wars. They're already familiar with its fantasy violence. {nm} Antibody Dec 13, 13:02

And you know this b/c? You should head over to the Disboards...some parents are refunding their opening night tickets right now... TwoMisfits Dec 13, 13:10

Confirmation bias is a hell of a drug. {nm} Dbot1800 Dec 13, 13:18

Because they've seen 8 Star Wars films and are okay with "laser blasts" and arms being chopped off. WARS is in the title. Antibody Dec 13, 13:21

Okay, I'll keep waiting for $200M+ floor and $900M for this movie that many have suggested - you've totally sold me:)... TwoMisfits Dec 13, 13:24

Has more than just that one person (forget who specifically ) said anything on this board about 200M being the floor? &bernou;ionic&Mscr;oron Dec 13, 13:30

Go back to Day 1 presales thread - it was insanity movie pumping... {nm} TwoMisfits Dec 13, 13:35

Day 1 after big presales data came out? Seems reasonable to react positively to that news. How about since then? ℬionicℳoron Dec 13, 13:39

Any taking them back? {nm} TwoMisfits Dec 13, 13:42

This is a back and forth Movie Discussion. Why are you taking it so personally? {nm} Antibody Dec 13, 13:33

I'm not - I'm pointing out data and getting it dismissed with "reasons"...so I won't point out more data... TwoMisfits Dec 13, 13:41

What data? You have "reasons" as well. {nm} Antibody Dec 13, 13:43





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


Constantine 2 (CNST2) 149999 33.96 (+0.13)          The Breadwinner (BREDW) 150000 26.33 (+0.90)          White Elephant (WELEP) 10000 18.00 (0.00)          The Breadwinner (BREDW) 150000 26.33 (+0.90)          Tony (TONY) 150000 14.23 (+1.29)          The Catch (TCATC) 48732 57.02 (+3.03)          Samo Lives (SAMOL) 150000 0.72 (-0.02)          Bear Country (BEARC) 150000 9.08 (-0.02)          Hokum (HOKUM) 149998 16.75 (+1.13)          White Elephant (WELEP) 150000 18.00 (0.00)          Bear Country (BEARC) 10000 9.08 (-0.02)          Hokum (HOKUM) 149998 16.75 (+1.13)          Tony (TONY) 150000 14.23 (+1.29)          Tower of Terror (TOWRT) 9999 11.59 (-0.02)          The Resurrection of the Christ: (RESU2) 5008 146.29 (+0.23)          Cut Off (CUTOF) 1 33.86 (-0.46)          Halle Bailey (HBAIL) 25000 85.14 (-0.75)          The Sheep Detectives (3BAGF) 149999 47.07 (-1.75)          Noomi Rapace (NRAPA) 25000 1.95 (+0.02)          Escape From New York (ESCNY) 150000 6.95 (-0.16)          Mortal Kombat II H$40 Call (MKMB2.CA) 25000 3.82 (+0.30)          Wonka 2 (WONK2) 40000 65.92 (-0.09)          Escape From New York (ESCNY) 150000 6.95 (-0.16)          Motor City (MTRCT) 31000 7.87 (+0.03)          The Sheep Detectives (3BAGF) 80000 47.07 (-1.75)          The Sheep Detectives (3BAGF) 40000 47.07 (-1.75)          Her Private Hell (HERPH) 31000 7.17 (+0.01)          Old Gold Mountain (OGMTN) 150000 13.13 (-0.08)          Barbie Ferreira (BFERR) 25000 41.26 (-0.50)          Old Gold Mountain (OGMTN) 50000 13.13 (-0.08)          Rapture (RAPTU) 6 1.73 (0.00)          The Furious (FURIS) 31000 6.17 (-0.02)          Star Wars: The Mandalorian and G (SWAR3) 3 200.20 (+0.31)          American Psycho (APSYC) 150000 19.34 (-0.18)          Them (THEM) 150000 43.18 (+3.18)          Star Wars: The Mandalorian and G (SWAR3) 3 200.20 (+0.31)          American Psycho (APSYC) 100000 19.34 (-0.18)          The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the (HGAM6) 3 176.17 (-0.15)          The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the (HGAM6) 3 176.17 (-0.15)          I Love Boosters (ILBOS) 31000 14.55 (-0.05)          Kristen Stewart (KSTEW) 25000 3.31 (0.00)          The Face of Horror (FCOHR) 1673 10.65 (0.00)          Attack of the 50 Foot Woman (A50FW) 100000 49.43 (-0.10)          In the Grey (NGREY) 30000 19.22 (+0.36)          The Resurrection of the Christ: (RESU2) 13652 146.29 (+0.23)          The Catch (TCATC) 5000 57.02 (+3.03)          The Wrong Girls (TWRNG) 10000 9.53 (+0.49)          Shrek 5 (SHRK5) 3112 233.59 (+0.34)          Good People Bad Things (GPBT) 1000 14.68 (+1.39)          Alia Shawkat (ASHAW) 25000 5.20 (+0.03)