HSX Forum

Movies

Not really. I read through the reviews. There was not one single gushing, raving review. Not one critic LOVED the movie.

Posted by: goodvibe61 on Oct 08, 12:51 in response to TheWeekendWarrior's post I'm sorry but that's bull****...57% on RT is just 3% away...

There wasn't anyone on there that considered it one of the better movies of the year, or a GREAT movie. The overall tone of the reviews, particularly the ones that are graded positive, are along the lines of grudingly accepting of the movie. 

Looking at the top critics, here are some of the first "positive" bites listed: 

Roeper: Thanks to an admittedly corny script, it's actually a winner by split decision.

Kennedy: it becomes increasingly easy to forgive its many nicks.

Long: It's a blast, mixes Rocky Xformers, etc. to great, if corny effect.

Covert: It's 10 % lovable hokum, 23 % sentimental drama...

Whitty: While the sappy drama pales next to the terrific Iron Giant...

Lacey: It borrows so much from other films that it might better be titled Reel Steal. 

 

Those are first half dozen reviews listed under "top " critics for this movie. Every one of those reviews are listed as "FRESH". 

OKAY....

Ides of March is 82% Fresh. Real Steel is 57% Rotten. Crap wins again. {nm} goodvibe61 Oct 08, 10:02

And will always win. It is the American Way. {nm} Latinman4747 Oct 08, 10:14

It isn't unique to America; the No. 1 films around the world each week, as well as the top international films ever, are not that different xiayun Oct 08, 16:27

How much did you actually think "Ides" would make? Its a political drama which will always are always, nominations > box office {nm} dioneta Oct 08, 10:50

pardon my grammar :) {nm} dioneta Oct 08, 10:51

I'm sorry but that's bull****...57% on RT is just 3% away from having a Fresh rating and that's a perfectly respectable percentage {nm} TheWeekendWarrior Oct 08, 11:05

Not really. I read through the reviews. There was not one single gushing, raving review. Not one critic LOVED the movie. goodvibe61 Oct 08, 12:51

And you've seen the movie yourself? Nope... thought not. {nm} TheWeekendWarrior Oct 08, 12:59

Seriously, the payout from Disney/DreamWorks must be pretty good these days P:) {nm} HarryWarden Oct 08, 13:12

Wow .. that's uncalled for ! Everyone is entitled to express their views. {nm} grammar Oct 08, 13:19

It was a joke or did you not notice the wink/tongue type {nm} HarryWarden Oct 08, 13:20

Nope .. I see a *P:) * and didn't have a clue what that was supposed to mean. {nm} grammar Oct 08, 13:22

It was not perfect grammar. {nm} damenchipguy Oct 08, 20:05

Hard to decipher sarcasm in print when the sentence begins with "seriously". So, are you serious or not? :()---/ {nm} Rocket Oct 09, 13:07

So; I saw both flicks this afternoon/evening at the Irvine Spectrum. goodvibe61 Oct 09, 01:51

Democracy at work srrichardson Oct 09, 02:04

+1 {nm} PRodQuanta Oct 09, 16:01

At 2200 theaters to 3400, where's the surprise? [RSTEL] is meant to make its $ up front ... jjmarino Oct 08, 12:16

Yes! I had 3-1 on Crap this week! Cha-Ching! wroberson Oct 08, 13:26

Movies are entertainment. Larger potential audience/broader appeal/more advertising=more $. {nm} forlorne Oct 08, 13:36

So the last eight weeks mean nothing to you? This is the first rotten #1 since Cowboys & Aliens {nm} tribefan695 Oct 08, 14:21

i only read the wikipedia entry on real steel, and even that was the worst thing i've ever read! i cant imagine going out to see it. {nm} David_Francis Oct 08, 20:56

Wikipedia is not a peer reviewed or credible source. Read more expert opinions... {nm} Rocket Oct 09, 13:05





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


Lilo & Stitch 2 (LILS2) 10000 272.17 (+0.25)          Midwinter Break (MIDWB) 150000 4.82 (+1.52)          Billy Magnussen (BMAGN) 20000 83.67 (+0.20)          Avengers: Secret Wars (AVNG6) 10000 460.12 (+0.52)          Emily Watson (EWATS) 24999 16.44 (-0.01)          Emily Watson (EWATS) 24999 16.44 (-0.01)          Untitled Event Film Directed By (SKIES) 10000 151.87 (+0.16)          Spaceballs 2 (SPCB2) 100 108.94 (+0.11)          The Beatles - A Four-Film Cinema (BEAT1) 15000 107.91 (+0.58)          Chiwetel Ejiofor (CEJIO) 24000 80.69 (+0.24)          Ebenezer: A Christmas Carol (EBNZR) 50000 64.29 (0.00)          Russell Crowe (RCROW) 24000 15.55 (+0.09)          Lilo & Stitch 2 (LILS2) 25000 272.17 (+0.25)          Lee Cronin's The Mummy (TMUMY) 150000 44.12 (-0.20)          Sydney Sweeney (SSWEE) 24000 30.09 (+0.12)          Midwinter Break (MIDWB) 100000 4.82 (+1.52)          June Squibb (JSQUI) 24000 57.86 (+0.16)          The Conjuring Prequel (CNJU5) 150000 82.05 (+1.09)          Elsie Fisher (EFISH) 24900 33.86 (+0.12)          Midwinter Break (MIDWB) 50000 4.82 (+1.52)          Rupert Friend (RFRIE) 24000 58.42 (-0.16)          Spider-Man: Brand New Day (SPID9) 526 422.01 (0.00)          Daniel Bruhl (DBRUH) 24900 16.69 (+0.09)          El Muerto (MUERT) 100000 5.07 (+0.01)          Diego Luna (DLUNA) 24000 29.92 (-0.01)          Constantine 2 (CNST2) 20000 43.81 (-0.23)          Avatar: Fire and Ash (AVAT3) 500 453.03 (-0.99)          Street Fighter (STFTR) 15000 67.16 (+0.43)          Hannah Waddingham (HWADD) 24000 131.52 (-0.32)          Avengers: Doomsday (AVNG5) 836 531.24 (+1.02)          Kate Mara (KMARA) 20000 9.86 (+0.04)          The Lord of the Rings: The Hunt (LOTR5) 5000 167.86 (-0.12)          Olivia Holt (OHOLT) 25000 12.76 (+0.10)          Eternity (ETERN) 150000 15.45 (-0.07)          Eternity (ETERN) 150000 15.45 (-0.07)          Michael Cera (MCERA) 24000 14.69 (+0.19)          Alone Together (ALTGT) 110000 4.50 (+0.64)          The Invite (TINVT) 50000 10.99 (+0.02)          The Invite (TINVT) 50000 10.99 (+0.02)          The Conjuring Prequel (CNJU5) 20000 82.05 (+1.09)          Constantine 2 (CNST2) 10000 43.81 (-0.23)          Avatar: Fire and Ash (AVAT3) 1000 453.03 (-0.99)          The Invite (TINVT) 50000 10.99 (+0.02)          The Invite (TINVT) 50000 10.99 (+0.02)          Constantine 2 (CNST2) 50000 43.81 (-0.23)          The Invite (TINVT) 50000 10.99 (+0.02)          The Invite (TINVT) 50000 10.99 (+0.02)          Whitney Peak (WPEAK) 25000 9.07 (+0.05)          Madden (MADEN) 25000 19.41 (-0.07)          Audition (AUDTN) 50000 4.91 (-0.01)