HSX Forum

Movies

I disgree. There is good movie logic (see Spider-Man 2 train scene) and bad movie logic (that WOLV2 train scene). {nm}

Posted by: Antibody on Jul 08, 17:55 in response to JDolphin's post There is scifi logic and then there is comic book...

This WOLV2 clip is ludricous. It's not physically possible to jump forward on a moving train. Antibody Jul 08, 17:11

Are you really looking for reality from a movie about a superhero that cannot be killed with magic retractable claws? {nm} dioneta Jul 08, 17:14

But can be killed with other types of retractable claws? {nm} RotoHockeyYTD2013 Jul 08, 17:21

Sure, when it comes to the laws of physics. {nm} Antibody Jul 08, 17:30

There are X-men that teleport, alter weather, etc..... Physics do not apply to Comic Books {nm} dioneta Jul 08, 17:45

There still must still be an consistent internal logic applied. That's the difference between good science-fiction, and bad sci-fi. {nm} Antibody Jul 08, 17:48

There is scifi logic and then there is comic book blockbuster logic {nm} JDolphin Jul 08, 17:51

I disgree. There is good movie logic (see Spider-Man 2 train scene) and bad movie logic (that WOLV2 train scene). Antibody Jul 08, 17:55

burden for willing suspension of disbelief is on the audience not the director. Its all subjective. {nm} Moviesnob Jul 08, 18:36

It's on the filmmakers. If they stretch the credibility too far, then they will lose a majority of the audience who won't enjoy and like it. {nm} Antibody Jul 08, 21:51

Everyone is eagerly anticipating your thoughts on movie Time-Travel. {nm} RotoHockeyYTD2013 Jul 08, 18:37

and faster than light speed travel {nm} forlorne Jul 08, 19:42

There are scientific theories for time travel and faster than light speed travel. {nm} Antibody Jul 08, 21:57

Oh sure - Amazingly, both of these will occur before You-Know-Who implements full Instant-Replay. {nm} RotoHockeyYTD2013 Jul 08, 22:41

Funny how there was a Quantum Leap from 'Physically Possible' to 'Scientific Theories'. {nm} RotoHockeyYTD2013 Jul 08, 22:43

You can establish "an internal movie logic". Wolverine has not established mutant power of super-speed that breaks the laws of physics. {nm} Antibody Jul 09, 09:56

Lol ! Thank you for that {nm} JMT-NL Jul 08, 21:24

directv cinem, order 2 xmen movies, get free ticket to wolverine {nm} islander Jul 08, 17:22

It reminds me of the schoolyard scene in the second Matrix film: concept A, execution F. {nm} second gary Jul 08, 17:37

Since he's a superhero I guess he can jump at a faster speed than the train is moving. {nm} taranev Jul 08, 18:35

Only impossible if the train is moving at the speed of light. On the other hand, sound does not travel in the vaccuum of space. Buy BONDS 20 Jul 08, 20:38

Every Marvel flick is ludicrous. Or, just about every big Hollywood flick is LUDICROUS. I don't think many people care much. {nm} goodvibe61 Jul 08, 21:42

If you are strong enough you can... bbb101 Jul 09, 10:31





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


The Catch (TCATC) 150000 50.00 (0.00)          The Amazing Digital Circus: The (AMZDC) 6666 19.03 (0.00)          Adam Scott (ASCOT) 25000 27.14 (+0.37)          Spider-Man: Brand New Day (SPID9) 150000 421.08 (-0.99)          The Odyssey (ODYSE) 149931 290.54 (+4.17)          Heart Eyes 2 (HRTE2) 150000 19.43 (+0.08)          Renny Harlin (RHARL) 25000 16.21 (+0.10)          The Devil Wears Prada 2 (PRAD2) 150000 216.96 (-5.87)          Woody Harrelson (WHARR) 25000 23.79 (-1.25)          The Catch (TCATC) 150000 50.00 (0.00)          Aaron Eckhart (AECKH) 25000 13.36 (-0.10)          The Catch (TCATC) 150000 50.00 (0.00)          The Devil Wears Prada 2 (PRAD2) 150000 216.96 (-5.87)          Woody Harrelson (WHARR) 25000 23.79 (-1.25)          Woody Harrelson (WHARR) 25000 23.79 (-1.25)          Colony (CLONY) 150000 2.05 (-0.10)          Kieran Culkin (KCULK) 25000 7.65 (-0.30)          Steve Buscemi (SBUSC) 25000 49.63 (-0.66)          The Catch (TCATC) 150000 50.00 (0.00)          Kieran Culkin (KCULK) 25000 7.65 (-0.30)          The Uprising aka The Hood (THOOD) 150000 7.65 (+0.01)          The Wrong Girls (TWRNG) 150000 9.31 (+0.01)          Rogue Trooper (RTROP) 150000 5.87 (+0.03)          Good People Bad Things (GPBT) 149999 13.21 (+0.15)          Rolling Loud (RLOUD) 150000 9.60 (+0.26)          Monopoly (MONOP) 150000 9.02 (+0.31)          Angel and the Badman (ANBAD) 149999 13.20 (+1.06)          Whalefall (WHALF) 10000 31.05 (+2.10)          Angel and the Badman (ANBAD) 10000 13.20 (+1.06)          Love Child (LOVCH) 149999 0.11 (+0.02)          Attack of the 50 Foot Woman (A50FW) 1000 49.76 (-0.30)          Tunnels (TUNLS) 149999 0.03 (-0.03)          Imelda Staunton (ISTAU) 12999 53.29 (+0.08)          Angel and the Badman (ANBAD) 1000 13.20 (+1.06)          Whalefall (WHALF) 4000 31.05 (+2.10)          Denzel Washington (DWASH) 4993 71.04 (+0.29)          Ethan Hawke (EHAWK) 25000 16.06 (+0.30)          Tim Blake Nelson (TBNEL) 25000 41.83 (-0.16)          Joe Alwyn (JALWY) 11999 10.63 (-0.04)          Seth Rogen (SROGE) 25000 127.46 (-0.66)          Seth Rogen (SROGE) 25000 127.46 (-0.66)          The Catch (TCATC) 100000 50.00 (0.00)          Robert Pattinson (RPATT) 25000 80.17 (0.00)          Mamoudou Athie (MATHI) 25000 96.19 (-1.24)          Mamoudou Athie (MATHI) 25000 96.19 (-1.24)          Keegan-Michael Key (KMKEY) 19999 149.31 (+0.07)          Angel and the Badman (ANBAD) 150000 13.20 (+1.06)          Angel and the Badman (ANBAD) 150000 13.20 (+1.06)          John Lithgow (JLITH) 25000 25.45 (+0.12)          Hokum (HOKUM) 150000 16.64 (+3.83)