HSX Forum

TVStocks, MusicStocks and Life

Frees up money to extend Scherzer after 2014 and do more beyond; Fielder's "body type" doesn't normally age well;

Posted by: Paul2k on Nov 20, 20:36 in response to Antibody's post Why is the Tigers trading Prince Fielder for Ian Kinsler?

the Tiger's infield defense improves by moving Cabrera to 1b, adding Kinsler over Infante at 2b, and possibly putting Castellanos (or someone else) at 3b. Kinsler's contract was frontloaded, so he gets paid less in the later years, giving the Tigers a little more financial flexibility. Fielder's contract would possibly look as bad as Ryan Howard's in Philly in a few years.

On Texas' end, Fielder's down 2013 may partially be due to his dealing with a divorce during the season. He could bounce back and have a few more beefy seasons left in his bat- 1B was pretty mediocre for them, and they need a big bopper with Cruz out as a free agent.

Why is the Tigers trading Prince Fielder for Ian Kinsler? Antibody Nov 20, 17:35

this seems reasonable as the reason. Moviesnob Nov 20, 17:41

I understand Texas, but are the Tigers that cash strapped? Fielder is in his prime at 29. {nm} Antibody Nov 20, 17:49

luxury tax is a ****. and Fielder isnt the most healthy guy in the world, hes not going to get better {nm} Moviesnob Nov 20, 17:49

Fielder has never been hurt, playing nearly 162 games every year. {nm} Antibody Nov 20, 17:54

I'm talking about his long term health related to his weight {nm} Moviesnob Nov 20, 17:56

yup at that weight, "roaring right back" will get harder every year {nm} islander Nov 20, 17:58

That might be true, however, he has NEVER been the DL. {nm} hankquinlan Nov 23, 14:07

could be great move by DET.get out of that contract while they can. Fielders stats dropped alot last year (avg, ob, slg, war) {nm} islander Nov 20, 17:47

He had an off year in 2010 and roar right back. {nm} Antibody Nov 20, 17:52

His Base-Running (term used loosely) made a number of Highlight Reels. {nm} RotoHockeyYTD2013 Nov 20, 18:57

I think the better question is why did Texas trade Kinsler for Fielder, Detroit got the better end of this trade. {nm} JDolphin Nov 20, 20:07

Texas also got $30 Million Cash. Yahoo Sports Link. RotoHockeyYTD2013 Nov 20, 20:23

that article doesn't say anything about Cash, but I missed that in the cbs sports link - immediate cash, long term debt {nm} JDolphin Nov 20, 20:33

Sure it does - check the second Tweet from Jeff Passan. {nm} RotoHockeyYTD2013 Nov 21, 06:28

Disagree. Kinsler is 32 and has had 2 down years in a row. As previously mentioned, Texas has Profar and Andrus. {nm} Antibody Nov 21, 10:14

Frees up money to extend Scherzer after 2014 and do more beyond; Fielder's "body type" doesn't normally age well; Paul2k Nov 20, 20:36

Fielder gets $24 per year until 2020; Kinsler gets $16m in 2014 and 2015, then $14m in 2016, $11m in 2017, and $12m team option 2018. Paul2k Nov 21, 09:07

They are roughly the same player, with slight edge to Fielder in OBP and OPS, big edge to Kinsler on SOs. Fielder forlorne Nov 21, 08:22

"Roughly the same player"? Do you mean WAR wise? Because they come to their WAR through very different means. {nm} Paul2k Nov 21, 09:10

You are right-to clarify, i meant overall offensive stats. {nm} forlorne Nov 25, 08:11





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


Scream 8 (SCRM8) 11111 67.32 (-0.16)          Sheep in the Box (SHPBX) 150000 0.84 (+0.01)          Breeder (BREDR) 150000 2.00 (0.00)          Sheep in the Box (SHPBX) 150000 0.84 (+0.01)          Sense and Sensibility (SNSNS) 77777 20.32 (-0.04)          Sgt. Rock (SGROC) 33333 20.22 (+0.05)          Snoop (SNOOP) 150000 22.75 (+1.41)          Breeder (BREDR) 150000 2.00 (0.00)          Saccharine (SCHRN) 77777 0.38 (-0.02)          Sacrifice (SCRIF) 44444 7.45 (-0.02)          Sam & Victor’s Day Off (SAVDO) 3333 6.72 (-0.01)          Breeder (BREDR) 150000 2.00 (0.00)          The Horror Fund X (SPOOK) 20000 40.06 (+0.20)          Homewrecker (HMWRC) 111 19.38 (-0.15)          Javier Bardem (JBARD) 25000 149.71 (+0.69)          Katy O'Brian (KOBRI) 25000 98.94 (-0.25)          Danielle Brooks (DBROO) 25000 108.49 (+1.00)          Craig Brewer (CBREW) 25000 26.96 (+0.37)          Rachel Brosnahan (RBROS) 25000 95.60 (0.00)          Eddie Murphy (EMURP) 25000 89.79 (+0.25)          Aunjanue Ellis-Taylor (AELLI) 25000 14.05 (-0.11)          Aunjanue Ellis-Taylor (AELLI) 25000 14.05 (-0.11)          Breeder (BREDR) 150000 2.00 (0.00)          Isabela Merced (IMONE) 25000 107.14 (+0.33)          The Angry Birds Movie 3 (ANGR3) 33333 39.87 (+0.03)          Snoop (SNOOP) 150000 22.75 (+1.41)          Snoop (SNOOP) 150000 22.75 (+1.41)          Doctor Strange 3 (DRST3) 10000 72.92 (-0.46)          Breeder (BREDR) 150000 2.00 (0.00)          Matthias Schoenaerts (MSCHO) 25000 18.32 (-2.99)          Matthias Schoenaerts (MSCHO) 25000 18.32 (-2.99)          Snoop (SNOOP) 150000 22.75 (+1.41)          Snoop (SNOOP) 150000 22.75 (+1.41)          Monitor (MONTR) 40000 9.89 (+0.36)          Snoop (SNOOP) 150000 22.75 (+1.41)          Snoop (SNOOP) 150000 22.75 (+1.41)          Snoop (SNOOP) 150000 22.75 (+1.41)          Denis Villeneuve (DVILL) 25000 138.77 (+0.66)          Scott Eastwood (SEAST) 25000 45.32 (-0.44)          Cheech Marin (CMARI) 25000 47.95 (-0.16)          Snoop (SNOOP) 150000 22.75 (+1.41)          Matthias Schoenaerts (MSCHO) 25000 18.32 (-2.99)          Snoop (SNOOP) 150000 22.75 (+1.41)          Snoop (SNOOP) 150000 22.75 (+1.41)          Emily Beecham (EBEEC) 25000 17.70 (-0.52)          The Brigands of Rattlecreek (BRGND) 150000 27.38 (-2.07)          Chase Sui Wonders (CSWON) 25000 17.01 (-0.10)          The Cat in the Hat (TCATH) 20000 92.16 (-1.29)          Other Mommy (IATHS) 150000 32.70 (+2.96)          Ocean's 14 (OCEN6) 20000 65.80 (-2.90)