HSX Forum

TVStocks, MusicStocks and Life

"Roughly the same player"? Do you mean WAR wise? Because they come to their WAR through very different means. {nm}

Posted by: Paul2k on Nov 21, 09:10 in response to forlorne's post They are roughly the same player, with slight edge to...

Why is the Tigers trading Prince Fielder for Ian Kinsler? Antibody Nov 20, 17:35

this seems reasonable as the reason. Moviesnob Nov 20, 17:41

I understand Texas, but are the Tigers that cash strapped? Fielder is in his prime at 29. {nm} Antibody Nov 20, 17:49

luxury tax is a ****. and Fielder isnt the most healthy guy in the world, hes not going to get better {nm} Moviesnob Nov 20, 17:49

Fielder has never been hurt, playing nearly 162 games every year. {nm} Antibody Nov 20, 17:54

I'm talking about his long term health related to his weight {nm} Moviesnob Nov 20, 17:56

yup at that weight, "roaring right back" will get harder every year {nm} islander Nov 20, 17:58

That might be true, however, he has NEVER been the DL. {nm} hankquinlan Nov 23, 14:07

could be great move by DET.get out of that contract while they can. Fielders stats dropped alot last year (avg, ob, slg, war) {nm} islander Nov 20, 17:47

He had an off year in 2010 and roar right back. {nm} Antibody Nov 20, 17:52

His Base-Running (term used loosely) made a number of Highlight Reels. {nm} RotoHockeyYTD2013 Nov 20, 18:57

I think the better question is why did Texas trade Kinsler for Fielder, Detroit got the better end of this trade. {nm} JDolphin Nov 20, 20:07

Texas also got $30 Million Cash. Yahoo Sports Link. RotoHockeyYTD2013 Nov 20, 20:23

that article doesn't say anything about Cash, but I missed that in the cbs sports link - immediate cash, long term debt {nm} JDolphin Nov 20, 20:33

Sure it does - check the second Tweet from Jeff Passan. {nm} RotoHockeyYTD2013 Nov 21, 06:28

Disagree. Kinsler is 32 and has had 2 down years in a row. As previously mentioned, Texas has Profar and Andrus. {nm} Antibody Nov 21, 10:14

Frees up money to extend Scherzer after 2014 and do more beyond; Fielder's "body type" doesn't normally age well; Paul2k Nov 20, 20:36

Fielder gets $24 per year until 2020; Kinsler gets $16m in 2014 and 2015, then $14m in 2016, $11m in 2017, and $12m team option 2018. Paul2k Nov 21, 09:07

They are roughly the same player, with slight edge to Fielder in OBP and OPS, big edge to Kinsler on SOs. Fielder forlorne Nov 21, 08:22

"Roughly the same player"? Do you mean WAR wise? Because they come to their WAR through very different means. Paul2k Nov 21, 09:10

You are right-to clarify, i meant overall offensive stats. {nm} forlorne Nov 25, 08:11





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


The New Simpsons Movie (SIMP2) 4 165.39 (-0.45)          Narcs (NARCS) 4 30.45 (+0.06)          A Quiet Place: Part III (AQPL4) 4 122.54 (+0.11)          Victorian Psycho (VPSYC) 1059 9.05 (-0.63)          A Minecraft Movie Squared (MINE2) 6 337.14 (+1.42)          Fake Skating (FKSKT) 135 15.69 (-0.05)          Crawl 2 (CRAW2) 8 17.42 (-0.08)          The Graveyard Book (GRVBK) 149994 0.07 (-0.01)          Man of Tomorrow (SPMOT) 6 271.84 (+1.01)          Oceans (OCEN5) 4 78.55 (-0.08)          Spider-Man: Beyond the Spider-Ve (ASPD3) 4 274.60 (+0.01)          How to Train Your Dragon 2 (HTTY2) 4 207.77 (+0.16)          Ebenezer (EBNZR) 49999 66.84 (-4.90)          Skeletons (SKLTN) 4 37.44 (-0.04)          Star Wars: Starfighter (SWAR4) 4 290.17 (+2.00)          Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Mu (TMNT4) 4 68.70 (+0.10)          Shiver (SHVER) 4 96.39 (-0.17)          Jason Statham Stole My Bike (JSSMB) 4 35.93 (0.00)          The Catch (TCATC) 4 82.10 (-0.16)          Anything But Ghosts (ANYBG) 4 35.58 (-0.08)          The Resurrection of the Christ (RESUR) 4 195.03 (+0.36)          Possession (PSESN) 4 43.13 (-0.10)          The Legend of Zelda (ZELDA) 4 244.37 (-0.84)          Bad Influence (BNFLU) 150000 10.00 (0.00)          Not Alone (NTALN) 4 127.47 (+0.24)          Monitor (MONTR) 4 11.01 (-0.02)          Panic Carefully (PNCRF) 4 28.18 (-0.03)          Boys For Life (BOYFL) 9 15.31 (+0.08)          Friday the 13th (FRI12) 150000 30.00 (0.00)          The Surgeon (SURGN) 4 13.13 (+0.02)          Friday the 13th (FRI12) 150000 30.00 (0.00)          Wind of Change (WNDOC) 15 3.10 (+0.03)          The Midnight Library (TMLIB) 149999 21.49 (-0.98)          Godzilla x Kong: Supernova (GOKO3) 4 165.00 (-0.33)          The Family Disappears (TFAMD) 149999 13.76 (+3.51)          Day Drinker (DRNKR) 4 21.58 (+0.02)          Sonic the Hedgehog 4 (SONC4) 4 166.26 (+0.23)          The Graveyard Book (GRVBK) 1 0.07 (-0.01)          The Exorcist: Martyrs (TEXO2) 4 61.14 (-0.02)          Gatto (GATTO) 6 146.24 (-0.55)          The Revenge of La Llorona (LORN2) 4 26.84 (-0.04)          K-Pop: The Debut (KPOPM) 7 38.65 (-0.16)          Wife and Dog (WIFDG) 4 17.13 (-0.02)          Preppy (PREPY) 150000 6.74 (+0.74)          In a Violent Nature 2 (IAVN2) 30 4.35 (-0.01)          Remain (REMAN) 4 68.27 (-0.06)          The Family Disappears (TFAMD) 150000 13.76 (+3.51)          Ice Age: Boiling Point (ICEA6) 4 98.80 (-0.25)          The Comeback King (CMBKN) 4 35.95 (-0.03)          Ice Age: Boiling Point (ICEA6) 4 98.80 (-0.25)