HSX Forum

TVStocks, MusicStocks and Life

RANDI: Dr. Stuart J. Robbins Discusses The Many Reasons To Be Skeptical Of Deathbed Confessions.

Posted by: Dr. Stuart J. Robbins (a.k.a RotoHockey2013MainPort) on Aug 30, 19:56 in response to Antibody's post No use arguing with a troll who think he's God and has...

http://doubtfulnews.com/2014/10/sad-that-disclosure-of-obviously-fake-aliens-is-the-last-thing-you-do/
http://web.randi.org/swift/bushmans-deathbed-confessions

Dr. Stuart Robbins discusses the many reasons to be skeptical of deathbed confessions.

A deathbed confession can also be a way to solidify one’s reputation by using the cultural belief in its veracity to double-down on the claim to increase general belief in it.

The thinking could easily be, “People really believe that people are 100% honest on their deathbed, so I’m going to make sure I go out with a ‘bang’ and make my claims yet again. People who didn’t believe me before might this time because they’ll think I’m telling the truth ’cause I’m about to die.”

That’s why I find this whole deathbed confession thing unconvincing and, perhaps more importantly, not useful: We have no more information than we had before. We have no way to verify any of the information claimed. No way to test or duplicate it. At *best*, we have another person claiming this stuff is real, and while he or she may be proven out with the passage of time, their “confession” contributed absolutely nothing to that advancement.





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


The Origin of the World (TOOTW) 150000 13.91 (-0.04)          Evil Dead Wrath (EVLD7) 25000 35.01 (+2.20)          Wild Horse Nine (WILDH) 50000 13.82 (+0.17)          The Sun Never Sets (TSNVS) 75000 0.44 (+0.01)          Wild Horse Nine (WILDH) 50000 13.82 (+0.17)          Wildwood (WILDW) 50000 38.33 (+0.59)          Ramayana (RAMAY) 150000 19.04 (+1.27)          Wild Horse Nine (WILDH) 50000 13.82 (+0.17)          Ramayana (RAMAY) 150000 19.04 (+1.27)          Wild Horse Nine (WILDH) 50000 13.82 (+0.17)          Ali G: Who Iz I? (ALIG2) 30000 1.02 (-0.01)          Wild Horse Nine (WILDH) 50000 13.82 (+0.17)          We All Die Young (WADY) 149999 0.02 (+0.01)          Wild Horse Nine (WILDH) 50000 13.82 (+0.17)          Winter of the Crow (WOTCR) 75000 0.15 (-0.01)          Jimmy (JIMYS) 50000 6.12 (+0.16)          Making Marie Antoinette (MAKMA) 50000 0.11 (0.00)          Jimmy (JIMYS) 50000 6.12 (+0.16)          Evil Dead Wrath (EVLD7) 30000 35.01 (+2.20)          Jimmy (JIMYS) 50000 6.12 (+0.16)          Ramayana (RAMAY) 149999 19.04 (+1.27)          Just Play Dead (JPDED) 135000 0.07 (-0.03)          Jimmy (JIMYS) 50000 6.12 (+0.16)          Chris Pine (CPINE) 13001 43.92 (0.00)          Jimmy (JIMYS) 50000 6.12 (+0.16)          Jimmy (JIMYS) 50000 6.12 (+0.16)          Always Lalisa (ALISA) 75000 0.08 (-0.01)          Can I Get a Witness (CIGAW) 1 0.04 (0.00)          The Second Act (SECAC) 1 0.04 (0.00)          Donkey Kong aka Untitled Nintend (DKONG) 150000 128.24 (+1.16)          Bad Blood (BDBLD) 104999 0.10 (0.00)          Donkey Kong aka Untitled Nintend (DKONG) 150000 128.24 (+1.16)          The Brand aka Branded (BRAND) 149998 3.29 (+0.16)          Donkey Kong aka Untitled Nintend (DKONG) 100 128.24 (+1.16)          Evil Dead Wrath (EVLD7) 150000 35.01 (+2.20)          The Brand aka Branded (BRAND) 1 3.29 (+0.16)          Priscilla: Queen of the Desert 2 (APQD2) 150000 2.95 (-0.02)          Awkwafina (AWKWA) 25000 112.34 (+1.00)          Matt Dillon (MDILL) 25000 9.27 (+0.05)          Bill Hader (BHADE) 25000 69.50 (-0.75)          Behemoth! (BEHEM) 25000 22.97 (-0.03)          Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Mu (TMNT4) 5000 69.43 (+0.55)          Magic: The Gathering (MGCTG) 150000 38.32 (+0.98)          Magic: The Gathering (MGCTG) 20000 38.32 (+0.98)          Highlander (HIGHL) 25000 35.61 (+0.02)          Evil Dead Wrath (EVLD7) 150000 35.01 (+2.20)          Ramayana (RAMAY) 10000 19.04 (+1.27)          Five Nights at Freddy's 3 (5NAF3) 25000 69.42 (-0.02)          They Know (TKNOW) 15000 14.54 (+1.53)          Hershey (HERSH) 150000 11.36 (0.00)