HSX Forum

Movies

are we going to have a serious conversation or is this the animal house character talking? <spoilers>

Posted by: Moviesnob on Jan 22, 19:12 in response to DTXbro's post Who in that movie was admirable, inspiring, heroic,...

ROMA is from the neo-realist school. Its grounded, about the poor, and utilizes a non professional. We see her normal life and routine, but we area also witness to a few select moments that are the most important in her life and they are given theatrical treatment thats both epic and moving. She loses her virginity. She finds out shes pregnant and tell her lover. She has the baby prematurely and stillborn when shes rejected by her lover and shes witness to a riot from seditionists. She finds acceptance with the family she works for when the family is torn apart by a divorce and she saves two of the children from drowning. These are all memorable and emotional moments for both her and the audience. Cuaron also shots the film with a real affection for Mexico City (think about how beautiful that movie theater was) and the photography is gorgeous. The heighten moments of Cleo's life are displayed by a director who has a knack for set pieces (think of GRAVITY AND CHILDREN OF MEN) so while they are not traditional heroic moments, in the context of her life, they are and are treated as such.

And then theres the reminder that the heaven's exist up above so while its still neo-realist and grounded, we can feel something beyond any existence. 

Whether or not you felt this was "admirable, inspiring, heroic, instructive, or even interesting", thats completely up to you. But there's a reason this film has been embraced by so many people and why they find those qualities in this film. Neo-realism allows an audience to find beauty in poverty and in the mundance and Cuaron just nails that for so many of the film's viewers, myself included. 

Kris Tapley, AMC is not going to include ROMA in its Best Picture Showcase/Marathons notfabio Jan 22, 10:03

Deadline: Both AMC and Regal are not showing ROMA. AMC says it's because they were never licensed to show ROMA notfabio Jan 22, 10:05

i mean thats technically true but you and i know all they had to do was want to book it and they could {nm} Moviesnob Jan 22, 10:21

Yeah, it's definitely an "easy out" for them, they could have negotiated something over the past few weeks if they were motivated to. notfabio Jan 22, 11:19

all they care about now is academy PR and they dont care about any cost there {nm} Moviesnob Jan 22, 11:53

It doesn't surprise me pquicio Jan 22, 10:31

I haven't seen ROMA but if the Shape of Water can win - anything is possible {nm} jdolphin Jan 22, 10:36

Roma is the good Mexican-directed one {nm} professor zovek Jan 22, 10:53

It was by far the best of the nominated films this year. I have seen some modest backlash on here from a few folks and it is baffling. {nm} MiyazakiFan Jan 22, 11:55

Yeah, I don't understand the comments that it's boring, etc. It's a movie centred on domestic life that still manages to be epic in scope. RogerMore Jan 22, 12:35

it didnt have thanos or the millenium falcon {nm} Moviesnob Jan 22, 13:12

this {nm} CSBD Jan 22, 13:48

i will confess to an occasional thought of "do we really need a shot of *everything* that's happening, Alfonso?" but they all quickly passed {nm} professor zovek Jan 22, 13:42

"Tarantino and feet..." - heh-heh! {nm} CSBD Jan 22, 13:47

Roma was pointless. Not insightful, thrilling, educational, inspirational, or anything else good. Boring, meandering, small depiction of DTXbro Jan 22, 15:18

It's a look at women's lives during a turbulent time. History is not just about men...etc, but also personal Her Stories. {nm} Antibody Jan 22, 15:29

its pretty obvious neo-realism unless you're being willful about disliking it. Any life can be epic, moving and beautiful. Moviesnob Jan 22, 15:47

Who in that movie was admirable, inspiring, heroic, instructive, or even interesting? DTXbro Jan 22, 17:54

are we going to have a serious conversation or is this the animal house character talking? <spoilers> Moviesnob Jan 22, 19:12

Serious response inside. {nm} DTXbro Jan 23, 10:51

Serious response inside (comment system willing) . . . DTXbro Jan 23, 16:28

Not to me. Definitely not by far. It's very well put together, with some excellent set pieces. It definitely has its problems. goodvibe61 Jan 23, 09:55

Good. Why should the theaters bend over backward if Netflix doesn't want to be a team player. Forget them. LaForza Jan 22, 11:14

and i hope the cops catch whoever held the gun to AMC's head and made them run this Best Picture showcase for several years now {nm} professor zovek Jan 22, 11:26

Their business model is counter to going to the movies. Watching a movie on Netflix is akin to watching a sunset from inside your house. Catzan Jan 22, 16:33

I like that...*thumbs up* {nm} tealfan Jan 22, 17:11

yep, well said {nm} Moviesnob Jan 22, 19:19

I would argue sometimes it is best to watch the sunset alone in my house than in a crowded beach with a lot of people making noises. FabioParme Jan 23, 06:24

And the sand! It's coarse and rough and irritating and it gets everywhere. {nm} RogerMore Jan 23, 07:45

from a certain poont of view {nm} tealfan Jan 23, 08:56





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


A Great Awakening (AGAWK) 150000 9.50 (-0.50)          Love is Not the Answer (LINTA) 150000 4.61 (-0.39)          The Wrecking Crew (WCREW) 150000 12.81 (-0.43)          Love is Not the Answer (LINTA) 150000 4.61 (-0.39)          A Great Awakening (AGAWK) 150000 9.50 (-0.50)          Corporate Retreat (CRPRT) 150000 4.60 (+0.76)          Melania (MLNIA) 150000 1.66 (-0.12)          Peaked (PEAKD) 150000 8.51 (+0.41)          Peaked (PEAKD) 150000 8.51 (+0.41)          The Moment (MOMNT) 150000 10.58 (-0.44)          The Chaperones (CHAPR) 150000 9.63 (-0.26)          The Chaperones (CHAPR) 150000 9.63 (-0.26)          Disclosure Day (SKIES) 150000 158.28 (0.00)          The Housemaid (HMAID) 20000 61.27 (-0.93)          Wicked: For Good $315M Blockbust (WCKD2.BW) 25000 7.20 (+0.16)          Disclosure Day (SKIES) 150000 158.28 (0.00)          Girls Like Girls (GRLGR) 50000 6.46 (-0.29)          Spider-Man: Brand New Day (SPID9) 16414 421.36 (+0.08)          Pirates of the Caribbean 6 (PIRT6) 37500 36.83 (-0.55)          The Mummy 4 (MUMY5) 10000 70.90 (+0.10)          Split Fiction (SPFIC) 12500 43.44 (+1.29)          A Great Awakening (AGAWK) 16663 9.50 (-0.50)          The Conjuring Prequel (CNJU5) 1803 90.54 (-0.30)          David Strathairn (DSTRA) 25000 32.82 (-0.12)          Love is Not the Answer (LINTA) 150000 4.61 (-0.39)          A Great Awakening (AGAWK) 150000 9.50 (-0.50)          Peaked (PEAKD) 150000 8.51 (+0.41)          Primate (PRIMT) 1 19.92 (-0.03)          Primate (PRIMT) 94999 19.92 (-0.03)          A Great Awakening (AGAWK) 27619 9.50 (-0.50)          Jurassic World sequel (JURA8) 1178 221.51 (0.00)          Wicked: For Good $315M Blockbust (WCKD2.BW) 25000 7.20 (+0.16)          Dracula - A Love Tale (DRALT) 150000 7.01 (-0.04)          Send Help (SENDH) 150000 35.80 (-0.13)          The Wrecking Crew (WCREW) 40000 12.81 (-0.43)          The Wrecking Crew (WCREW) 150000 12.81 (-0.43)          Is This Thing On? (ISTON) 149999 13.82 (+0.52)          Avatar: Fire and Ash H$125 Put (AVAT3.PU) 25000 3.91 (+0.03)          Avatar: Fire and Ash H$125 Put (AVAT3.PU) 25000 3.91 (+0.03)          Avatar: Fire and Ash H$125 Call (AVAT3.CA) 25000 2.70 (-0.01)          Avatar: Fire and Ash H$125 Call (AVAT3.CA) 25000 2.70 (-0.01)          Avatar: Fire and Ash - Opening W (AVAT3.OW) 100000 115.98 (-0.38)          Avatar: Fire and Ash - Opening W (AVAT3.OW) 100000 115.98 (-0.38)          Wuthering Heights (WUTHR) 150000 55.23 (-0.15)          Girls Like Girls (GRLGR) 150000 6.46 (-0.29)          Love is Not the Answer (LINTA) 150000 4.61 (-0.39)          A Great Awakening (AGAWK) 150000 9.50 (-0.50)          X-Men aka Mutants (XMEN8) 83000 167.08 (-0.18)          Judy aka Untitled Alejandro Gonz (JUDY1) 150000 100.53 (+0.33)          Marty Supreme (MRTSU) 150000 35.65 (+0.10)