HSX Forum

TVStocks, MusicStocks and Life

I've given you perfectly viable reasons why you're premise isn't as solid as you think it is, you simple don't want to hear it.

Posted by: Scorpion on Feb 20, 10:20 in response to RogerMore's post I'm not trying to get you to agree with me - I just want...

I don't have to answer your question Roger, I simply need to make counter arguments. This is a debate, not an inquest.

Rural areas have far lower murder and crime with the same access to the same weapons.

The murder rate has consistently fallen over the last 30 years in the US(~50%), with no effective legislation being enacted to curtail access to firearms. If your premise was the golden goose you seem to think it is, the murder rate would be consistent over that period, all other things being equal. But it isn't.

I'm not going to sit here and argue the access to machine guns, because it's like arguing what knife type people most commonly stab people with. It’s the most convenient one. And when that one becomes inconvenient, they just chose the next most convenient. They don’t just give up once they have crossed that boundary.

If you want to debate spree killers and how you think you're "solution" is going to stop them. Let's go. Tim McVeigh, 160 people from IED, no gun. If someone wants to kill a mass amount of people, they're not going to say "Darn, they made guns illegal. Guess I just got to deal with life. Herpaderp". Columbine killers brought IED's, the Colorado killer rigged his apartment full of them. Mass killers don't give 2 ****s about the inconvenience of law.

Where we can agree is that buying a gun or transferring to a non-family member should take a simple background check. Not some overly burdensome, intrusive & long process. The government knows when you’re a convicted violent offender instantly when you provide identification. That helps keep weapons out of criminal hands & doesn’t overly burden people’s rights. Where I will never agree is that simply making them go away solves the core problem of people wanting to kill others.

As for the Mentally Ill. You have to be very careful how you approach that. Stigmatizing people and taking their rights away without good cause ensures no one seeks help. Taking of rights requires a court of law, or at the very least a Judge, not some activist mental health professional’s opinion.

Good luck with your gun free society, we'll see how that works out for you long term. History is a **** if you don't pay attention.

And, that's really all I have, or need, to say. Toodles.

Country music star Mindy McCready commits suicide. Vashta Nerada Feb 17, 18:39

Hmmm - person with documented mental illness in possession of a gun - where have we heard that before. {nm} RotoHockeyYTD2013 Feb 17, 23:54

on reruns of Canadian TV show Flashpoint (on Ion Cable Network) {nm} RazorHawk Feb 18, 06:04

Endless array of mass shootings in the USA with automatic weapons. Pay attention. {nm} RotoHockeyYTD2013 Feb 18, 12:14

They're not "automatic". If you're going to spew your "righteousness", get it right. Else you just look stupid. {nm} Scorpion Feb 18, 17:40

Pay attention. Those mass shootings weapons were mostly semi-automatic or fully automatic weapons. RotoHockeyYTD2013 Feb 18, 20:27

Name a recent mass shooting where a fully automatic weapon was used in the US. Cause I think you're the one that needs to pay attention {nm} Scorpion Feb 19, 05:12

I'm guessing it's pretty rare, since fully automatic weapons are so tightly regulated. {nm} RogerMore Feb 19, 07:05

There's 240,000 fully automatic machine guns registered in private hands in the U.S. Expensive, but not difficult to obtain. Scorpion Feb 19, 13:24

So you obviously agree that making guns slightly harder to get hold of = fewer shootings. That's great! {nm} RogerMore Feb 19, 13:33

No, I do not agree with you. And it's clear that your argument using machine guns is so utterly baseless it's ludicrous. {nm} Scorpion Feb 19, 15:12

I'm confused. Your argument was that fully automatic weapons are rarely used in mass shootings. You agree that automatic weapons are more RogerMore Feb 19, 15:22

Yet, making a semi-auto weapon full auto is trivial for anyone that can use a power tool & the Internet. Scorpion Feb 19, 16:01

That completely avoids my simple question. RogerMore Feb 19, 19:55

And you're avoiding the fact that they were rarely used even before the regulations were tightened in the 1980's. Scorpion Feb 19, 22:10

I'm not trying to get you to agree with me - I just want you to understand how bad your argument is. RogerMore Feb 20, 06:43

I've given you perfectly viable reasons why you're premise isn't as solid as you think it is, you simple don't want to hear it. Scorpion Feb 20, 10:20

I should clarify a few things here... RogerMore Feb 20, 12:30

Mass shootings in the US typically happen in "gun-free zones". accountant_4_Jesus Feb 19, 14:30

Mass shootings are a far bigger problem in the United States than other countries. Why do you think this is so? RogerMore Feb 19, 15:54

There are a few reasons, most of which are controversial and I don't want to go into at this point in time. accountant_4_Jesus Feb 19, 16:03

You can email me if you want to keep it off the boards - but if not, have you been to America? RogerMore Feb 19, 20:34

Try comparing countries of similar populations and population densities. {nm} Scorpion Feb 19, 16:07

These are all liberal, urbanised democracies based on shared philosophies like the rule of law, liberty, freedom to live your life RogerMore Feb 19, 20:07

Your examples included robberies (which are not mass shootings) and some of the armed citizens are off-duty/retired police officers. {nm} Antibody Feb 19, 16:55

As John McClane is fond of saying, 'If you are not part of the solution, you are part of the problem'. {nm} RotoHockeyYTD2013 Feb 18, 12:21

Hmmm. Funny you'd say that... {nm} eyescovered Feb 19, 09:15

Sad story. It's ok she off'ed herself, did she have to off the dog, as well? Plenty of people would be willing to take it in. {nm} elchan Feb 18, 09:05

Life is precious and irreplaceable however, people are not {nm} wroberson Feb 19, 00:15





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


The Return (TRETU) 1000 4.10 (+0.41)          Anora (ANORA) 1000 4.10 (+0.49)          Wolfs (WOLFS) 1 53.51 (-0.10)          Ewan McGregor (EMCGR) 20106 91.47 (-0.20)          Wolfs (WOLFS) 1 53.51 (-0.10)          Taylor Russell (TARUS) 20179 14.98 (-0.08)          The Exorcism (TGTWP) 150000 1.59 (-0.02)          Untitled Alejandro Gonzalez Inar (UAGIP) 150000 60.89 (+0.89)          The Exorcism (TGTWP) 150000 1.59 (-0.02)          Julia Louis-Dreyfus (JLOUI) 20039 71.71 (-0.45)          Julia Louis-Dreyfus (JLOUI) 25000 71.71 (-0.45)          Spider-Man: Beyond the Spider-Ve (ASPD3) 150000 225.21 (+0.66)          Mufasa: The Lion King (LION2) 149999 286.44 (+1.27)          The Crow (TCROW) 150000 23.40 (+0.04)          The Crow (TCROW) 5 23.40 (+0.04)          The Wager (WAGER) 86653 36.99 (+1.42)          Robot Dreams (RBDRM) 5000 1.72 (0.00)          Polly Pocket (POLYP) 5000 37.14 (-0.03)          The Down Under Fund (AUSIE) 20000 89.61 (-0.07)          Locked (LOCKD) 10000 6.75 (0.00)          The One (THEON) 5000 11.95 (+0.02)          Summer Camp (SUMCP) 10000 8.58 (-0.02)          Untitled Alejandro Gonzalez Inar (UAGIP) 1136 60.89 (+0.89)          Solitary (SOLIT) 1 0.01 (-0.01)          Zootopia 2 (ZOOT2) 19100 174.64 (-0.04)          Playdate (PLYDT) 10000 15.96 (+0.02)          Lips Like Sugar (LIPLS) 10000 11.73 (+0.39)          The Wager (WAGER) 150000 36.99 (+1.42)          Children of the New World (COTNW) 1 0.01 (0.00)          Untitled Alejandro Gonzalez Inar (UAGIP) 150000 60.89 (+0.89)          Beautiful Ruins (BTRUI) 1 0.01 (0.00)          Nobody 2 (NOBO2) 150000 16.92 (+1.03)          Untitled Alejandro Gonzalez Inar (UAGIP) 834 60.89 (+0.89)          Artist in Residence (ARTIR) 100000 0.03 (+0.02)          Gilded Rage (GLDRG) 1 0.10 (0.00)          Zootopia 2 (ZOOT2) 265 174.64 (-0.04)          Civil War (CVLWR) 5 60.96 (+0.05)          Sovereign (SOVRN) 10000 6.79 (-0.01)          The Smashing Machine (SMACH) 12500 17.90 (0.00)          The Ministry Of Ungentlemanly Wa (TMOUW) 2275 22.74 (-0.09)          Bum's Rush (BUMSR) 19001 0.06 (0.00)          The Ministry Of Ungentlemanly Wa (TMOUW) 53590 22.74 (-0.09)          Thelma (THELM) 27500 3.46 (0.00)          Borderline (BRLIN) 27500 12.01 (-0.07)          A Problem Of Providence (APROP) 40000 0.05 (0.00)          Untitled Alejandro Gonzalez Inar (UAGIP) 148030 60.89 (+0.89)          Flight of the Navigator (FNAVG) 40000 0.03 (-0.01)          Everest aka Mallory aka The Summ (SUMIT) 20000 0.10 (0.00)          Revival (RVIVL) 20000 0.10 (0.00)          Challengers (CHALN) 140048 40.13 (+0.64)