HSX Forum

Movies

The Audience is the correct answer.

Posted by: medv4380 on May 07, 12:17 in response to DTXbro's post Comic books v. John McPhee. Shawshank Redemption v....

For every Transformers that the audiance enjoys and is willing to spend the money you get dozens like Green Lantern and Green Hornet. Weak story and incoherent plot can only take you so far before the audicance back lashes. As much as Michael Bay appears to be a hack driector he is no Uwe Boll, and Bay can satisfy his perticular audicance.Ā 

And if Ebert is your God of film critics then you should like Avengers because he liked it too, or did you miss his fresh rating and review of the Avengers?

A collection of Avengers-related thoughts about the movies. DTXbro May 07, 07:46

agreed on your point 3. Furthermore; 'why so serious' about this kiddiefare JMT-NL May 07, 07:53

You should probably go back and re-read points 1, 2, 4, and 5. :) {nm} DTXbro May 07, 08:04

okay... tried again... head hurts... AAArgh... JMT Smash ! {nm} JMT-NL May 07, 08:50

The most important point was in the final line.{nm} DTXbro May 07, 10:23

Luxurification? Infantalization? {nm} forlorne May 07, 08:28

I don't really agree with your points. medv4380 May 07, 08:29

I believe Robert Downey Jr. sold some Avengers tickets. But isn't that a vivid exception? Edward Norton is a fine actor, but DTXbro May 07, 08:47

RDOWN, in the same way JDEPP made the "Pirates..." franchise work, or HLEDG made BATM2 something very good into something... second gary May 07, 09:31

I think your mixing some rotten apples in with your oranges. medv4380 May 07, 09:58

Box office figures seem to suggest that many AVNGR patrons did not see the predecessor movies. I doubt most viewers cared about missing the DTXbro May 07, 10:22

Following this logic, box office figures seem to suggest that many ANVGR patrons did not see any other movie ever SamJohnson2 May 07, 10:42

What form of logic do you have in mind? Deductive, inductive, and even abductive appear to be out of the running.{nm} DTXbro May 07, 11:20

The argument of it being Hackneyed is academic, and applies to everything. medv4380 May 07, 11:34

Comic books v. John McPhee. Shawshank Redemption v. Gigli. Paul Newman v. Kim Kardashian. At some point, who is to say what is superior? DTXbro May 07, 11:57

The Audience is the correct answer. medv4380 May 07, 12:17

The mass audience decides popularity. Nothing more. Do McBurgers and ramen noodles top the "best foods" list. As for Ebert's review, DTXbro May 07, 12:40

The Audience is the only measuring stick you really have. medv4380 May 07, 13:54

Don't worry. It's the blockbusters that pay the way for artistic films. elchan May 07, 09:05

And if anyone fixates on artistic films, it's a guy named Bluto who lives at Delta House! {nm} DTXbro May 07, 15:49

Relax. Not every film can be high-minded art like Caddyshack or Animal House. {nm} Tanker May 07, 09:32

Those films will be quoted for decades and are featured in well-regarded lists. A work of almost any genre can be done well, or brilliantly. DTXbro May 07, 10:30

Seems to me that you are like Judge Smails looking down on lowbrow entertainment like The Avengers. Tanker May 07, 10:37

Stripes, Caddyshack, and Animal House were great lowbrow entertainments, which is in some ways the best entertainment. {nm} DTXbro May 07, 11:22

The gist of your argument (such that it is) when all is said and done comes to an internet meme. Tanker May 07, 11:47

I do not begrudge those that like The Avengers. I count myself fortunate that these are my children's economic competitors. But if we can DTXbro May 07, 12:45





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


The Social Reckoning (SOCI2) 47000 57.71 (-0.49)          Ralph Fiennes (RFIEN) 25000 27.10 (+0.25)          Top Gun 3 (TOPG3) 700 173.82 (-0.76)          CBS: NCIS: New York (NCISNY) 3000 12.42 (0.00)          Patrick Schwarzenegger (PSCHW) 2000 6.38 (-0.16)          Narnia: The Magician's Nephew (NARN4) 8000 27.33 (-1.04)          Ghost Rider (GHSRD) 134 155.73 (-0.11)          Verity H$25 Put (VERTY.PU) 2000 1.64 (+0.06)          Dennis Quaid (DQUAI) 20000 13.25 (+0.08)          The Batman: Part II (TBAT2) 6004 281.09 (-1.25)          By Any Means (CI34) 150000 17.70 (+0.15)          Verity H$25 Call (VERTY.CA) 1000 2.87 (-0.08)          Practical Magic 2 (PRAC2) 150000 71.98 (+1.15)          Verity H$25 Call (VERTY.CA) 2000 2.87 (-0.08)          By Any Means (CI34) 1 17.70 (+0.15)          Jeffrey Wright (JWRIG) 20000 63.86 (-0.20)          Angourie Rice (ARICE) 25000 116.12 (+0.33)          Digger H$25 Put (DIGER.PU) 3000 3.12 (+0.10)          Practical Magic 2 (PRAC2) 15000 71.98 (+1.15)          Digger H$25 Call (DIGER.CA) 2000 1.59 (-0.02)          Digger H$25 Call (DIGER.CA) 2000 1.59 (-0.02)          Eva Victor (EVICT) 25000 3.38 (-0.05)          Practical Magic 2 (PRAC2) 30000 71.98 (+1.15)          Iron Jane (IRONJ) 1104 9.16 (-0.84)          Leo Woodall (LWOOD) 25000 11.20 (-0.10)          Antonio Banderas (ABAND) 25000 53.31 (+0.16)          I am Legend 2 (LEGN2) 32007 27.70 (+0.05)          Claire Foy (CFOY) 25000 5.58 (+0.05)          Resident Evil (RESE8) 1000 102.55 (+2.42)          Bad Lieutenant: Tokyo (BADLT) 1000 4.26 (+0.44)          Your Mother Your Mother Your Mot (YOURM) 1000 8.32 (+0.81)          Anna Faris (AFARI) 25000 70.50 (+0.25)          Focker In-Law (MPRN4) 8150 124.84 (+0.01)          Snake Island (SNKIS) 2000 17.13 (-0.24)          Jason Statham (JSTAT) 25000 33.07 (+0.12)          George Michael: The Faith Tour (GMTFT) 139258 7.26 (-0.04)          The Origin of the World (TOOTW) 27000 14.92 (-0.03)          Annabelle Wallis (AWALL) 25000 37.88 (+0.12)          Daniel and The Fiery Furnace (DANIL) 48048 5.17 (-0.15)          X-Men aka Mutants (XMEN8) 21929 207.66 (+0.10)          Metal Gear Solid (MTLGR) 47999 11.29 (-0.03)          Untitled Blair Witch Movie (TBWP4) 28120 37.53 (-0.01)          Wife and Dog (WIFDG) 40000 12.31 (-0.30)          Rolling Loud The Movie (RLOUD) 25000 10.82 (-0.07)          Rolling Loud The Movie (RLOUD) 66001 10.82 (-0.07)          Practical Magic 2 (PRAC2) 100000 71.98 (+1.15)          Seasons (SEASN) 25000 25.84 (+0.53)          Misty Green (MSTYG) 25000 10.44 (-0.09)          Shang-Chi 2 (SHCH2) 5000 47.63 (-0.15)          Street Fighter (STFTR) 1000 75.60 (+0.12)