HSX Forum

Movies

After reading posts below, I see that folks here seem to think that superhero films have already been dark. Well...

Posted by: Willroast on Feb 13, 21:58 in response to Willroast's post (not meaning to exclude SvB, just not sold on Afleck...

...Very few have when considering the source material. The Dark Knight tril is dark? Hardly when you compare it to many stories told in the books. The only actual dark story I can offhand think of (ultra-violence alone doesn't count so the Punisher attemps don't work here) is Sin City.

I mean, there are shades of dark I guess that will show in TDK stuff and SvB and so on, but that is not what I mean when I say "dark". Dark is having villains win or, often, having a true bad guy be the person you root for. In my brief time reading comics, several characters would fall into that role. Deadpool was one (though I wasn't a fan) because he was written obscene and killed without remorse (something Marvel didn't do often at that time). Preacher and Transmetropolitan and several other Vertigo titles also come to mind. 

I'm looking forward to some actual dark superhero movies/shows coming in the future. When it comes to Horror movies or superhero movies the difference, to me, between PG-13 and R is that only one of them treats the audience as an adult viewer and let's the story tell itself without inhibitions. 

Speaking of 'fun' superhero film... "Captain America: Civil War" is a 'dark' superhero film, but it still tested extremely well Peterlee Feb 13, 20:05

Civil War is a ton of fun {nm} Moviesnob Feb 13, 20:12

Just because the movie goes to dark places doesnt mean its as dark as BvS. the stakes are serious thats all {nm} Moviesnob Feb 13, 20:15

its not guardians or ant man, but theres humor. Its tone about the same as Winter Soldier {nm} Moviesnob Feb 13, 20:27

This is great news. I think Suicide Squad and Civil War will show that there is a big interest in dark superhero stories. {nm} Willroast Feb 13, 21:02

(not meaning to exclude SvB, just not sold on Afleck pulling it off yet, hope to be wrong) {nm} Willroast Feb 13, 21:06

After reading posts below, I see that folks here seem to think that superhero films have already been dark. Well... Willroast Feb 13, 21:58

well, there's serious/grounded vs fantasy. "Dark" can exist in both in many different ways. The point I was making was the lesson Moviesnob Feb 13, 22:33

Absolutely. I don't see the rating possibilities changing something as mainstream as Superman or Batman. Movies with... Willroast Feb 13, 23:38

IDK, I think Affleck is going to be great as Batman, might even be the highlight. {nm} ~JPV~ Feb 13, 23:12

I've been skeptical since he was first rumored, but if he can keep that stupid grin of his in check as Batman than he may be alright. {nm} Dorfman Feb 14, 01:51

Big if. {nm} VicMackeyYTD Feb 14, 02:06

HUGE. I'll expect is as Bruce Wayne, but not as the bat. {nm} RREYN Feb 14, 06:13





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


Dog Stars (DOGST) 139000 56.54 (-0.18)          28 Years Later: The Bone Temple (28LT4) 140000 62.54 (-0.44)          The Man with the Bag (TMWTB) 2 14.45 (+0.56)          The Man with the Bag (TMWTB) 2 14.45 (+0.56)          Animal Farm (AFARM) 2 5.79 (+0.29)          Animal Farm (AFARM) 2 5.79 (+0.29)          In the Grey (NGREY) 2 14.70 (+0.30)          In the Grey (NGREY) 2 14.70 (+0.30)          G.I. Joe sequel (GIJO4) 1 14.55 (+0.45)          G.I. Joe sequel (GIJO4) 1 14.55 (+0.45)          Fauzi (FAUZI) 150000 5.07 (+0.43)          Fauzi (FAUZI) 3 5.07 (+0.43)          Dune: Part Three aka Dune: Messi (DUNE3) 3 222.38 (+0.40)          Dune: Part Three aka Dune: Messi (DUNE3) 3 222.38 (+0.40)          Mother Mary (MMARY) 150000 11.26 (-0.75)          Mother Mary (MMARY) 3 11.26 (-0.75)          Zootopia 2 (ZOOT2) 10 300.22 (-3.37)          Zootopia 2 (ZOOT2) 10 300.22 (-3.37)          Rock'em Sock'em Robots (RMSMR) 49999 17.44 (-0.46)          Peaky Blinders: The Immortal Man (PEKBL) 150000 1.00 (0.00)          Nick Frost (NFROS) 25000 55.00 (0.00)          The Way of the Wind (LPLNT) 10000 0.01 (-0.03)          Jurassic World sequel (JURA8) 1000 209.53 (+9.53)          Avengers: Doomsday (AVNG5) 17000 530.30 (+0.47)          Avengers: Secret Wars (AVNG6) 16887 456.02 (+0.77)          Deep Water (DEEPW) 20000 6.06 (-0.07)          The Odyssey (ODYSE) 50 279.60 (-0.17)          Deep Water (DEEPW) 10000 6.06 (-0.07)          Michael 2 (MJAC2) 1000 135.65 (-0.72)          The SpongeBob Movie: Search for (SPBO4) 150000 72.48 (+0.20)          Peaky Blinders: The Immortal Man (PEKBL) 150000 1.00 (0.00)          Star Wars: Dawn of the Jedi (STRW1) 3000 132.24 (-0.51)          The SpongeBob Movie: Search for (SPBO4) 149999 72.48 (+0.20)          The Mummy 4 (MUMY5) 5000 66.64 (+0.33)          Pirates of the Caribbean 6 (PIRT6) 82344 39.16 (-0.78)          Bullitt (BULIT) 149999 22.15 (+0.05)          Wicked: For Good (WCKD2) 150000 325.52 (-21.09)          Anaconda (ANAC3) 149998 82.91 (+0.34)          Zootopia 2 (ZOOT2) 150000 300.22 (-3.37)          Ready or Not 2: Here I Come (RONO2) 150000 27.61 (-0.42)          Anaconda (ANAC3) 2 82.91 (+0.34)          Final Destination 7 (FDES7) 150000 71.43 (-1.04)          Peaky Blinders: The Immortal Man (PEKBL) 150000 1.00 (0.00)          Peaky Blinders: The Immortal Man (PEKBL) 150000 1.00 (0.00)          Glenn Close (GCLOS) 25000 5.76 (-0.09)          Peaky Blinders: The Immortal Man (PEKBL) 150000 1.00 (0.00)          Wicked: For Good (WCKD2) 45748 325.52 (-21.09)          How to Train Your Dragon 2 (HTTY2) 150000 181.53 (+1.18)          Cocomelon the Movie (COMEL) 150000 50.88 (+0.82)          G.I. Joe sequel (GIJO4) 150000 14.55 (+0.45)