HSX Forum

Movies

It's a legitimate criticism but I don't think Cloud Atlas belongs on that list

Posted by: the_treachery_of_images on Apr 22, 19:35 in response to Antibody's post Vox has made a video for those we don't get Yellowface is...

The ensemble cast includes Doona Bae (Korean) and Xun Zhou (Chinese). The narrative interweaves several stories from different setting with completely different characters all played by the same cast swapping out personas. You can't point to having some white actors playing asian characters as a problem when all the cast was doing similar things like not just race switching but gender switching as well. It was an integral aspect of the movie and I think done very well (though I may be in a minority for liking that film). 

Vox has made a video for those we don't get Yellowface is bad. Hollywood’s best Asian roles still go to white people. Antibody Apr 22, 14:53

You should really see a doctor about that chip on your shoulder. {nm} hyperzeitgeist Apr 22, 14:56

Maybe there is a troll proctologist that can pull your head out of your ass. {nm} islander Apr 22, 15:17

lol {nm} Moviesnob Apr 22, 15:19

We are the goon squad and we're coming to town beep-beep {nm} hyperzeitgeist Apr 22, 15:23

This is the first time I've been happy David Bowie has passed bennyg1985 Apr 22, 16:43

would it have have frustrated you if Charles Kane had been played by a Tibetan, Don Corleone by an Asian or George Washington by a Mexican? tealfan Apr 22, 16:06

Isn't George Washington being played by a black guy in Hamilton, the hottest show on Broadway in a long time? shadowking Apr 22, 16:21

Shhhh, stop noticing things. {nm} MattW Apr 22, 16:25

+1 {nm} Dorfman Apr 22, 18:26

The point of the video is that it isn't one iconic asian role that is being played by a white person... bennyg1985 Apr 22, 16:41

i think tealfan is a person of color. He's basically saying the same thing you are {nm} Moviesnob Apr 22, 16:43

yup, I'm Filipino...and I didn't have enough room in the title to cover the whole scope of the problem. :) {nm} tealfan Apr 22, 17:19

My apologies for misunderstanding your point and snapping at you. {nm} bennyg1985 Apr 22, 18:22

no worries {nm} tealfan Apr 22, 21:29

+1 {nm} hawkfanatic2 Apr 22, 20:01

Thanks for posting! I only knew about half or so of those snubs, so that was really enlightening {nm} bennyg1985 Apr 22, 15:11

Ashton kutcher should know better {nm} islander Apr 22, 15:18

2012 was a different time... {nm} RamsFan2004 Apr 22, 15:29

I want to make sure I got this straight. So Asian people can complain that there are white actors cast as Asian characters... diamondman56 Apr 22, 19:05

It's a legitimate criticism but I don't think Cloud Atlas belongs on that list the_treachery_of_images Apr 22, 19:35

+1 on this. I posted about Cloud Atlas getting a short shrift in this conversation as well. Hell, Doona Bae plays 2 other races herself! MiyazakiFan Apr 22, 23:33

So would it be okay for Gal Gadot to play an Asian? She is from the Asian continent. {nm} tenchi7 Apr 23, 01:11

I believe it started with Sessue Hayakawa(Colonel Saito in Bridge over the River Kwai). He was the biggest star in Holly wood... tenchi7 Apr 23, 01:19





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


The Sequel Fund (SQUEL) 20000 68.48 (+0.04)          The Horror Fund 9 (SPOOK) 20000 93.21 (-0.06)          Paul Thomas Anderson - One Battl (A6DPTA) 100 11.19 (+0.07)          The Asian Fund (ASIAN) 20000 27.03 (-0.72)          The Animal Fund (ZOO) 20000 20.12 (+0.03)          Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Mu (TMNT4) 5000 73.08 (0.00)          Michael B. Jordan - Sinners - Ac (A6AMBJ) 100 6.56 (+0.03)          The African-American Fund (AFRAM) 20000 41.19 (+0.06)          Spaceballs 2 (SPCB2) 5000 120.21 (+0.01)          Amy Madigan - Weapons - Sup Actr (A6SAMA) 100 7.89 (-0.03)          Broadsword (BROSW) 37500 55.68 (-0.03)          TimothĂ©e Chalamet - Marty Supre (A6ATCH) 100 9.92 (+0.06)          ABC: RJ Decker (RJDECK) 25000 9.15 (+0.07)          Evil Dead Burn (EVLD6) 5 38.47 (+0.02)          The Odyssey (ODYSE) 4 292.96 (+0.55)          Minions 3 (MNIO3) 119 317.36 (0.00)          The Drama (TDRAM) 28000 22.56 (+0.30)          Stellan SkarsgĂĄrd - Sentimental (A6RSSK) 100 9.29 (0.00)          Moana (MOAN1) 500 219.43 (+0.36)          Supergirl (SUPGR) 50 181.23 (+0.04)          The Breadwinner (BREDW) 70000 25.98 (+0.51)          Toy Story 5 (TOYS5) 4 363.14 (+1.25)          Disclosure Day (SKIES) 4 162.80 (+0.16)          Iron Lung (IRONL) 1600 24.05 (-0.31)          Scary Movie 6 (SCAR6) 4 54.93 (-0.05)          Send Help (SENDH) 150000 46.60 (+0.01)          Avengers: Doomsday (AVNG5) 9998 548.84 (+0.63)          The Mandalorian and Grogu (SWAR3) 5000 239.09 (-0.55)          The Mandalorian and Grogu (SWAR3) 5000 239.09 (-0.55)          Hey Bear (HEYBR) 10941 6.47 (+0.68)          Animal Friends (ANFRN) 5 74.43 (+0.25)          Spider-Man: Brand New Day (SPID9) 150000 420.83 (0.00)          Passenger (PSNGR) 4 18.11 (-0.04)          Pressure (PRSUR) 20 15.84 (+0.27)          Toy Story 5 (TOYS5) 150000 363.14 (+1.25)          The Mandalorian and Grogu (SWAR3) 4 239.09 (-0.55)          The Mandalorian and Grogu (SWAR3) 23418 239.09 (-0.55)          The Custom of the Country (TCOTC) 150000 18.96 (+2.29)          The Sheep Detectives (3BAGF) 4 40.33 (+0.11)          They Follow aka It Follows 2 (TFLW2) 78333 5.64 (+0.03)          Wuthering Heights H$45 Put Fri-M (WUTHR.PU) 25000 2.38 (-0.08)          The Devil Wears Prada 2 (PRAD2) 8 175.85 (-1.18)          John Wick: Chapter 5 (WICK5) 150000 108.70 (+1.62)          Over Your Dead Body aka The Trip (TETRP) 160 7.44 (+0.96)          Normal (NORML) 120 17.72 (-0.04)          Beneath the Storm (BSTRM) 150000 5.14 (-0.06)          The Drama (TDRAM) 40200 22.56 (+0.30)          The Moment (MOMNT) 150000 9.06 (-0.07)          Cillian Murphy (CMURP) 820 90.76 (0.00)          In the Grey (NGREY) 4 17.16 (+0.02)