HSX Forum

TVStocks, MusicStocks and Life

Since 1956. More...

Posted by: PVL Admin (a.k.a Rocket123) on Nov 17, 22:18 in response to elchan's post Since when was bombing civilians a war crime? It was...

All nations are deeply convinced that war should be banned as a means of settling disputes between human communities.
However, in view of the need, should hostilities once more break out, of safeguarding the civilian population from the destruction with which it is threatened as a result of technical developments in weapons and methods of warfare,
The limits placed by the requirements of humanity and the safety of the population on the use of armed force are restated and defined in the following rules.
In cases not specifically provided for, the civilian population shall continue to enjoy the protection of the general rule set forth in Article 1, and of the principles of international law. 

...

CHAPTER II : OBJECTIVES BARRED FROM ATTACK

Immunity of the civilian population

Art. 6. Attacks directed against the civilian population, as such, whether with the object of terrorizing it or for any other reason, are prohibited. This prohibition applies both to attacks on individuals and to those directed against groups.
In consequence, it is also forbidden to attack dwellings, installations or means of transport, which are for the exclusive use of, and occupied by, the civilian population.
Nevertheless, should members of the civilian population, Article 11 notwithstanding, be within or in close proximity to a military objective they must accept the risks resulting from an attack directed against that objective. 


Limitation of objectives which may be attacked

Art. 7. In order to limit the dangers incurred by the civilian population, attacks may only be directed against military objectives.
Only objectives belonging to the categories of objective which, in view of their essential characteristics, are generally acknowledged to be of military importance, may be considered as military objectives. Those categories are listed in an annex to the present rules.
However, even if they belong to one of those categories, they cannot be considered as a military objective where their total or partial destruction, in the circumstances ruling at the time, offers no military advantage.

...

Target-area bombing

Art. 10. It is forbidden to attack without distinction, as a single objective, an area including several military objectives at a distance from one another where elements of the civilian population, or dwellings, are situated in between the said military objectives

...

Intentional exposure to danger

Art. 13. Parties to the conflict are prohibited from placing or keeping members of the civilian population subject to their authority in or near military objectives, with the idea of inducing the enemy to refrain from attacking those objectives.  

Should the Hamas leadership be brought up on war crimes for launching military weapons at civilian populations? {nm} websch01ar Nov 15, 11:56

Hmmm. Wonder what the USA would do if Mexico kept lobbing rockets into Texas. {nm} RotoHockeyYTD2012 Nov 15, 12:14

did the Mexicans have their land along the Texas border taken without their consent to establish a . . . oh wait {nm} mickpix Nov 15, 16:12

Lets not over-commit to this logic. Palenstians have been kicked out of places like Jordan for a long time. websch01ar Nov 16, 04:30

I think Israel prefers assassinations. {nm} Antibody Nov 15, 15:00

And you can prove that it was them? {nm} RotoHockeyYTD2012 Nov 15, 15:10

Yes, IDF posted it on Youtube Antibody Nov 15, 18:42

Your point? This is a fair military objective carried out with precision. It honors the Geneva accords perfectly. {nm} websch01ar Nov 16, 04:31

Israel prefers assassinations than trials for war crimes. {nm} Antibody Nov 16, 08:56

Obama prefers Drones...is there a point here? {nm} websch01ar Nov 16, 09:36

Yes, there is a point there. Are you purposely ignoring the point or just tring to pick a fight? {nm} PVL Admin Nov 17, 21:42

My dad is one of them. He's in Beersheba at the moment {nm} Moviesnob Nov 15, 16:03

Since when was bombing civilians a war crime? It was done in WWII, and in every war since. {nm} elchan Nov 15, 17:35

Israeli airstrikes have also killed civilians, including a 11-month baby. {nm} Antibody Nov 15, 18:58

It's the reality of war in the modern era. War in the 18th century was more civilized. {nm} elchan Nov 15, 19:04

Wars in the 18th century had lots of empty room to have their battles in. {nm} DTravel Nov 15, 19:57

Don't forget the Sabra & Shatila Massacre as depicted in the outstanding film 'Waltz With Bashir'. {nm} RotoHockeyYTD2012 Nov 15, 21:27

When a civilian area is used for military purposes, under International law it loses its civilian classification. No one likes to see a websch01ar Nov 16, 04:35

Neither side is completely innocent just as UN's Goldstone Report commission found about last Gaza conflict in 2008. {nm} Antibody Nov 16, 09:02

So a soveriegn nation does not have the right to react according to International Law? That is your position? websch01ar Nov 16, 09:37

I'm just stop responding to your trolling. {nm} Antibody Nov 16, 10:24

This is just laziness on your part. Clearly make an argument rather than using talking points here. {nm} websch01ar Nov 19, 07:53

Why are you putting words in his mouth. Clearly, neither side is innocent. Period. If you don't like reading it, go change history. {nm} PVL Admin Nov 17, 21:46

Ahh here is an interesting point of conflict between us. I do not see how Israel is guilty in this exchange. websch01ar Nov 19, 07:52

Well, if you looked back further than a week in history, you might see it differently. {nm} PVL Admin Nov 19, 12:24

I see Israel as a nation with an obligation to defend its borders. We should look at the current conflict in current context, not associate websch01ar Nov 20, 05:54

I said nothing of the sort regarding MY beliefs. Now you are projecting to bait. Uninterested. {nm} PVL Admin Nov 20, 16:41

That's true, but it's combattant and non-combattant status. {nm} PVL Admin Nov 17, 21:44

1899? mickpix Nov 16, 02:18

It is a war crime when ppl dressed as civilians target civilian areas. Period. Go read International Law. {nm} websch01ar Nov 16, 04:32

Civilian deaths are inevitable collateral damage in war. Targetting civilian non-combattants is a crime. Do some research. {nm} PVL Admin Nov 17, 21:31

Since 1956. More... PVL Admin Nov 17, 22:18

I agree. Pls find the portions of the laws that indicate what happens when a civilian location is used as a military websch01ar Nov 19, 07:55

I did not disagree with this in your post. Why are you arguing this? Some people just can't take YES for an answer ;) {nm} PVL Admin Nov 19, 12:41

From the State Department websch01ar Nov 16, 04:58

Israel has an *obligation* to defend itself, not a *right*. In that regard, the State Department errs greatly. accountant_4_Jesus Nov 16, 07:54

I agree with your IM, but disagree with you title post. A cointry has the RIGHT to defend its borders against agression. {nm} PVL Admin Nov 17, 21:34

There is a big difference in the meanings of the two words, as I shall demonstrate. accountant_4_Jesus Nov 18, 17:28

(Reposted with better formatting here) accountant_4_Jesus Nov 18, 17:34

A4J, I understand your dictionary definitions; however, the issue of rights and obligations extends beyond the accademic. PVL Admin Nov 19, 13:03





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


Over Your Dead Body (TETRP) 60000 4.19 (+0.23)          Death Stranding (DSTRN) 999 21.44 (-0.02)          The Kidnapping of Arabella (TKOAR) 150000 1.00 (0.00)          Clifton Collins Jr. (CCOLL) 25000 2.54 (-0.05)          The Revenge of La Llorona (LORN2) 1000 24.09 (-0.05)          Gladys aka Weapons prequel (WEPN2) 40000 68.57 (-0.08)          Clifton Collins Jr. (CCOLL) 25000 2.54 (-0.05)          Wishful Thinking (WSHFT) 150000 3.42 (+0.38)          Animal Farm (AFARM) 150000 8.42 (-1.28)          Hit Me Hard And Soft: The Tour (HMHAS) 30000 23.89 (+0.49)          The Isolate Thief (ISOLT) 1000 0.85 (-0.15)          Wishful Thinking (WSHFT) 1000 3.42 (+0.38)          Wishful Thinking (WSHFT) 150000 3.42 (+0.38)          The Kidnapping of Arabella (TKOAR) 150000 1.00 (0.00)          The Kidnapping of Arabella (TKOAR) 150000 1.00 (0.00)          A Colt Is My Passport (ACIMP) 150000 8.00 (0.00)          The Wrong Girls (TWRNG) 150000 9.02 (-0.55)          The Wrong Girls (TWRNG) 150000 9.02 (-0.55)          Giant (GIANT) 150000 0.96 (+0.04)          Godzilla x Kong: Supernova (GOKO3) 4000 156.26 (-0.11)          Giant (GIANT) 150000 0.96 (+0.04)          Angel and the Badman (ANBAD) 150000 11.92 (-1.24)          Angel and the Badman (ANBAD) 150000 11.92 (-1.24)          The Isolate Thief (ISOLT) 150000 0.85 (-0.15)          Good People Bad Things (GPBT) 150000 12.87 (-0.32)          The Kidnapping of Arabella (TKOAR) 150000 1.00 (0.00)          Good People Bad Things (GPBT) 150000 12.87 (-0.32)          A Colt Is My Passport (ACIMP) 150000 8.00 (0.00)          Animal Farm (AFARM) 150000 8.42 (-1.28)          Good People Bad Things (GPBT) 150000 12.87 (-0.32)          Good People Bad Things (GPBT) 150000 12.87 (-0.32)          The Great Beyond aka Ghostwriter (ACRNS) 40000 125.72 (-0.23)          Pierce Brosnan (PBROS) 25000 50.99 (+0.16)          Animal Farm (AFARM) 150000 8.42 (-1.28)          Animal Farm (AFARM) 150000 8.42 (-1.28)          Voltron (VOLTN) 64 22.34 (-0.02)          The Wrong Girls (TWRNG) 150000 9.02 (-0.55)          The Wrong Girls (TWRNG) 150000 9.02 (-0.55)          Untitled Fourth Film directed by (UJPE4) 6 52.08 (+0.30)          Rolling Loud (RLOUD) 150000 9.17 (-0.79)          The Saint (TSAIN) 5 5.08 (+0.02)          Angel and the Badman (ANBAD) 150000 11.92 (-1.24)          Angel and the Badman (ANBAD) 150000 11.92 (-1.24)          Tomb Raider (TOMB4) 3 2.88 (-0.01)          Gatto (GATTO) 4000 122.70 (-0.14)          Top Gun 3 (TOPG3) 3 234.95 (-0.16)          Tomb Raider (TOMB4) 5 2.88 (-0.01)          Top Gun 3 (TOPG3) 3 234.95 (-0.16)          Cocomelon the Movie (COMEL) 4000 53.24 (0.00)          Ono Ghost Market (ONOGM) 40000 85.04 (+1.17)