HSX Forum

TVStocks, MusicStocks and Life

So you're saying that American Pharoah and Secretariat weren't true champions because they didn't race on turf?...

Posted by: hyperzeitgeist on May 08, 06:18 in response to blaze223's post Until the horse is run at say Epsom,Ascot,Newmarket or...

The corollary of your argument is that neither Frankel or Mill Reef were true champions as they didn't race on dirt! Of course it's always difficult to draw a direct line of comparison as the two surfaces require different preparation, riding tactics and there is considerable evidence that the two disciplines require an entirely different genetic make-up. Trust me when I say that I have been watching thoroughbred racing for a very long time and have learned to recognise true champions wherever they race. Which is not to say that American dirt-track horses can't succeed on turf - you only have to look at Wesley Ward's track record with 2 year-olds at Royal Ascot.

Mario Gutierrez gives Nyquist a superb ride to win the Kentucky Derby. Horse 8 for 8, Jockey 2 for in the Derby!... hyperzeitgeist May 07, 15:59

Jockey *2 for 2* in Derby. {nm} hyperzeitgeist May 07, 16:00

Until the horse is run at say Epsom,Ascot,Newmarket or Longchamp cannot be a true champion. {nm} blaze223 May 08, 05:36

So you're saying that American Pharoah and Secretariat weren't true champions because they didn't race on turf?... hyperzeitgeist May 08, 06:18

Everything in USA is left handed oval,need to experience many types of course to prove how good horse really is. {nm} blaze223 May 08, 06:45

So You're Saying that Usain Bolt needs to Compete in the Decathlon to see how Good he Really is. {nm} Captain Obvious May 08, 06:57

Actually I was only talking horses but all Epsom winners should go to the Arc at Longchamp same distance different challange {nm} blaze223 May 08, 07:15

Perhaps all Epsom Derby winners should be required to run in the Cheltenham Gold Cup :p {nm} hyperzeitgeist May 08, 07:04

You could argue the same point about IndyCar Vs F1 which would be equally fatuous. {nm} hyperzeitgeist May 08, 07:15

Waiting for the Oxford - Cambridge Canoe Race. {nm} Captain Obvious May 08, 07:36

Rowing and it was last month so it will be a while....... {nm} blaze223 May 08, 08:06

Fastball - Right Over the Head. Need the Canoe Race to see how Good they Really are. {nm} Captain Obvious May 08, 08:13

Well done but considering how many sports Cambridge/Oxford compete in,this might happen. {nm} blaze223 May 08, 10:16

Waiting for the Phil Taylor - Raymond van Barneveld Lawn Darts Match to see how Good they Really are. {nm} Captain Obvious May 08, 08:16





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


Ice Cream Man (ICREM) 150000 12.07 (-0.14)          Ice Cream Man (ICREM) 149999 12.07 (-0.14)          Forgotten Island (FRGIS) 1 54.58 (+0.14)          Two Pianos (2PINO) 150000 0.82 (-0.09)          Two Pianos (2PINO) 149999 0.82 (-0.09)          Scandalous (SCAND) 150000 6.97 (-0.11)          Scandalous (SCAND) 149999 6.97 (-0.11)          The Memory Police (TMEMP) 150000 4.97 (-0.09)          The Memory Police (TMEMP) 149999 4.97 (-0.09)          Peaked (PEAKD) 150000 14.97 (-0.03)          Peaked (PEAKD) 149999 14.97 (-0.03)          Teen Titans (TEENT) 1000 35.03 (0.00)          Mother Mary (MMARY) 150000 7.64 (-0.18)          Mother Mary (MMARY) 149999 7.64 (-0.18)          Air Bud Returns (AIRB3) 149999 5.63 (+0.10)          Stop! That! Train! (STTRN) 150000 8.36 (+0.08)          Stop! That! Train! (STTRN) 149999 8.36 (+0.08)          Joni Mitchell biopic (JONIM) 150000 13.59 (+0.07)          Joni Mitchell biopic (JONIM) 149999 13.59 (+0.07)          A Tree is Blue (ATBLU) 150000 4.36 (+0.12)          Jack of Spades (JACSP) 1000 7.52 (0.00)          A Tree is Blue (ATBLU) 149999 4.36 (+0.12)          Seance on a Wet Afternoon (SOAWA) 150000 5.21 (+0.14)          Seance on a Wet Afternoon (SOAWA) 149999 5.21 (+0.14)          Billion Dollar Spy (BDSPY) 149999 6.31 (+0.33)          Ibelin (IBELN) 150000 6.13 (+0.32)          Ibelin (IBELN) 149999 6.13 (+0.32)          The Furious (FURIS) 150000 5.73 (+0.49)          The Furious (FURIS) 149999 5.73 (+0.49)          George Michael: The Faith Tour (GMTFT) 150000 8.27 (+0.62)          George Michael: The Faith Tour (GMTFT) 149999 8.27 (+0.62)          Jennifer's Body 2 (JBOD2) 150000 15.00 (0.00)          The Entertainment System Is Down (TESID) 1000 11.07 (0.00)          Lizard Music (LZMUS) 149999 18.23 (+0.99)          The Super Mario Galaxy Movie (MARI2) 434 471.20 (-6.15)          Jennifer's Body 2 (JBOD2) 150000 15.00 (0.00)          The Drama (TDRAM) 40000 35.84 (+0.17)          Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Mu (TMNT4) 60000 75.00 (+0.68)          Lizard Music (LZMUS) 555 18.23 (+0.99)          Whalefall (WHALF) 2000 24.21 (0.00)          Possession (PSESN) 5452 34.80 (-4.17)          The Comeback King (CMBKN) 50000 48.80 (+0.96)          Jennifer's Body 2 (JBOD2) 50000 15.00 (0.00)          Jennifer's Body 2 (JBOD2) 150000 15.00 (0.00)          Honeymoon With Harry (HWHRY) 1000 12.58 (0.00)          The Super Mario Galaxy Movie (MARI2) 110000 471.20 (-6.15)          Lee Cronin's The Mummy - Opening (TMUMY.OW) 100000 16.70 (-0.22)          Lee Cronin's The Mummy - Opening (TMUMY.OW) 100000 16.70 (-0.22)          Top Gun 3 (TOPG3) 61000 211.80 (+0.46)          Lee Cronin's The Mummy H$15 Call (TMUMY.CA) 25000 3.10 (-0.17)