HSX Forum

TVStocks, MusicStocks and Life

Hmmm... (spoilers)

Posted by: RogerMore on Mar 25, 05:52 in response to islndr's post oh Roger no.....

Nostalgia. Flawed Picard. Damaged characters. A story arc rather than an episode that happens and is never mentioned again. And probably because I haven't thought about it too deeply, I've just been watching it for entertainment.

I never really cared much for the Roddenberry ideals - I mean, it's great that he was optimistic and wanted to set a flag for what humans should aspire to be - but I never found his rules about no conflict between the characters, or statements about how humans have 'evolved' to be that realistic, so it doesn't bother me that Picard has gone against those rules.

I think the changes to Picard are realistic and true to the character. The end of a career can feel like a failure, especially when it ends with a failure, and he's had twenty years of mulling over regret.

The other points sound like nitpicking - the Romulan sister (nah, I can't remember her name) released all the Borg into space because otherwise they would attack her and all the other Romulans. With the Romulan homeworld destroyed, the warbirds were all probably off-world - there was an evacuation and the warbirds would have been part of that. The Romulans have a Borg cube because it was in Romulan space and they captured it.  Soji's a post-grad student/research fellow, so she's not so young that her twin sister can't have a research job of her own.

But for you, things I don't like. The F-bombs do feel gratuitous. "Ooh, we can swear in Star Trek now". And while I do like the take on older Picard, some things don't feel that realistic. Like, he doesn't talk with his former first officer for fifteen years? There are some really disturbing scenes (the ones involving suicide)

The big main plot is hard to follow - but I think you have it the wrong way around? The super duper synth life from millions of years ago nearly wiped out the organic life forms, and the surviving organic life forms left it as a message to their future generations. (I haven't seen last week's episode though?). Anyway, I'll reserving judgment until the end of the series.

Also, thinking about it, we just had a season of Discovery where Starfleet clandestinely decided to destroy anything that would lead to the development of artificial intelligence, and this season is all about research into AI and creating intelligent life forms?





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


Ice Cream Man (ICREM) 10000 8.47 (-0.04)          Dynamic Duo (DYDUO) 50000 91.53 (+4.18)          Ink (INK) 10000 13.84 (-0.10)          Call of Duty (CODUT) 150000 69.08 (-4.30)          Dolly (DOLLY) 150000 1.34 (-0.08)          From the World of John Wick: Cai (FJWCN) 150000 39.41 (+2.76)          Dynamic Duo (DYDUO) 150000 91.53 (+4.18)          The Incomer (INCOM) 150000 1.00 (0.00)          Helldivers (HELDV) 150000 99.34 (-2.55)          Heart Eyes 2 (HRTE2) 10000 18.19 (-0.29)          Dynamic Duo (DYDUO) 10000 91.53 (+4.18)          Mike & Nick & Nick & Alice (MNANA) 150000 1.26 (-0.50)          Pretty Lethal (BALOD) 150000 2.48 (-0.35)          Gundam (GUNDM) 20000 13.95 (+0.83)          Matthew Lillard (MLILL) 25000 77.25 (+3.28)          The Sheep Detectives (3BAGF) 3 45.21 (+2.73)          The Sheep Detectives (3BAGF) 3 45.21 (+2.73)          Mike & Nick & Nick & Alice (MNANA) 150000 1.26 (-0.50)          From the World of John Wick: Cai (FJWCN) 149999 39.41 (+2.76)          Mckenna Grace (MCGRA) 25000 81.00 (+1.69)          Mckenna Grace (MCGRA) 25000 81.00 (+1.69)          Pretty Lethal (BALOD) 150000 2.48 (-0.35)          Call of Duty (CODUT) 1 69.08 (-4.30)          Call of Duty (CODUT) 1 69.08 (-4.30)          From the World of John Wick: Cai (FJWCN) 1 39.41 (+2.76)          From the World of John Wick: Cai (FJWCN) 150000 39.41 (+2.76)          Mike & Nick & Nick & Alice (MNANA) 150000 1.26 (-0.50)          From the World of John Wick: Cai (FJWCN) 150000 39.41 (+2.76)          From the World of John Wick: Cai (FJWCN) 150000 39.41 (+2.76)          Dynamic Duo (DYDUO) 150000 91.53 (+4.18)          Dynamic Duo (DYDUO) 150000 91.53 (+4.18)          From the World of John Wick: Cai (FJWCN) 100000 39.41 (+2.76)          Mckenna Grace (MCGRA) 25000 81.00 (+1.69)          Mckenna Grace (MCGRA) 25000 81.00 (+1.69)          From the World of John Wick: Cai (FJWCN) 50000 39.41 (+2.76)          Helldivers (HELDV) 150000 99.34 (-2.55)          Joel McHale (JMCHA) 25000 27.63 (+0.13)          Baz Luhrmann (BLUHR) 1 71.72 (-0.07)          Baz Luhrmann (BLUHR) 25000 71.72 (-0.07)          Mckenna Grace (MCGRA) 25000 81.00 (+1.69)          Barbie Ferreira (BFERR) 25000 43.00 (0.00)          Celeste O’Connor (COCON) 25000 80.54 (+0.48)          Baz Luhrmann (BLUHR) 25000 71.72 (-0.07)          The Incomer (INCOM) 150000 1.00 (0.00)          The Incomer (INCOM) 150000 1.00 (0.00)          Baz Luhrmann (BLUHR) 25000 71.72 (-0.07)          Ramayana (RAMAY) 50000 7.69 (-0.07)          Baz Luhrmann (BLUHR) 1 71.72 (-0.07)          Ramayana (RAMAY) 50000 7.69 (-0.07)          Olivia Holt (OHOLT) 5000 12.66 (+0.12)