HSX Forum

Movies

Your hero is a *real* spy, whose primary mode is NOT SHOWING WHAT HE'S THINKING OR FEELING. That creates ...

Posted by: jjmarino on Jan 17, 16:31 in response to lobogotti's post spoliers...

special problems for a film. As a novel it was great ... because you're inside his head, and seeing the world through his very, very sharp eyes. As a TV miniseries in the 1970s, it was great, because they gave the audience lots and lots of time to watch him.

Dealing with George Smiley, excellent actual spy, in two hours of a visual medium is a serious challenge. I give them points for effort.

But last night I heard an interview with Oldman, and (great as his performance was), the way he talked about the character was much more interesting than the character on screen. Oldman understands things about Smiley that the movie never got across.

I went to see Tinker, Tailor... yesterday man the last 20 minutes are great but the rest....what a bore!!!!!!!! {nm} gogreenytd Jan 17, 09:19

I 100% agree. This was my kind of movie too and I just couldn't get into it. bloopster Jan 17, 09:53

I think it was the Script, it was just too complicated to follow, and the settings dint help either {nm} gogreenytd Jan 17, 10:12

I knew it... JMT-NL Jan 17, 09:56

had a few friends tell me the same. i loved it and oddly knew exactly what happened at the end (was asked to translate lobogotti Jan 17, 09:56

I'm with you!..seen it 3 times and going back for more....its a brilliant piece of movie-making. {nm} GLAMMGUY Jan 17, 10:15

indeed. I will say though that the film is not meant for wide release. could easily see it disappointing the masses. {nm} lobogotti Jan 17, 11:26

Too true, but none the less, an homage to the art of film making. {nm} GLAMMGUY Jan 17, 13:42

Question for you inside... spoilers bloopster Jan 17, 10:28

Spoilers gogreenytd Jan 17, 10:32

spoliers... lobogotti Jan 17, 11:19

also (spolier).... lobogotti Jan 17, 11:23

spoliers... lobogotti Jan 17, 11:24

Spoilers gogreenytd Jan 17, 11:26

oh absolutely. spolier lobogotti Jan 17, 11:27

Thanks Lobo and GoGreen. Spoiler bloopster Jan 17, 12:15

spoils RogerMore Jan 17, 14:33

Your hero is a *real* spy, whose primary mode is NOT SHOWING WHAT HE'S THINKING OR FEELING. That creates ... jjmarino Jan 17, 16:31

You make good points there ... Jane_Citizen Jan 17, 22:37

Spoilers jack foley Jan 17, 10:57

jack foley said it well and you guessed correctly. never read the book but plan to. {nm} lobogotti Jan 17, 11:20

Mostly only people weened on US action movie explication could say this masterpiece was boring, I guess.. {nm} Facto Jan 17, 13:43

I found The Lives of Others (spy/mole story set in Cold War Europe) to be 10x more interesting and captivating. bloopster Jan 17, 15:01

It's the best boring film I've seen since that goat-herder film. {nm} RufusS Jan 17, 09:59

But the 7:00+ long-take of the Easter procession from a high angle at the village intersection: a miraculous shot. (Link.) second gary Jan 17, 10:26





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


Ice Cream Man (ICREM) 29999 9.87 (+0.52)          Crime 101 (CRIM1) 2000 33.81 (0.00)          Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Mu (TMNT4) 20000 72.75 (-0.03)          Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Mu (TMNT4) 3000 72.75 (-0.03)          Evil Dead Wrath (EVLD7) 2000 38.34 (0.00)          You, Me & Tuscany aka Italianna (ITLIA) 1000 20.90 (-0.01)          Mutiny (MUTNY) 10000 21.17 (-0.03)          Jason Statham (JSTAT) 181 54.75 (0.00)          Paris Paramount aka Untitled Nan (PRSPM) 150000 40.89 (+0.01)          Romy & Michelle 2 (ROMY2) 20000 15.26 (+0.66)          The Bride! (BRIDE) 100000 43.28 (-0.93)          Wild Horse Nine (WILDH) 2000 8.16 (+0.06)          The Bride! (BRIDE) 50000 43.28 (-0.93)          Ice Cream Man (ICREM) 150000 9.87 (+0.52)          Deep Cuts (DPCUT) 10000 16.26 (+0.05)          Leviticus (LEVIT) 150000 5.75 (-0.35)          The Testament of Ann Lee (ANLEE) 150000 4.90 (-0.04)          Mutiny (MUTNY) 50000 21.17 (-0.03)          Mutiny (MUTNY) 100000 21.17 (-0.03)          Mutiny (MUTNY) 5000 21.17 (-0.03)          The Bride! (BRIDE) 50000 43.28 (-0.93)          Ice Cream Man (ICREM) 150000 9.87 (+0.52)          The Bride! (BRIDE) 50000 43.28 (-0.93)          What Happens At Night (WHANT) 13 35.86 (-0.41)          I Want Your Sex (IWYSX) 5000 5.73 (+0.34)          Reminders of Him (RMNDH) 150000 23.93 (-0.25)          Reminders of Him (RMNDH) 150000 23.93 (-0.25)          The Best is Yet to Come (TBYTC) 30 13.83 (-0.30)          The Masque Of The Red Death (MOTRD) 43 18.31 (+0.59)          The Masque Of The Red Death (MOTRD) 70000 18.31 (+0.59)          Face/Off 2 (FCOF2) 350 5.82 (+0.10)          Momo (MOMO) 10000 4.80 (-0.10)          Leviticus (LEVIT) 10000 5.75 (-0.35)          Baby Driver 2 (BDRV2) 800 2.73 (-0.02)          Do Not Enter aka Creepers (CREPR) 1000 1.81 (0.00)          What Happens At Night (WHANT) 10000 35.86 (-0.41)          Is God Is (ISGOD) 149999 11.09 (+0.43)          What Happens At Night (WHANT) 10000 35.86 (-0.41)          Reminders of Him (RMNDH) 4000 23.93 (-0.25)          Is God Is (ISGOD) 150000 11.09 (+0.43)          A Head Full of Ghosts (AHFOG) 59 3.44 (-0.15)          Leviticus (LEVIT) 30000 5.75 (-0.35)          Ice Cream Man (ICREM) 149999 9.87 (+0.52)          Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Mu (TMNT4) 200 72.75 (-0.03)          Ice Cream Man (ICREM) 150000 9.87 (+0.52)          King Snake (KSNAK) 10000 14.02 (+0.11)          The Masque Of The Red Death (MOTRD) 149999 18.31 (+0.59)          The Masque Of The Red Death (MOTRD) 150000 18.31 (+0.59)          Romy & Michelle 2 (ROMY2) 149999 15.26 (+0.66)          Is God Is (ISGOD) 20000 11.09 (+0.43)