HSX Forum

Movies

It's also ignorant in not admitting the fundamental changes in our culture that make this statistic interesting but not worth much.

Posted by: goodvibe61 on Jan 02, 11:25 in response to hyperzeitgeist's post You are the one displaying your ignorance if you believe...

While it is always fascinating to compare real tickets sold and box office,  fans have been doing it forever, the bottom line is the amount of significant differences within our culture and world wide culture is simply too significant fo this statistic to be worth much. 

Some of the posters in this thread have already pointed out some of the many statistical elements that weaken an argument either way, but suffice to say there are so many important differences between "then" and "now" it renders the comparison nearly worthless.

Regarding your use of "perspective", well, perspective cuts several ways in this case, and simply pulling one number without including the shortcomings of the comparison limits the effectiveness of the comparison.

A little bit of perspective amidst all the 'Star Wars' hysteria... hyperzeitgeist Jan 02, 02:22

I don't see the point. It's been out for a couple of weeks, vs. many years for the others. If those stats are meant to take some shine off edzep - Port Monkey! Jan 02, 06:29

The inflation argument is ignorant. No one adjusts apples revenue for inflation to compare to 1950s corps, and why not judge all variables Fitch3k Jan 02, 06:41

You are the one displaying your ignorance if you believe that inflation isn't relevant... {nm} hyperzeitgeist Jan 02, 07:04

The point is that people are still watching 'Gone With The Wind'. Do you think that will be true of STAR7 in 75 years? {nm} hyperzeitgeist Jan 02, 07:06

They're still watching STAR4 42 years later, so probably :) {nm} Chateau_du_Mal_Voisin Jan 02, 07:08

er... 38 years. {nm} Chateau_du_Mal_Voisin Jan 02, 07:09

The thing GWTW & STAR4 have in common is that they are both genuine cultural phenomena. STAR7: Over-hyped retread. {nm} hyperzeitgeist Jan 02, 07:12

Usually people bring up "The Hidden Fortress" and Flash Gordon serials when assessing the originality of "Star Wars." So. . . second gary Jan 02, 07:33

Who cares? BO success is not determined by movie quality. People wanted Star Wars content, they got it. {nm} slappydavid Jan 02, 07:42

Tell me then what does it matter to Disney what Gone With the Wind was able to make over 70 years? {nm} Fitch3k Jan 02, 07:07

Your argument contains a logical fallacy. {nm} hyperzeitgeist Jan 02, 07:13

It's also ignorant in not admitting the fundamental changes in our culture that make this statistic interesting but not worth much. goodvibe61 Jan 02, 11:25

Relevant quote from the article inside (emphasis added). The Force-Ghost of DTravel Jan 02, 09:48

We get it, you hate SW, move on. The next decade is going to really suck for you. {nm} skunkrunner Jan 02, 09:57

+1. {nm} Captain Obvious Jan 02, 10:17

Wow! A +1 from the troll...you're really in exalted company. {nm} hyperzeitgeist Jan 02, 10:23

Please Stop TROLLING. {nm} Captain Obvious Jan 02, 10:37

I see what you did there...very clever /s {nm} hyperzeitgeist Jan 02, 12:07

Sorry to disappoint you but 'Star Wars' doesn't exist in my universe so it's hardly likely to impact on my decade... {nm} hyperzeitgeist Jan 02, 10:20

Come back and tell me how much fun you're having after you've been force-fed another half dozen helpings :p {nm} hyperzeitgeist Jan 02, 10:22

What universe is that? Star Wars is the undisputed Alpha and Omega of modern American cinema. {nm} skunkrunner Jan 02, 10:31

I think you need to get out more :D {nm} hyperzeitgeist Jan 02, 12:09

Sorry to hear that. If you dont appreciate Star Wars it could be said you really dont appreciate films.nm vindog Jan 02, 10:35

+1. {nm} Captain Obvious Jan 02, 10:41

Yes my point being films like Star Wars and Indiana Jones are the heart of the business. vindog Jan 02, 11:37

"Business" being the operative word. {nm} hyperzeitgeist Jan 02, 12:01

Of course we all have to make a living vindog Jan 02, 14:09

I've probably appreciated more films than you've had hot dinners. {nm} hyperzeitgeist Jan 02, 12:20

if it doesn't exist in your universe, then why are you posting about it? {nm} JDolphin Jan 02, 11:41

Because this is (supposedly) a movie forum on a website devoted to movies that currently seems obsessed with one film? {nm} hyperzeitgeist Jan 02, 12:03

It's as much a box office site as a movie site, and so yes, this forum is obsessed with the movie having the largest box office impact now. {nm} goodvibe61 Jan 02, 12:55

I can appreciate that but as others have pointed out there are other investments that offer a far better ROI, yet they barely get a look in. {nm} hyper_2016YTD Jan 02, 12:59

Just like the real stock market. :D {nm} The Force-Ghost of DTravel Jan 02, 18:33

Then why don't you point those out instead of trying to post misplaced and inaccurate "perspective" {nm} JDolphin Jan 02, 20:37





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


Your Mother Your Mother Your Mot (YOURM) 150000 7.00 (+2.84)          Tom and Jerry: Forbidden Compass (TMJR2) 150000 19.49 (+3.16)          Samantha Morton (SMORT) 25000 82.42 (+0.89)          Tom and Jerry: Forbidden Compass (TMJR2) 150000 19.49 (+3.16)          The Musical (MSCAL) 150000 1.00 (0.00)          Company (COMPN) 145000 8.00 (0.00)          Sam Claflin (SCLAF) 25000 16.71 (+0.10)          Jason Clarke (JCLAR) 25000 73.54 (+1.00)          Jason Clarke (JCLAR) 25000 73.54 (+1.00)          James Bond 26 (JB26) 5000 169.10 (+0.44)          Dennis (DENIS) 1000 4.93 (-0.11)          Atonement (ATONM) 10245 1.77 (-0.05)          Dynamic Duo (DYDUO) 150000 126.11 (+2.39)          Avengers: Doomsday (AVNG5) 80867 555.71 (+1.60)          Atonement (ATONM) 10467 1.77 (-0.05)          X-Men aka Mutants (XMEN8) 150000 183.92 (+3.16)          Atonement (ATONM) 300 1.77 (-0.05)          Tom and Jerry: Forbidden Compass (TMJR2) 150000 19.49 (+3.16)          Tom and Jerry: Forbidden Compass (TMJR2) 149999 19.49 (+3.16)          Sam Claflin (SCLAF) 25000 16.71 (+0.10)          The Matrix 5 (MTRX5) 140000 28.68 (+0.04)          Avengers: Doomsday (AVNG5) 8185 555.71 (+1.60)          Them (THEM) 149000 31.86 (-0.09)          The Gauntlet (GNTLT) 140000 32.90 (-0.09)          Constantine 2 (CNST2) 140000 30.52 (-0.11)          By Any Means (CI34) 10000 25.97 (-0.15)          Horizon Zero Dawn (HRIZD) 110000 30.81 (-0.04)          Coyote vs. ACME (CVACM) 25000 53.00 (+0.55)          Avengers: Secret Wars (AVNG6) 10000 504.38 (+2.36)          Coyote vs. ACME (CVACM) 50000 53.00 (+0.55)          Coyote vs. ACME (CVACM) 10000 53.00 (+0.55)          Avengers: Doomsday (AVNG5) 2000 555.71 (+1.60)          The Goonies 2 (GONI2) 130000 48.77 (-0.18)          The Musical (MSCAL) 150000 1.00 (0.00)          Company (COMPN) 150000 8.00 (0.00)          Ali G: Who Iz I? (ALIG2) 50000 21.32 (-0.09)          10 Lives (10LIV) 70000 1.73 (-0.04)          Spider-Man: Brand New Day (SPID9) 1000 634.24 (+17.39)          Finding Emily (CCEML) 60000 4.42 (-0.06)          Super Troopers 3 (STRO3) 150000 22.93 (-1.27)          PAW Patrol: The Dino Movie H$20 (PAWP3.PU) 25000 2.89 (+0.10)          The End of Oak Street H$30 Put (FLWVS.PU) 25000 3.62 (+0.30)          Ice Cream Man - Opening Weekend (ICREM.OW) 100000 4.69 (-0.38)          The Shrinking of Treehorn (TSOTH) 375 0.26 (0.00)          The Shrinking of Treehorn (TSOTH) 4000 0.26 (0.00)          Belly of the Beast (BELYB) 130000 2.76 (-0.02)          Super Troopers 3 H$15 Put (STRO3.PU) 4963 3.48 (+0.14)          Bratz (BRAT2) 108000 11.82 (-0.16)          Your Mother Your Mother Your Mot (YOURM) 149999 7.00 (+2.84)          The Memory Police (TMEMP) 339 3.79 (-0.02)