HSX Forum

Movies

Debateable with this one. {nm}

Posted by: lhayes37 on Jan 27, 11:56 in response to Andre C's post QLATI in Chicago

THR: Kareem Abdul-Jabbar: Why Black People Are Invisible to Oscar Voters Antibody Jan 27, 09:42

Besides Jamie Foxx in Colateral can you think of a nominated Black actor that has been nominated for a role that didn't require being Black? {nm} lhayes37 Jan 27, 10:40

DWASH Flight {nm} Antibody Jan 27, 10:46

and Philadelphia, although it gave his character's homophobia a deeper layer {nm} slipping jimmy Jan 27, 10:48

Denzel wasn't nominated for Philadelphia. {nm} Andre C Jan 27, 11:32

Still don't understand that. {nm} leo21 Jan 27, 15:19

DWASH Training Day {nm} Bleachigo Jan 27, 11:36

His character had to be black in South Central. {nm} Antibody Jan 27, 11:55

Disagree. RDUVA didn't have to be black in Colors. {nm} Chest Rockwell Jan 27, 13:16

that was probably a good thing for Robert Duvall then {nm} slipping jimmy Jan 27, 17:46

Thanks, forgot about that one. {nm} lhayes37 Jan 27, 11:56

VDAVI in Doubt? {nm} Roger More Jan 27, 11:27

Doubt was based on a play. In the production the character is Black. So I respectfully disagree on this one. {nm} lhayes37 Jan 27, 12:04

I can see that (though they could have whitewashed it) {nm} Roger More Jan 27, 13:19

QLATI in Chicago {nm} Andre C Jan 27, 11:31

Debateable with this one. lhayes37 Jan 27, 11:56

what's your thinkng behind this? debatable how? {nm} CSBD Jan 27, 12:01

The original production starred Mary McCarty who was a white actress. So after some research, I agree with you. Thank you for your input. {nm} lhayes37 Jan 27, 12:07

all depends on how you view race being a requirement for a role {nm} lapuckfan Jan 27, 11:33

Well like when Nupita was nominated the actor had to be Black. Like when Spike Lee was casting Malcom X, the actor had to be Black. {nm} lhayes37 Jan 27, 12:01

Halle Berry Monster's Ball {nm} Bleachigo Jan 27, 11:38

Louis Gossett Jr. Officer and a gentleman ...he should have got another nod for IRON EAGLES {nm} Bleachigo Jan 27, 11:40

She had to be black, because her husband was an imprisoned black man and BBTHO's dad was a racist. {nm} Antibody Jan 27, 12:02

Agree. BBTHO's shift on acceptance is a critical part of his character. {nm} Chest Rockwell Jan 27, 13:18

DWASH in Training Day? JFOXX in Collateral? {nm} Chest Rockwell Jan 27, 11:40

Yes thank you. {nm} lhayes37 Jan 27, 11:59

Morgan Freeman in Shawshank Redemption {nm} RazorHawk Jan 27, 11:40

Morgan Freeman in Million Dollar Baby {nm} RazorHawk Jan 27, 11:42

Jaye Davidson in The Crying Game {nm} RazorHawk Jan 27, 11:43

Samuel L Jackson in Pulp Fiction {nm} RazorHawk Jan 27, 11:43

Wait Mr. Wolf writes down (black) by Jules name lol... {nm} lhayes37 Jan 27, 11:59

+1 whatever happned to Jaye? Frog and Scorpion story FTW! {nm} lhayes37 Jan 27, 12:03

Yeah both of Morgan's characters were written as whites in the books. Red was Irish in Rita Hayworth and Shawshank Redemption. {nm} lhayes37 Jan 27, 11:56

"OK....well except for those...." {nm} Bleachigo Jan 27, 11:41

Samuel "BAMF" Jackson in Pulp Fiction {nm} Bleachigo Jan 27, 11:43

Cuba Gooding Jr. as Rod Tidwell in Jerry Maguire {nm} Bleachigo Jan 27, 11:46

No. NFL WRs are 99% Black so I disagree here. A Black actor was required. {nm} lhayes37 Jan 27, 11:57

That's inaccurate and sounds racist...he could have been Australian, Hispanic or even Canadian {nm} Bleachigo Jan 27, 12:17

aren't you late for a Trump rally somewhere? {nm} slipping jimmy Jan 27, 12:25

lol I'am a Hillary Campaign Volunteer (both times), why so quick to attack when we might actually be on the same side? {nm} Bleachigo Jan 27, 13:29

You are calling lhayes37 racist? lol lhayes37 = famous ..... RazorHawk Jan 27, 12:32

Listen, I played the game. I know the racial breakdown of football teams. 48 of the top 50 WRs in terms of stats in 2015 were Black...96% lhayes37 Jan 27, 12:56

So why could character NOT be based on one of them? {nm} Bleachigo Jan 27, 13:31

Ok, we'll agree to disagree on this one. {nm} lhayes37 Jan 27, 15:31

Louis Gossett Jr. Officer and a Gentleman. When Gossett was cast they were going to re-write the part for a black actor but... mrbeankc Jan 28, 01:41





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


Charlie the Wonderdog (CWDOG) 4800 1.45 (+0.01)          Charlie the Wonderdog (CWDOG) 200 1.45 (+0.01)          Noah Jupe (NJUPE) 25000 59.66 (+1.40)          Heel (HEEL) 150000 1.00 (0.00)          Will Arnett (WARNE) 25000 33.18 (-2.22)          Naomi Ackie (NACKI) 25000 17.81 (-0.30)          Will Ferrell (WFERR) 25000 106.54 (-0.57)          Alien sequel (ALIE6) 4000 71.83 (+0.02)          Slanted (SLANT) 150000 4.44 (-0.24)          Dune: Part Three aka Dune: Messi (DUNE3) 1000 235.41 (+0.77)          Slanted (SLANT) 150000 4.44 (-0.24)          Nicolas Cage (NCAGE) 25000 16.51 (+0.19)          Nicolas Cage (NCAGE) 25000 16.51 (+0.19)          Wishful Thinking (WSHFT) 150000 3.79 (+0.33)          Wishful Thinking (WSHFT) 150000 3.79 (+0.33)          A Tree is Blue (ATBLU) 150000 4.96 (+0.75)          A Tree is Blue (ATBLU) 150000 4.96 (+0.75)          Meghann Fahy (MFAHY) 25000 5.43 (+0.06)          Over Your Dead Body aka The Trip (TETRP) 150000 7.08 (+0.60)          Over Your Dead Body aka The Trip (TETRP) 150000 7.08 (+0.60)          Ric Roman Waugh (RRWAU) 25000 26.97 (+0.18)          Disclosure Day (SKIES) 1000 162.98 (+0.34)          Heel (HEEL) 150000 1.00 (0.00)          A Tree is Blue (ATBLU) 150000 4.96 (+0.75)          A Tree is Blue (ATBLU) 150000 4.96 (+0.75)          Day Drinker (DRNKR) 150000 13.27 (+1.68)          Day Drinker (DRNKR) 150000 13.27 (+1.68)          The Custom of the Country (TCOTC) 150000 19.22 (+2.55)          The Custom of the Country (TCOTC) 150000 19.22 (+2.55)          The Housekeeper (HSKPR) 150000 4.47 (-0.33)          Amy Madigan (AMADI) 25000 34.11 (+0.10)          The Housekeeper (HSKPR) 150000 4.47 (-0.33)          The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the (HGAM6) 1000 178.92 (-0.16)          Amy Madigan (AMADI) 25000 34.11 (+0.10)          Slanted (SLANT) 150000 4.44 (-0.24)          Troy Kotsur (TKOTS) 25000 8.39 (-0.52)          Slanted (SLANT) 150000 4.44 (-0.24)          Troy Kotsur (TKOTS) 25000 8.39 (-0.52)          Spider-Man: Brand New Day (SPID9) 1000 420.81 (-0.02)          A Tree is Blue (ATBLU) 150000 4.96 (+0.75)          A Tree is Blue (ATBLU) 150000 4.96 (+0.75)          Will Arnett (WARNE) 25000 33.18 (-2.22)          Will Arnett (WARNE) 25000 33.18 (-2.22)          Laura Dern (LDERN) 25000 72.97 (-0.36)          Avengers: Secret Wars (AVNG6) 1000 473.90 (+1.00)          Laura Dern (LDERN) 25000 72.97 (-0.36)          The Strangers: Chapter 3 - Openi (STRN5.OW) 25000 5.07 (-0.43)          The Strangers: Chapter 3 - Openi (STRN5.OW) 25000 5.07 (-0.43)          Bradley Cooper (BCOOP) 25000 126.91 (-0.02)          Bradley Cooper (BCOOP) 25000 126.91 (-0.02)