HSX Forum

Movies

So are you saying Walwart clearanced TFA? Still downward regardless. It'd be nice if disclosed easier, publicly.

Posted by: Baron_Darcon2017 on Jun 06, 22:17 in response to Moviesnob's post I can tell you whats non proprietary - hard good sales...

I don't shop at Walmart, only purchase from Best Buy.   I know some places did place TFA in clearnace and bargin bins from youtube video channels. 

So who's lying?  Are studios inflating their numbers of sales? Are retailers? Are both?  Wouldn't that amount to fraud by misleading shareholders?

My local newspaper and Marvel Comics I know would inflate and overship numbers but hide the charge back numbers.  Is it the same principle?

The-Numbers.com TLJ vs TFA sales of DVD-Bluray #s $45M v. $119.3M for first 3 week... a 37% of TFA sales as reported. Baron_Darcon2017 Jun 06, 20:32

Wow would love too see how now these last Jedi lovers are going to defend this !! bunty_ketti Jun 06, 20:47

because those numbers arent remotely accurate. They are estimates. Moviesnob Jun 06, 20:51

Can you supply us with accurate # for all 3 movies to compare? {nm} Baron_Darcon2017 Jun 06, 21:16

I can tell you whats non proprietary - hard good sales are down 25% since Force Awakens came out. Moviesnob Jun 06, 21:26

So are you saying Walwart clearanced TFA? Still downward regardless. It'd be nice if disclosed easier, publicly. Baron_Darcon2017 Jun 06, 22:17

Box office is the only sales stat that's public. I've looked for others and it's all very closely held, so much so that I'm surprised MattW Jun 06, 22:52

To what -- other than bigotry and backwardness among disaffected, can't-keep-up yahoos -- do you ascribe these numbers? Thanks {nm} DTXbro Jun 06, 22:19

Simple... Disney didn't produce what the FANS wanted! Disney destroyed the OT, destroyed the legacy of Luke, Leia, Han, Lando etc. Baron_Darcon2017 Jun 06, 23:32

TFA made $2B worldwide and is the biggest film in US Box office history. But fans hated it, sure. {nm} numbersix_99 Jun 07, 01:14

Fans had hope then, LusacFilms hadn't gone full throated attacking fans. TLJ made TFA worse and wrecked the it all {nm} Baron_Darcon2017 Jun 07, 09:36

The fans who have revised their feeling on TFA are by far a massive minority. Where is the evidence? {nm} numbersix_99 Jun 07, 12:47

WIRED: Star Wars and the Battle of the Ever-More-Toxic Fan Culture Wellespring Jun 07, 03:46

TFA and TLJ might be flawed and divisive, but they are still superior to the boring, unnesscary, mundane prequel trilogy. {nm} bennyg1985 Jun 07, 05:43

The entitled view of "manbabies" pretty well characterized by that BMD article. Antibody Jun 07, 09:47

Disaffected, belligerent, stale-thinking, marginalized wingnuts are among my favorite wingnuts {nm} DTXbro Jun 07, 11:09

Empire did less business than Star Wars, Clones less than Menace. I sense a trend. {nm} soupcam Jun 07, 08:18

Here is one more TLJ number for you: 5,000 (approximate). bennyg1985 Jun 07, 05:39

Don't waste your time, these people have people brainwashed, they are defending the undefendable. {nm} Filmstardust Jun 07, 07:31

Please explain how my response is an indication of being brainwashed. He asked me a question and I answered it. {nm} Moviesnob Jun 07, 07:48

Thanks MovieSnob your responses were informative, some others are zealous denials of the state of SW. {nm} Baron_Darcon2017 Jun 07, 09:02

No, you ignored my responses which discredit your theories. To be clear, there's no data that I've seen that proves a theory that SW has Moviesnob Jun 07, 09:08

Solo Box Office, TLJ Box Office, polls on SW forums, toy , merch and video game sale declines all are evidence Baron_Darcon2017 Jun 07, 10:01

TLJ box office? 1.3B worldwide, 11th biggest film of all time (unadjusted). Yes it made less, but it's a sequel, which tend to drop. {nm} numbersix_99 Jun 07, 12:49

TLK largest sequel drop ever $700M. Solo currently at 273M and 492 worldwide all time. Solo will come in 900M less than TLJ {nm} Baron_Darcon2017 Jun 07, 17:42

Does this include online retailers? Amazon didn't start selling TLJ until approx. 3-4 weeks after its street date {nm} mantleclinic Jun 07, 08:35

Video Stock Exchange Wellespring Jun 07, 08:52





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


The Fall Guy (FALGY) 75000 119.61 (-0.87)          The Fall Guy (FALGY) 2500 119.61 (-0.87)          The Fall Guy (FALGY) 12500 119.61 (-0.87)          Monkey Man (MNKYM) 1 23.30 (+0.06)          Monkey Man (MNKYM) 50000 23.30 (+0.06)          Monkey Man (MNKYM) 50000 23.30 (+0.06)          Monkey Man (MNKYM) 50000 23.30 (+0.06)          Fred Hechinger (FHECH) 25000 32.46 (-0.25)          Fred Hechinger (FHECH) 25000 32.46 (-0.25)          Nonnas (NONAS) 20000 8.79 (+0.01)          Julianne Nicholson (JUNIC) 25000 7.55 (+0.05)          Maya Hawke (MHAWK) 25000 55.40 (+0.16)          Ariana DeBose (ADEBO) 25000 31.76 (-0.25)          The Phoenician Scheme (TPSCH) 26000 20.72 (+0.01)          Ariana DeBose (ADEBO) 25000 31.76 (-0.25)          Alex Garland (AGARL) 25000 32.02 (-0.12)          Perfect Days (PRFCD) 49999 3.56 (+0.03)          My Ex-Friend's Wedding (MEXFW) 26000 22.37 (+0.01)          Octavia Spencer (OSPEN) 25000 38.92 (+0.12)          Perfect Days (PRFCD) 50000 3.56 (+0.03)          Perfect Days (PRFCD) 50000 3.56 (+0.03)          Perfect Days (PRFCD) 50000 3.56 (+0.03)          Jason Schwartzman (JSCHW) 25000 81.51 (+0.25)          Ben Wang (BWANG) 25000 26.10 (+0.12)          Diego Calva (DCALV) 25000 6.04 (+0.05)          Russell Crowe (RCROW) 25000 61.96 (-0.50)          The Bride! (BRIDE) 30000 64.31 (+0.08)          Russell Crowe (RCROW) 25000 61.96 (-0.50)          Addison Rae (ARAE) 25000 22.45 (+0.12)          The Exorcism (TGTWP) 150000 1.59 (+0.02)          Spider-Man Untitled (SPID9) 1400 314.99 (-0.25)          Kiki Layne (KLAYN) 25000 23.53 (-0.25)          Kiki Layne (KLAYN) 25000 23.53 (-0.25)          Danny Ramirez (DARAM) 25000 97.51 (-0.25)          Danny Ramirez (DARAM) 25000 97.51 (-0.25)          Horizon: An American Saga Chapte (HORZ2) 43400 62.64 (+0.09)          Georgina Campbell (GCAMP) 25000 20.72 (+0.25)          Georgina Campbell (GCAMP) 25000 20.72 (+0.25)          Young Woman and the Sea (YWATS) 6000 17.34 (+0.09)          Madden (MADEN) 12000 30.80 (+0.17)          Separate Rooms (SEPRM) 150000 5.81 (-0.19)          East Bay (EASTB) 150000 0.95 (-0.05)          Kingdom of the Planet of the Ape (APES4.CA) 25000 1.19 (-0.04)          Kingdom of the Planet of the Ape (APES4.CA) 25000 1.19 (-0.04)          The Fall Guy H$50 Call (FALGY.CA) 25000 2.00 (-0.04)          The Fall Guy H$50 Call (FALGY.CA) 25000 2.00 (-0.04)          The Fall Guy - Opening Weekend (FALGY.OW) 100000 42.30 (-0.26)          The Fall Guy - Opening Weekend (FALGY.OW) 100000 42.30 (-0.26)          Kingdom of the Planet of the Ape (APES4.PU) 25000 2.99 (+0.04)          Kingdom of the Planet of the Ape (APES4.PU) 25000 2.99 (+0.04)