HSX Forum

Movies

I've thought about this for a while now, and feel that I must respectfully disagree.

Posted by: Rocket123YTD (a.k.a del_HYE_Rocket123YTD) on Mar 30, 15:01 in response to mickpix's post it's Pixar. it's not Merchant Ivory. Any twenty minutes...

I didn't want to post in haste, so I thought about what you said.  Monsters Inc. was not a funny movie, per se.  Great story line and very interesting, with excellent graphics and voice overs.  Cars, not funny, again per se.  Up, NOT funny at all. 

There are funny moments in these movies, but I would not categorize Cars or Monsters Inc as comedies.  I watched the trailer again and found the plot and story line interesting.  The graphics are outstanding and the voice overs appear to be good.  I believe that I am Pro-Cars 2 at this point, as I have decided that it does not need to be funny to be good.

Incidentally, my daughter laughed her a$$ off for a good 10 minutes at the start of Wall-E.  I thought she was going to get lock jaw!  But the movie on the whole, was not funny; in fact it was more of a romance/tear jerker.

Given my epiphany, I must now ask SS, what criteria constitutes a "Big Time" Bomb?  If it's laughter from the audience, then I can go against that.  If it is bad graphics, poor voice overs, terrible plot, etc... then there may be something to reconsider.

Please advise.  Thx.

Disney, CinemaCon - updates PVL Admin Mar 29, 22:56

Cars 2 bombed BIG TIME at CinemaCon... I think there was one laugh during the 20 minutes shown... this is PIXAR we're talking about. {nm} secretstalker Mar 29, 22:59

Maybe it wasn't meant to be a funny twenty. Could you decipher an attempt at humor and it just failed?or were there no lines? {nm} PVL Admin Mar 29, 23:30

it's Pixar. it's not Merchant Ivory. Any twenty minutes of a Cars movie should be a laugh a minute {nm} mickpix Mar 29, 23:43

Pixar isn't pure comedy, Wall-E had very few laughs, Up had long serious stretches... {nm} lapuckfan Mar 30, 07:12

"He p$#@ed in what?!?!" {nm} Richard In G Mar 30, 09:40

I've thought about this for a while now, and feel that I must respectfully disagree. Rocket123YTD Mar 30, 15:01

Yeah, totally agree... ;) JK {nm} PVL Admin Mar 30, 15:05

Surprising horlicks Mar 30, 05:05

Yes, well, there's a good chance that maybe Cars is a concept that works better in 5 to 10 minute increments. {nm} secretstalker Mar 30, 06:12

I don't recall Cars being a comedy. {nm} AgentEvil Mar 30, 05:13

Were there kids in the audience? The first one wasn't that well received by adults either, but kids gobbled it up. {nm} BionicMoron Mar 30, 05:18

Cars made $244M Domestic, $218M Foreign, $245M in DVD Sales...to do anything less would be quite a blow for Pixar lobogotti Mar 30, 06:30

True, but it's the OW that matters right now. How much higher than 60 can we expect it's growth? 80? 100? {nm} PVL Admin Mar 30, 10:32

Toy Story 1-2-3 went 29-57-110, or close to doubling with each sequel. BionicMoron Mar 30, 10:38

I agree, Cars is not Toy Story. So, a 30% increase is not over-reaching? {nm} PVL Admin Mar 30, 10:59

I seem to remember the first CARS (the full thing) going through similar long stretches of silence back at ShoWest. {nm} notfabio Mar 30, 07:11

gee thanks - wonder which way you're holding the stock? {nm} click999 Mar 30, 08:51

and how much did Cars actually open to ,,, IMO overvalued {nm} bunty_ketti Mar 30, 01:12

OW= 60.1; Total Domestic = $ 244.1 Domestic PVL Admin Mar 30, 01:21

IMHO Cars2 will be the first critical and box office dissapoinment for PIXAR, when you make a decision based on gogreen Mar 30, 11:12

I seem to recall people saying that CARS would be Pixar's first box office dissapointment as well. {nm} Hooray360 Mar 30, 11:36

I doubt it'll be a financial flop, but it certainly isn't looking like an awards contender {nm} tribefan695 Mar 30, 12:13

Muppets kinda flopped too LariatSam Mar 30, 15:56

Muppets weren't big film grossers to begin with. {nm} Antibody Mar 30, 16:08





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


The Secret Agent (TSAGN) 150000 3.56 (+0.05)          The Riders (RIDER) 150000 36.55 (+2.06)          The Bride! (BRIDE) 10000 44.73 (+0.12)          The Custom of the Country (TCOTC) 50000 18.17 (+1.50)          Will Ferrell (WFERR) 25000 106.54 (-0.57)          CBS: Sheriff Country (SHERFC) 24900 9.67 (+0.06)          Will Ferrell (WFERR) 25000 106.54 (-0.57)          The Custom of the Country (TCOTC) 50000 18.17 (+1.50)          ABC: 9-1-1 Nashville (911NAS) 24900 11.30 (+0.05)          The Custom of the Country (TCOTC) 50000 18.17 (+1.50)          Will Arnett (WARNE) 25000 33.18 (-2.22)          I Can Only Imagine 2 (ICOI2) 21000 47.69 (-0.02)          Will Arnett (WARNE) 25000 33.18 (-2.22)          CBS: DMV (DMVCBS) 24900 14.47 (+0.05)          The Custom of the Country (TCOTC) 50000 18.17 (+1.50)          The Custom of the Country (TCOTC) 50000 18.17 (+1.50)          CBS: Boston Blue (BOSBLU) 24900 15.13 (0.00)          CBS: Boston Blue (BOSBLU) 24900 15.13 (0.00)          The Custom of the Country (TCOTC) 50000 18.17 (+1.50)          Troy Kotsur (TKOTS) 25000 8.39 (-0.52)          Troy Kotsur (TKOTS) 25000 8.39 (-0.52)          Troy Kotsur (TKOTS) 25000 8.39 (-0.52)          Troy Kotsur (TKOTS) 25000 8.39 (-0.52)          Ric Roman Waugh (RRWAU) 25000 26.97 (+0.18)          Corporate Retreat (CRPRT) 10000 5.08 (+0.01)          The Asian Fund (ASIAN) 20000 27.20 (-0.55)          The Animal Fund (ZOO) 20000 20.25 (+0.16)          Roman Griffin Davis (RGDAV) 25000 36.60 (+0.01)          Noah Jupe (NJUPE) 25000 59.66 (+1.40)          FOX: Best Medicine (BESMED) 24900 8.86 (0.00)          NBC: The Fall and Rise of Reggie (FARORD) 25000 10.08 (+0.37)          CBS: Marshals (YMARSH) 25000 11.76 (+0.08)          CBS: CIA (CIACBS) 25000 9.79 (0.00)          The Housekeeper (HSKPR) 150000 4.41 (-0.39)          ABC: RJ Decker (RJDECK) 25000 9.33 (+0.25)          Mark Ruffalo (MRUFF) 25000 68.43 (-36.24)          Laura Dern (LDERN) 25000 72.97 (-0.36)          Laura Dern (LDERN) 25000 72.97 (-0.36)          Wuthering Heights (WUTHR) 1000 88.98 (+1.06)          Josh O'Connor (JOOCO) 25000 10.83 (-0.35)          Josh O'Connor (JOOCO) 25000 10.83 (-0.35)          Will Ferrell (WFERR) 25000 106.54 (-0.57)          Gerard Butler (GBUTL) 25000 68.11 (+1.27)          Gerard Butler (GBUTL) 25000 68.11 (+1.27)          Mark Ruffalo (MRUFF) 25000 68.43 (-36.24)          Morena Baccarin (MBACC) 25000 54.41 (-0.59)          Full Phil (FPHIL) 149998 4.73 (+0.95)          Full Phil (FPHIL) 150000 4.73 (+0.95)          Josh O'Connor (JOOCO) 25000 10.83 (-0.35)          In Cold Light (INCLT) 150000 0.99 (-0.04)