HSX Forum

TVStocks, MusicStocks and Life

My understanding is that this bill wouldn't specifically alter any laws, but it includes a general provision that says something like...

Posted by: RogerMore on Mar 28, 16:49 in response to shadowking's post I assume the goal of the bill is to alter/ammend existing...

"the government shall not place a substantial burden on the exercise of someone's religious belief, and if it does it has to demonstrate a compelling government interest and that it is imposing the burden in the least intrusive way".

It's very general, so it's hard to spell out exactly what that means (what's a substantial burden? what's a compelling government interest? how do you demonstrate 'least intrusive'?). But the concern is that it will enable discrimination against certain groups of people - particularly LGBT people, given the other provisions of the bill (eg - no one shall be forced to attend a same sex marriage against their will, as though that's a serious concern which requires a law to prevent it) - and opens cans of worms everywere (eg can a pharmacist refuse to fill a prescription for a morning after pill based on a religious objection? can they refuse to stock contraceptives in their store for the same reason? can a state or city official refuse to issue a same sex marriage licence? what about a marriage licence for an inter-racial couple? etc)

I don't believe GA includes sexuality as a protected class in their anti-discrimination laws, and this is one of the reasons why the GA bill has received so much attention - there would be legal protection for those who want to discriminate, and less legal recourse for those who would be discriminated against.

Absolute garbage if one can discriminate against or fire for some supposed "sincerely held beliefs". Period. {nm} islander Mar 28, 09:39

I don't agree with the firing aspect; however, are you saying businesses should never be able to refuse services to another? RollingThunder Mar 28, 09:51

As I understand it, that's not the controversial part of the bill. Of course religious orgs should be able to decline to perform same-sex RogerMore Mar 28, 10:11

I agree with your very well-written points. On that level, I do see how people would abuse the real intent of the Bill. RollingThunder Mar 28, 10:16

if they are a public business, the law is clear that they can't discriminate {nm} slipping jimmy Mar 28, 11:07

Apologies everyone, busy at work! Trying to read thread now :) {nm} islander Mar 28, 13:31

My issue is with the bill because its a bad bill that could lead to worse bills. islander Mar 28, 14:13

All sincerely held beliefs, or only the ones you disagree with? shadowking Mar 28, 10:06

Anti-discrimination laws protect against discrimination based on certain grounds, such as gender, race, sexuality and religion. RogerMore Mar 28, 10:19

To clarify - Content of good required is ok to descriminate upon, purpose/ultimate use of said good not ok to descriminate based on? shadowking Mar 28, 10:41

No, you can discriminate based on content too. "Sorry, we don't stock male-male cake toppers and I won't order them in" is discrimination. RogerMore Mar 28, 12:55

By "you can discriminate based on content", I mean "discriminating based on content is not OK either" {nm} RogerMore Mar 28, 13:10

I assume the goal of the bill is to alter/ammend existing anti-discrimination law, so falling back on those laws as a criteria for shadowking Mar 28, 15:22

My understanding is that this bill wouldn't specifically alter any laws, but it includes a general provision that says something like... RogerMore Mar 28, 16:49

That is not a correct comparison DeanB Mar 28, 10:26

Sadly, this kind of thing has been happening for a long time. The Bill would just allow them to be blunt with their denial of services. {nm} RollingThunder Mar 28, 10:29

i dont think the issues in your first inside line come up much. If that did happen to me, I'd make them but might spit in their cupcakes ;) islander Mar 28, 14:15

At the risk of generalising it seems that a significant percentage of Americans still have a very deep puritanical streak that most of us... hyperzeitgeist Mar 28, 10:20

Thankfully, that percentage is declining annually. {nm} BSmurf Mar 28, 10:50

Europe exorcised all that by shipping the puritanical religious types to North America. DTravel Mar 28, 12:53

Even setting aside agreement/disagreement with others' sexuality, there is a more fundamental problem with the bill. DTravel Mar 28, 13:06

Now, if we could only get all those religions and churches to start paying taxes... {nm} BSmurf Mar 29, 14:25





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


Dead by Daylight (DBDLT) 150000 28.29 (+2.17)          Winter Games (WNTGM) 100000 7.06 (+0.51)          Fablehaven (FBLHV) 100 13.18 (0.00)          Winter Games (WNTGM) 50000 7.06 (+0.51)          Dead by Daylight (DBDLT) 150000 28.29 (+2.17)          Winter Games (WNTGM) 150000 7.06 (+0.51)          Winter Games (WNTGM) 150000 7.06 (+0.51)          Teen Titans (TEENT) 5000 33.34 (+2.45)          Michael 2 (MJAC2) 10000 177.73 (-0.43)          One Night Only (ONTON) 149612 25.57 (+0.13)          Teen Titans (TEENT) 5000 33.34 (+2.45)          Teen Titans (TEENT) 150000 33.34 (+2.45)          Teen Titans (TEENT) 150000 33.34 (+2.45)          Teen Titans (TEENT) 150000 33.34 (+2.45)          Robotech (RTECH) 100000 6.71 (+0.26)          Miami Vice '85 (MIVIC) 150000 113.11 (-0.92)          The Invite (TINVT) 145000 21.64 (+0.28)          Teen Titans (TEENT) 75000 33.34 (+2.45)          Dead by Daylight (DBDLT) 2500 28.29 (+2.17)          Viva La Madness (VLMAD) 150000 18.31 (+0.95)          Fortitude (FRTUD) 40000 8.47 (-0.01)          Teen Titans (TEENT) 45000 33.34 (+2.45)          Dune: Part Three (DUNE3) 10000 243.71 (+0.04)          The Teller (TELER) 50000 8.81 (+1.03)          Moana - Opening Weekend (MOAN1.OW) 100 83.42 (-1.05)          Robotech (RTECH) 40000 6.71 (+0.26)          Jackass: Best and Last (JCKA6) 150000 21.68 (+0.20)          Other Mommy aka Incidents Around (IATHS) 150000 29.67 (-0.36)          Other Mommy aka Incidents Around (IATHS) 150000 29.67 (-0.36)          The Odyssey (ODYSE) 5000 318.62 (+0.59)          Robotech (RTECH) 10000 6.71 (+0.26)          Minions & Monsters (MNIO3) 150000 193.01 (-2.48)          Robotech (RTECH) 150000 6.71 (+0.26)          Teen Titans (TEENT) 150000 33.34 (+2.45)          Ice Cream Man (ICREM) 150000 18.56 (-0.15)          Ice Cream Man (ICREM) 150000 18.56 (-0.15)          Lords of War (LRDW2) 25000 8.00 (-0.05)          Everyone Wants to F*ck Me (EWTFM) 150000 7.54 (-0.11)          Metal Gear Solid (MTLGR) 150000 14.91 (+1.22)          Toy Story 5 (TOYS5) 150000 403.94 (+1.49)          Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomo (TATAT) 149996 32.34 (-1.71)          November 1963 (NOV63) 150000 6.28 (-0.12)          Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomo (TATAT) 149998 32.34 (-1.71)          I Play Rocky (IPROC) 10000 21.91 (0.00)          The Teller (TELER) 40000 8.81 (+1.03)          Beware Boiuna aka Legend of the (BOUNA) 40000 18.77 (-0.01)          Flywheel: Ignition of the Soul (FLYWH) 150000 8.25 (-0.03)          Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomo (TATAT) 5345 32.34 (-1.71)          The Only Living Pickpocket in Ne (OLPNY) 150000 2.28 (-0.02)          Dead by Daylight (DBDLT) 150000 28.29 (+2.17)