HSX Forum

Movies

Who/whom. It all depends on what race/sex/sexual identity is being replaced, and by wat other identity it's being replaced {nm}

Posted by: MattW on Jul 13, 12:02 in response to Antibody's post So you don't object to blackface or whitewashing?

Johansson drops out of Rub & Tug day after Black Widow gets a director Moviesnob Jul 13, 11:13

Wow. Pivotal moment in Hollywood. They can only cast a trans person in that role now. {nm} Antibody Jul 13, 11:16

She drops out so another female can pretend to be a male. {nm} Chimpmuck Jul 13, 11:21

No cis actress is stupid to take this role now. {nm} Antibody Jul 13, 11:24

Only a "trans" female pretending to be a male can play a female pretending to be a male? {nm} Chimpmuck Jul 13, 11:26

Again after the backlash, no cis is stupid enough to take this role. {nm} Antibody Jul 13, 11:32

Shouldn't the producer be blamed for not hiring a trans gender actor ? {nm} Randy Jul 13, 11:40

SJOHA is one of the producers {nm} RogerMore Jul 13, 11:47

Okay now i understand the hate lol. I didn't know she was a producer on the project. {nm} Randy Jul 13, 11:54

Really, it's that trans men don't get opportunities to play men, and trans women don't get opportunities to play women, so all that is left RogerMore Jul 13, 12:24

She dropped out because of the backlash. No menion of BWDOW in her statement. {nm} Antibody Jul 13, 11:36

So what's next for Hollywood only a real killer can play a killer ? {nm} Randy Jul 13, 11:21

Wrong analogy. Sexual identity is more like race. {nm} Antibody Jul 13, 11:30

I'm just meaning there actors playing a role. {nm} Randy Jul 13, 11:37

So you don't object to blackface or whitewashing? {nm} Antibody Jul 13, 11:39

Of course i object to that. {nm} Randy Jul 13, 11:44

Then that's how a trans person feels who a cis like SJOHA play their role. {nm} Antibody Jul 13, 11:46

who=when {nm} Antibody Jul 13, 11:47

Why wouldn't the producers hire a real trans gender ? They should get the blame not her. She's just doing her job. {nm} Randy Jul 13, 11:50

You're 100% right that producers can share blame if the goal here is representation. But the great thing about mistakes is you can learn Moviesnob Jul 13, 11:54

Exactly. {nm} Randy Jul 13, 11:56

Like transgenderism, acting is just make believe {nm} Chimpmuck Jul 13, 11:44

Sex change isn't make believe. {nm} Antibody Jul 13, 11:47

ie Undergoing an operation. {nm} Antibody Jul 13, 11:48

Surgery can't change your sex, only your appearance {nm} Chimpmuck Jul 13, 11:50

Surgery is real and permanent, not "make believe". {nm} Antibody Jul 13, 11:52

Umm I'm pretty sure the surgery will change your sex. {nm} Randy Jul 13, 11:52

Cutting something off of your body or otherwise altering it does not change your sex, only your appearance. {nm} Chimpmuck Jul 13, 11:55

You're wrong. many of states require reassignment surgery to legally change your gender and have your birth certificate re-issued {nm} Moviesnob Jul 13, 11:58

Sex is not binary. There are people born with odd chroosomes like XXY, or other appearances like don't match XX or XY. {nm} Antibody Jul 13, 11:59

Developmental abnormalities like Klinefelter syndrome are a weak argument for support of transgenderism {nm} Chimpmuck Jul 13, 12:05

Well I'm sure they would beg the differ. All people should have the right to feel the way they are. {nm} Randy Jul 13, 12:02

Actually, it's gender that's make believe. {nm} Bronzey Jul 13, 12:17

Who/whom. It all depends on what race/sex/sexual identity is being replaced, and by wat other identity it's being replaced MattW Jul 13, 12:02

Dante Tex Gill's cousin believes he would have wanted to be played by a male actor, since he self-identified as a man slipping jimmy Jul 13, 11:53

I knew Tex Gill (slightly). Don't know what she would have wanted but it would have been weird. I also knew one of her acquaintances, who DTXbro Jul 13, 12:02

Her snarky response to criticisms before already did a little too much damage for me. Ed Skrein was classier backing out of Hellboy. {nm} Jay_Beezy Jul 13, 11:40

Exhausting, tedious, ultimately dividing people one way or the other. All of these things are killing us. It's a shame. Goodvibe61 Jul 13, 11:58

did they even try to audition any trans men for this role? {nm} tealfan Jul 13, 12:56

Think this wasn’t an audition scenario. ScarJo was a producer. {nm} Jay_Beezy Jul 13, 14:25





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


Winnie-the-Pooh: Blood and Honey (WTPB2) 150000 2.02 (-0.05)          Captain America: Brave New World (CAPA4) 500 194.27 (-0.16)          The First Omen H$10 Call (OMEN1.CA) 25000 2.95 (+0.01)          Arthur the King (ARTKN) 150000 22.45 (0.00)          Tank Girl (TANKG) 150000 13.49 (+0.20)          Godzilla x Kong: The New Empire (KONG2) 1 155.38 (+1.55)          The Down Under Fund (AUSIE) 900 89.80 (0.00)          Arthur the King (ARTKN) 150000 22.45 (0.00)          Alto Knights aka Wise Guys (WISEG) 100 30.40 (-0.13)          Dune: Part Two $235M Blockbuster (DUNE2.BW) 25000 9.48 (+0.03)          Here (HERE1) 2 43.93 (+0.15)          Mina Harker aka Dracula - Blumho (DRACU) 900 4.01 (+0.22)          The Accountant 2 (ACTN2) 1 23.83 (-0.03)          Alto Knights aka Wise Guys (WISEG) 100 30.40 (-0.13)          Winnie-the-Pooh: Blood and Honey (WTPB2) 150000 2.02 (-0.05)          Thanksgiving 2 (THNK2) 150000 19.34 (-0.66)          Jon Voight (JVOIG) 25000 44.16 (0.00)          Godzilla x Kong: The New Empire (KONG2) 150000 155.38 (+1.55)          Winnie-the-Pooh: Blood and Honey (WTPB2) 150000 2.02 (-0.05)          Beverly Hills Cop: Axel F (BHCP4) 149999 0.31 (+0.03)          Winnie-the-Pooh: Blood and Honey (WTPB2) 150000 2.02 (-0.05)          The First Omen H$10 Call (OMEN1.CA) 1000 2.95 (+0.01)          A Simple Favor 2 (ASFA2) 12500 17.97 (+1.26)          Beverly Hills Cop: Axel F (BHCP4) 149999 0.31 (+0.03)          Abigail (ABGAL) 25000 59.40 (-0.84)          Thanksgiving 2 (THNK2) 37500 19.34 (-0.66)          Samuel L. Jackson (SLJAC) 415 33.45 (0.00)          The Fall Guy (FALGY) 799 155.24 (0.00)          Alto Knights aka Wise Guys (WISEG) 150000 30.40 (-0.13)          Tank Girl (TANKG) 150000 13.49 (+0.20)          Nosferatu (NOSFR) 150000 20.47 (-0.08)          Thanksgiving 2 (THNK2) 150000 19.34 (-0.66)          A Simple Favor 2 (ASFA2) 100000 17.97 (+1.26)          Beetlejuice Beetlejuice (BEET2) 149999 158.03 (-0.77)          Kinds of Kindness (AND) 100000 18.34 (+0.88)          Megalopolis (MEGAL) 100000 23.60 (+0.16)          Thanksgiving 2 (THNK2) 150000 19.34 (-0.66)          Thanksgiving 2 (THNK2) 150000 19.34 (-0.66)          A Complete Unknown aka Going Ele (GOELC) 100000 17.58 (+0.50)          Weekend in Taipei (WKNTP) 150000 14.14 (-0.34)          A Simple Favor 2 (ASFA2) 150000 17.97 (+1.26)          A Simple Favor 2 (ASFA2) 150000 17.97 (+1.26)          Abigail (ABGAL) 150000 59.40 (-0.84)          Abigail (ABGAL) 150000 59.40 (-0.84)          Saw XI aka Saw 11 (SAW11) 150000 37.21 (-1.18)          Thanksgiving 2 (THNK2) 150000 19.34 (-0.66)          Not Another Church Movie (NACM) 150000 10.41 (+0.45)          Not Another Church Movie (NACM) 150000 10.41 (+0.45)          Red One (REDON) 150000 75.64 (-0.25)          Kinds of Kindness (AND) 150000 18.34 (+0.88)