HSX Forum

Movies

Really, it's that trans men don't get opportunities to play men, and trans women don't get opportunities to play women, so all that is left

Posted by: RogerMore on Jul 13, 12:24 in response to Randy's post Okay now i understand the hate lol. I didn't know she was...

for them are trans roles. But there's no barrier (until recently, in the form of protest) for a cis actor playing a trans person, and obviously the commercial decision is to pick an actor with name recognition, star power, box office draw etc over one with none of those things, so what opportunities for trans actors does that leave?

If audiences would accept trans actors playing cis roles, this wouldn't be an issue - but they don't, so here we are.

Johansson drops out of Rub & Tug day after Black Widow gets a director Moviesnob Jul 13, 11:13

Wow. Pivotal moment in Hollywood. They can only cast a trans person in that role now. {nm} Antibody Jul 13, 11:16

She drops out so another female can pretend to be a male. {nm} Chimpmuck Jul 13, 11:21

No cis actress is stupid to take this role now. {nm} Antibody Jul 13, 11:24

Only a "trans" female pretending to be a male can play a female pretending to be a male? {nm} Chimpmuck Jul 13, 11:26

Again after the backlash, no cis is stupid enough to take this role. {nm} Antibody Jul 13, 11:32

Shouldn't the producer be blamed for not hiring a trans gender actor ? {nm} Randy Jul 13, 11:40

SJOHA is one of the producers {nm} RogerMore Jul 13, 11:47

Okay now i understand the hate lol. I didn't know she was a producer on the project. {nm} Randy Jul 13, 11:54

Really, it's that trans men don't get opportunities to play men, and trans women don't get opportunities to play women, so all that is left RogerMore Jul 13, 12:24

She dropped out because of the backlash. No menion of BWDOW in her statement. {nm} Antibody Jul 13, 11:36

So what's next for Hollywood only a real killer can play a killer ? {nm} Randy Jul 13, 11:21

Wrong analogy. Sexual identity is more like race. {nm} Antibody Jul 13, 11:30

I'm just meaning there actors playing a role. {nm} Randy Jul 13, 11:37

So you don't object to blackface or whitewashing? {nm} Antibody Jul 13, 11:39

Of course i object to that. {nm} Randy Jul 13, 11:44

Then that's how a trans person feels who a cis like SJOHA play their role. {nm} Antibody Jul 13, 11:46

who=when {nm} Antibody Jul 13, 11:47

Why wouldn't the producers hire a real trans gender ? They should get the blame not her. She's just doing her job. {nm} Randy Jul 13, 11:50

You're 100% right that producers can share blame if the goal here is representation. But the great thing about mistakes is you can learn Moviesnob Jul 13, 11:54

Exactly. {nm} Randy Jul 13, 11:56

Like transgenderism, acting is just make believe {nm} Chimpmuck Jul 13, 11:44

Sex change isn't make believe. {nm} Antibody Jul 13, 11:47

ie Undergoing an operation. {nm} Antibody Jul 13, 11:48

Surgery can't change your sex, only your appearance {nm} Chimpmuck Jul 13, 11:50

Surgery is real and permanent, not "make believe". {nm} Antibody Jul 13, 11:52

Umm I'm pretty sure the surgery will change your sex. {nm} Randy Jul 13, 11:52

Cutting something off of your body or otherwise altering it does not change your sex, only your appearance. {nm} Chimpmuck Jul 13, 11:55

You're wrong. many of states require reassignment surgery to legally change your gender and have your birth certificate re-issued {nm} Moviesnob Jul 13, 11:58

Sex is not binary. There are people born with odd chroosomes like XXY, or other appearances like don't match XX or XY. {nm} Antibody Jul 13, 11:59

Developmental abnormalities like Klinefelter syndrome are a weak argument for support of transgenderism {nm} Chimpmuck Jul 13, 12:05

Well I'm sure they would beg the differ. All people should have the right to feel the way they are. {nm} Randy Jul 13, 12:02

Actually, it's gender that's make believe. {nm} Bronzey Jul 13, 12:17

Who/whom. It all depends on what race/sex/sexual identity is being replaced, and by wat other identity it's being replaced {nm} MattW Jul 13, 12:02

Dante Tex Gill's cousin believes he would have wanted to be played by a male actor, since he self-identified as a man slipping jimmy Jul 13, 11:53

I knew Tex Gill (slightly). Don't know what she would have wanted but it would have been weird. I also knew one of her acquaintances, who DTXbro Jul 13, 12:02

Her snarky response to criticisms before already did a little too much damage for me. Ed Skrein was classier backing out of Hellboy. {nm} Jay_Beezy Jul 13, 11:40

Exhausting, tedious, ultimately dividing people one way or the other. All of these things are killing us. It's a shame. Goodvibe61 Jul 13, 11:58

did they even try to audition any trans men for this role? {nm} tealfan Jul 13, 12:56

Think this wasn’t an audition scenario. ScarJo was a producer. {nm} Jay_Beezy Jul 13, 14:25





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


Stop! That! Train! (STTRN) 25000 5.54 (-0.14)          Dog Years (DOGYS) 150000 1.92 (-0.08)          The Chaperones (CHAPR) 10000 9.56 (-0.44)          Constantine 2 (CNST2) 25000 45.66 (+0.12)          Zootopia 2 (ZOOT2) 4000 307.41 (+0.23)          Soulm8te (SOM8T) 148500 16.00 (-0.87)          Soulm8te (SOM8T) 67000 16.00 (-0.87)          Is This Thing On? (ISTON) 5000 17.95 (-0.01)          In the Grey (NGREY) 75000 15.64 (+1.03)          Jane (JANE1) 70000 14.48 (+1.02)          The Chosen Season 6 (TCS61) 75000 12.97 (+1.06)          Hunting Matthew Nichols (HUNMN) 80000 4.12 (-0.44)          The SpongeBob Movie: Search for (SPBO4) 115000 78.76 (-0.97)          Wicked: For Good (WCKD2) 10000 359.24 (-1.00)          Mother Mary (MMARY) 115000 11.25 (-1.14)          Obsession (OBSSN) 115000 16.42 (-1.22)          Airman (AIRMA) 2500 25.42 (+0.06)          Soulm8te (SOM8T) 50000 16.00 (-0.87)          Blade (BLAD1) 150000 41.05 (-0.20)          Hunting Matthew Nichols (HUNMN) 2500 4.12 (-0.44)          Mother Mary (MMARY) 2500 11.25 (-1.14)          Eternity (ETERN) 149910 11.40 (+0.27)          Eternity (ETERN) 149993 11.40 (+0.27)          Obsession (OBSSN) 2500 16.42 (-1.22)          Is This Thing On? (ISTON) 150000 17.95 (-0.01)          Is This Thing On? (ISTON) 149994 17.95 (-0.01)          Everyone Wants to F*ck Me (EWTFM) 150000 9.68 (+0.04)          Everyone Wants to F*ck Me (EWTFM) 150000 9.68 (+0.04)          Rush Hour 4 (RUSH4) 150000 20.69 (+0.38)          Rush Hour 4 (RUSH4) 150000 20.69 (+0.38)          Deep Water (DEEPW) 149999 5.97 (-0.03)          Alien sequel (ALIE6) 150000 69.27 (+0.32)          Wicked: For Good (WCKD2) 149999 359.24 (-1.00)          Empire City (EMPCT) 150000 18.96 (-0.27)          Rental Family (RNTLF) 1 9.76 (0.00)          Empire City (EMPCT) 150000 18.96 (-0.27)          Idris Elba (IELBA) 25000 106.39 (+0.66)          Hunting Matthew Nichols (HUNMN) 150000 4.12 (-0.44)          Hamnet - Opening Weekend (HAMNT.OW) 100000 3.74 (-0.01)          Hunting Matthew Nichols (HUNMN) 150000 4.12 (-0.44)          Merrily We Roll Along (MWRAL) 150000 4.21 (+0.36)          Fackham Hall (FACKH) 150000 5.80 (-0.58)          100 Nights of Hero (100NH) 150000 7.96 (-0.02)          The Nightingale (NITNG) 149999 5.69 (+0.03)          Merrily We Roll Along (MWRAL) 150000 4.21 (+0.36)          Soulm8te (SOM8T) 150000 16.00 (-0.87)          Merrily We Roll Along (MWRAL) 150000 4.21 (+0.36)          Silent Night, Deadly Night (SNDN) 150000 16.06 (+0.90)          Silent Night, Deadly Night (SNDN) 150000 16.06 (+0.90)          Monopoly (MONOP) 150000 12.46 (+0.98)