HSX Forum

Movies

For Context: Why I felt "Minions" had the edge on "Lightyear," My full thoughts on that call earlier this year.

Posted by: VictorY on Jun 24, 15:01

To be honest, Disney's trailers for LY were confusing at first, then later trailers basically sold it as a kid's move verison of "Interstellar," off tone and viabliity. 

The problem is just that:  a dark tone for the film's narrative.  If we're talking about a film that inspired the purchase of the Lightyear toy by Andy, doesn't it make more sense its a film that's more inspriting and less dreary?  With a much more lively and funner tone?

Which brings us to "Minions" which continues to have a more fun and lively tone.  I was also amazed how projections for the new one were low, really low (40-50 million opening weekend). This considering the last "Minions" film opened to well over 100+ million at start..   So I sided with "Minions."

Now the whole "kiss" contreversy could have been handled better, no question, on Disney's part.  Once the decision was made to put that part back into the film, there should have been a effort to focus marketing on that being part of "Pride Month" celebration. I'm actually really surprised Disney marketing didn't do that to help mediate any controversy. 

I've seen "Lightyear," and the film isn't horrible either..  The team he assembles (and the robot car) are awesome to watch, but I couldn't over-look the tone aspect of the narrative compared to what "Minions" will offer (I personally feel M will be one of the funniest films of the year off its marketing).

As always HSXers...  Have a great film summer..





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


Last Friday (FRID4) 150000 8.09 (-0.01)          Wildwood (WILDW) 14 26.82 (+0.32)          A Talent for Murder (SWITZ) 18 4.70 (-0.08)          A Talent for Murder (SWITZ) 19 4.70 (-0.08)          Clayface (CLAYF) 18 58.39 (-0.77)          Whalefall (WHALF) 499 20.62 (-0.94)          Terrifier 4 (TERF4) 37500 19.46 (+0.01)          Whalefall (WHALF) 65 20.62 (-0.94)          Street Fighter (STFTR) 150000 73.86 (-1.69)          Fear the Reaper (FREPR) 150000 15.70 (+1.45)          Victorian Psycho (VPSYC) 150000 15.22 (+1.25)          Playmates (PLYMT) 150000 10.26 (+1.09)          Sense and Sensibility (SNSNS) 10 19.82 (+0.14)          Wet (WET) 150000 5.31 (-0.51)          The Social Reckoning (SOCI2) 5 14.42 (-0.04)          Jehanne d'Arc (JDARC) 24000 32.06 (+0.06)          Other Mommy (IATHS) 10 51.03 (-0.36)          Angel and the Badman (ANBAD) 4 4.52 (+0.01)          Verity (VERTY) 100 68.94 (+0.44)          Winter of the Crow (WOTCR) 150000 0.29 (+0.01)          Digger (DIGER) 10 23.16 (+0.23)          You Can See Everything (YCSET) 150000 32.90 (+0.99)          Heart of the Beast (HOTBS) 4 56.38 (-0.08)          You Can See Everything (YCSET) 150000 32.90 (+0.99)          Forgotten Island (FRGIS) 9 35.69 (-0.26)          24 Jump Street (21JS3) 25 88.20 (+2.40)          Lilo & Stitch 2 (LILS2) 4000 284.76 (+0.23)          Street Fighter (STFTR) 75000 73.86 (-1.69)          Freddy the 13th (FREDY) 3000 57.48 (-0.05)          Monster High (MONHI) 37500 19.16 (+0.01)          Whalefall (WHALF) 2 20.62 (-0.94)          Whalefall (WHALF) 150000 20.62 (-0.94)          Sicario 3 (SICA3) 150000 15.59 (+0.06)          The Flood (FLOOD) 3000 104.37 (+0.77)          Dynamic Duo (DYDUO) 3000 120.63 (-0.11)          Barbarella (BARBA) 50000 21.78 (+0.02)          The Lunar Chronicles (LUNAR) 3000 65.97 (-0.15)          Street Fighter (STFTR) 150000 73.86 (-1.69)          Evil Dead Wrath (EVLD7) 70000 33.99 (+0.08)          Clayface (CLAYF) 150000 58.39 (-0.77)          24 Jump Street (21JS3) 150000 88.20 (+2.40)          Greenhouse aka The Uninhabitable (GRENH) 37500 19.22 (+0.05)          The Six Billion Dollar Man (6MILL) 50000 4.90 (0.00)          Black Panther III (BPNT3) 3000 290.82 (-0.01)          24 Jump Street (21JS3) 150000 88.20 (+2.40)          Fear the Reaper (FREPR) 15000 15.70 (+1.45)          James Bond 26 (JB26) 3000 171.27 (0.00)          Death Stranding (DSTRN) 37500 19.99 (+0.03)          Dead by Daylight (DBDLT) 37500 19.17 (-0.01)          Calamity Hustle (CLMTY) 37500 19.12 (+0.02)