HSX Forum

TVStocks, MusicStocks and Life

I'm not being dismissive - when I talked about whether home invasions would become common, I was talking about the type you described.

Posted by: RogerMore on Jan 22, 15:45 in response to edzep - Port Monkey!'s post Home invasion IS a growing threat.

Most home invasions aren't done with semi-automatic weapons and bulletproof vests.

I'm finding it hard to find reliable statistics on home invasions.  The FBI doesn't separate them from burglaries or robberies.  Robberies are down 20% over the last 5 years, burglaries are up slightly over the past decade.  Insurance companies have some statistics, but being insurance companies they are more interested in property crimes than violence.  Anyway, more data would be useful.

I'm looking at defensivecarry.com now - I did a site search using google, which works OK.  There are some interesting forum members on that site but hey, it's the internet.  Very different views about whether an AR-15 is appropriate for home defense in the forum I read.  Some think it's great, others would prefer a handgun.  Interesting (for me) to see a diversity of views from gun owners, because we only get outrageous (from my perspective) positions from gun advocates on the news.

We rationalise "greater good" things every day.  As a society, America "accepts" over 30,000 deaths per year from traffic accident fatalities - three times as many as gun homicides.  Obviously cars are great and necessary for society and the economy to function.  But we accept the risks that having a car-based society involved, while at the same time we try to limit the number of people who are killed and injured in car accidents through regulation - traffic laws, licensing, drink driving laws, safety standards, seat belts, speed limits, and so on.  I have a similar perspective on guns - what level of gun violence is society willing to "accept"? And what can be done to minimise that # at the least cost to individuals?

I don't think that guns cause a sickness - but at the same time, not everyone has the positive community-based experiences that you had with guns when you were growing up.  Most people who drive a car have tens of hours of supervised practice behind a wheel with an instructor or a parent before they are allowed to drive on their own.  Is the same true of guns?  (I know training and safety programs exist

I'm cautious of the "society is sick" argument as well.  With the higher rate of American gun violence, it implies that American society is somehow sicker and more into violence than other comparable countries. No data, other my experiences living outside America, but I don't believe this is the case.

CNN: 5 people accidentally shot at 3 private gun shows. (where were the armed citizens to stop this!) Antibody Jan 21, 12:04

Um, did you bother to actually read the article? They all discharged *accidentally*. None of the incidents were a mass shooting. *facepalm* {nm} accountant_4_Jesus Jan 21, 14:00

Whoosh. Sarcasm went over your head. {nm} Antibody Jan 21, 14:49

We really need a sarcasm font then. {nm} accountant_4_Jesus Jan 21, 15:04

Pull! *BLAM* {nm} DTravel Jan 21, 20:41

Meanwhile, Chicago is outpacing 2012's murder rate. {nm} Samuel_L_Bronkowitz Jan 21, 20:47

meanwhile, every other developed nation that allows virtually no private gun ownership is not {nm} charlie Jan 21, 21:40

Chicago has some of the strictest laws against handguns in America. Samuel_L_Bronkowitz Jan 22, 03:28

Isn't Chicago right next to, say, Indiana - which doesn't? It's not as though Chicago is in a vacuum. {nm} RogerMore Jan 22, 07:02

Are you suggesting that criminals do not obey gun laws? Surely that cannot be the case! {nm} Samuel_L_Bronkowitz Jan 22, 07:37

I'm saying "why make it so easy for criminals to ignore them?" {nm} RogerMore Jan 22, 07:41

Joe "I love being president" Biden says we don't have the manpower to enforce the gun laws we have now. Samuel_L_Bronkowitz Jan 22, 10:19

Do you think it's really about manpower, or willpower? Gun ownership is popular in America, and few politicians want to be seen messing Roger More Jan 22, 11:26

Isn't the USA right next to Mexico? We can't/won't even control our own border, much less passage of weapons. {nm} edzep - Port Monkey! Jan 22, 10:07

The US/Mexico weapons traffic goes the other way. {nm} Roger More Jan 22, 11:09

For now, maybe. But, Mexican drug gangs are a force to be reconed with. If there's a criminal market in the US for what may become illegal edzep - Port Monkey! Jan 22, 11:45

I think that's a fair assessment - but an incredibly perverse outcome, when a big part of their power is from access to US-sourced guns. RogerMore Jan 22, 12:38

Most citizens are not going to make criminals of themselves by buying illegal arms, no matter how much they edzep - Port Monkey! Jan 22, 13:06

Hmmm... you are probably right about how ordinary people and criminal gangs will respond. I am more optimistic than you about whether RogerMore Jan 22, 14:01

Home invasion IS a growing threat. edzep - Port Monkey! Jan 22, 14:32

I'm not being dismissive - when I talked about whether home invasions would become common, I was talking about the type you described. RogerMore Jan 22, 15:45

I was going to mention the varitey of characters on that site... edzep - Port Monkey! Jan 22, 16:16





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


Stalemate (STALM) 150000 1.64 (-0.04)          Mark Ruffalo (MRUFF) 25000 80.81 (+0.50)          Mark Ruffalo (MRUFF) 25000 80.81 (+0.50)          Isabella Rossellini (IROSS) 25000 11.81 (+0.40)          Friday the 13th (FRI12) 150000 31.07 (+1.07)          Friday the 13th (FRI12) 150000 31.07 (+1.07)          Friday the 13th (FRI12) 150000 31.07 (+1.07)          Friday the 13th (FRI12) 150000 31.07 (+1.07)          How To Rob A Bank (HTRAB) 150000 27.00 (-0.98)          Ebenezer (EBNZR) 150000 64.96 (-0.91)          The Lost Boys (LOSTB) 150000 0.75 (-0.02)          Cloud Girl (CLOUG) 150000 2.60 (+0.35)          Cocomelon: the Movie (COMEL) 150000 56.65 (-0.20)          Maatrubhumi (BGALW) 150000 1.19 (+0.13)          The Hole (THHOL) 149999 6.81 (+0.43)          Dragon (DRAGO) 150000 5.97 (-0.07)          Wet (WET) 150000 9.93 (+0.90)          Friday the 13th (FRI12) 5000 31.07 (+1.07)          Godzilla Minus Zero (GODM2) 150000 73.67 (-0.61)          Teen Titans (TEENT) 150000 22.97 (+0.08)          Ebenezer (EBNZR) 150000 64.96 (-0.91)          Play House (PLYHS) 149999 19.31 (+0.86)          Drag (DRAG) 149999 6.62 (-0.06)          Hershey (HERSH) 149999 11.57 (+0.66)          Children of Blood and Bone (COBAB) 149999 29.54 (-0.13)          Wet (WET) 15795 9.93 (+0.90)          Ebenezer (EBNZR) 150000 64.96 (-0.91)          Magic: The Gathering (MGCTG) 149999 42.06 (-0.19)          Bad Influence (BNFLU) 150000 9.48 (-0.52)          Friday the 13th (FRI12) 150000 31.07 (+1.07)          Steve Buscemi (SBUSC) 24990 12.58 (-0.09)          Behemoth! (BEHEM) 150000 22.91 (+0.06)          Outer Dark (OTDRK) 10 4.83 (+0.01)          Orphan (ORPAN) 10 0.03 (0.00)          Onwards and Sideways (OWASW) 10 1.57 (0.00)          Only What We Carry (OWWC) 10 0.57 (0.00)          One Punch Man (1PMAN) 10 7.32 (0.00)          One of Them Days 2 (1OTD2) 10 11.52 (+0.04)          One Italian Summer (1ITAS) 10 31.18 (-0.03)          Once Upon a Time in the Middle E (OUATM) 10 0.66 (0.00)          Friday the 13th (FRI12) 150000 31.07 (+1.07)          Once Upon a Time in Harlem (OUATH) 10 0.48 (0.00)          Bad Influence (BNFLU) 150000 9.48 (-0.52)          Adrift (ADRIF) 150000 0.94 (0.00)          Old Man in the Dunes (OMITD) 10 6.60 (0.00)          Stalemate (STALM) 150000 1.64 (-0.04)          Old Friends New Friends (OFNF) 10 9.16 (0.00)          Octet (OCTET) 10 15.32 (+0.04)          G.I. Joe (GIJO4) 150000 44.75 (+0.40)          Oceans (OCEN5) 10 78.55 (0.00)