HSX Forum

Movies

well

Posted by: boondock islander (a.k.a del_USA_islander) on Sep 04, 07:02 in response to Vashta Nerada's post I don't care that the stock moved. Playing the players is...

a search of the strangelove feature at st for review turns up several posts of reviews from thr and var as well as less known sites by several TOP players, some of whom cherry picked words from the review! reviews get posted all the time, and this is the first I remember anyone having a problem with it. Reviewing dmacs post, he could have avoided the obviously negative subject line, but to me it is news when a major publication reviews a film. not the biggest news to be sure, but it gives me a feel for what may come. he did at least start off the post with "variety review" which tells me its not news.

we trust variety as a source for news, thus i am willing to give weight to them for a review, as opposed to some newspaper we dont link to. most players know which sites to listen to: var, thr, etc, as opposed to something like jimbos film shack. if someone posts a review from some lame site, they should absolutely be shouted down and taught the error of their way

players are always going to jump at any post to make a Hbuck. the fact that this was a dmac post is irrelevant. i still say if some veteran would have posted it, the stock would have behaved the same way.

if there is one thing to fault dmac for, its continuing on the repeated negative posting between him and you, and you and ss.

The D.Mac/TROAD Debacle Vashta Nerada Sep 03, 18:59

96% of the people living in the United States who want to see TROAD will never read Variety. That's just one opinion. {nm} secretstalker Sep 03, 19:07

Precisely. {nm} Vashta Nerada Sep 03, 19:11

I'd express my opinion on this post, but seeing as no other opinions are posted yet, maybe I shouldn't? Yes, flawless logic. Sorry, had to Perfection Sep 03, 19:09

The Variety review was news-worthy because it was FIRST of a highly-anticipated movie. {nm} Antibody Sep 03, 19:33

The fact that it has generated responses from Playlist, Jeffery Wells and other bloggers makes it even more news relevant. {nm} Antibody Sep 03, 19:40

98% of the people living in the United States who want to see TROAD will never read either of those blogs. {nm} secretstalker Sep 03, 20:02

I think the fact that it generated responses on this board says a lot more. {nm} Vashta Nerada Sep 03, 22:41

Some people would find that Variety, THR and Playlist all don't think TROAD is a commercial film useful information. {nm} Antibody Sep 04, 09:31

I read a reviews of it last year and a couple this year. Last october Joblo said, "THE ROAD easily makes it into my top 5 thus far (2008)" Shrike Sep 04, 06:43

Those were unfinished cuts last year. {nm} Antibody Sep 04, 09:29

i can't believe you wrote so much. how many paragraphs is this? its like a manifesto {nm} Moviesnob Sep 03, 19:55

If I still had them I'd repost the unofficial news rules. {nm} Vashta Nerada Sep 03, 21:05

a counterpoint... boondock islander Sep 03, 20:21

I don't care that the stock moved. Playing the players is an age old trading practice around here. What I do care about is him not taking Vashta Nerada Sep 03, 22:38

well boondock islander Sep 04, 07:02

Huh? I do know Variety review is an opinion. What happens now?! {nm} Antibody Sep 04, 09:18

You scribble yourself? hah {nm} mysti hsx Sep 04, 11:47

Not manipulation in any way, shape, or form . . . Weyland-Yutani Sep 04, 02:14

You're out of your element, Donny. {nm} emoticripple Sep 04, 07:05





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


Nick Frost (NFROS) 5000 53.21 (-0.53)          The Invite (TINVT) 150000 14.51 (-0.07)          Iron Lung (IRONL) 150000 23.16 (+1.01)          Scream 7 (SCRM7) 20000 80.74 (-0.42)          Julian Dennison (JDENN) 2000 122.33 (+0.36)          Sonic the Hedgehog 4 (SONC4) 3693 155.87 (-0.32)          Shaun The Sheep: The Beast Of Mo (SHEP3) 2121 12.40 (-1.01)          ABC: RJ Decker (RJDECK) 25000 8.00 (0.00)          The Moment (MOMNT) 150000 9.33 (-0.08)          NBC: The Fall and Rise of Reggie (FARORD) 25000 8.00 (0.00)          Shiver (SHVER) 1000 54.02 (+2.95)          Spider-Man: Beyond the Spider-Ve (ASPD3) 292 229.23 (+0.25)          Shelter (SELTR) 150000 11.49 (+0.99)          Godzilla Minus Zero (GODM2) 100 42.42 (+0.35)          ABC: RJ Decker (RJDECK) 25000 8.00 (0.00)          The Legend of Aang: The Last Air (ATLA1) 50 19.22 (0.00)          Resident Evil (RESE8) 50 49.67 (+0.01)          NBC: The Fall and Rise of Reggie (FARORD) 25000 8.00 (0.00)          Insidious 6 (NSID6) 50 31.91 (-0.09)          Iron Lung (IRONL) 150000 23.16 (+1.01)          Moana (MOAN1) 50 218.55 (+0.16)          Send Help (SENDH) 150000 44.95 (-0.78)          Jackass 5 (JCKA6) 20 47.74 (+0.04)          Supergirl (SUPGR) 15 182.30 (+0.34)          A Tree is Blue (ATBLU) 150000 5.17 (+1.24)          A Tree is Blue (ATBLU) 150000 5.17 (+1.24)          Disclosure Day (SKIES) 15 162.44 (-0.08)          Sender (SENDR) 150000 10.18 (+1.41)          Sender (SENDR) 150000 10.18 (+1.41)          Final Destination 7 (FDES7) 150000 58.65 (-0.72)          Final Destination 7 (FDES7) 150000 58.65 (-0.72)          Lee Cronin's The Mummy (TMUMY) 10 43.43 (+0.30)          ABC: RJ Decker (RJDECK) 25000 8.00 (0.00)          Gundam (GUNDM) 150000 15.43 (+0.04)          Project Hail Mary (PRJHM) 20 190.37 (0.00)          ABC: RJ Decker (RJDECK) 25000 8.00 (0.00)          A Tree is Blue (ATBLU) 150000 5.17 (+1.24)          NBC: The Fall and Rise of Reggie (FARORD) 25000 8.00 (0.00)          NBC: The Fall and Rise of Reggie (FARORD) 25000 8.00 (0.00)          NBC: The Fall and Rise of Reggie (FARORD) 25000 8.00 (0.00)          Reminders of Him (RMNDH) 20 23.14 (+0.44)          Ramayana (RAMAY) 150000 8.75 (+0.16)          A Tree is Blue (ATBLU) 150000 5.17 (+1.24)          Ramayana (RAMAY) 150000 8.75 (+0.16)          A Tree is Blue (ATBLU) 150000 5.17 (+1.24)          ABC: RJ Decker (RJDECK) 25000 8.00 (0.00)          NBC: The Fall and Rise of Reggie (FARORD) 25000 8.00 (0.00)          The Mandalorian and Grogu (SWAR3) 300 239.94 (-0.70)          Spider-Man: Brand New Day (SPID9) 300 420.32 (+0.28)          ABC: RJ Decker (RJDECK) 25000 8.00 (0.00)