HSX Forum

Movies

Circular argument...Limbaugh has used this for years. So, because you utilize a racist viewpoint and get called out for it, you attack the

Posted by: Catzan on Aug 01, 12:41 in response to Chimpmuck's post Typical SJW drone. When you have exhausted the script,...

attack? Racist conservatives now say the red rose is not red. Who the heck teaches debate anymore? Oh, right, that was cut from school budgets because it indoctrinates socialisism into unsuspecting conservative kids. 

See, when you parrot responses from right wing idealogues that are essentially: "I know you are but what am I?", you are not furthering the discourse of a civil society. A better response would be to ask why is your commentary racist. Perhaps you can learn why it is or perhaps you cannot understand. So, I will try to explain.

The minority is smaller than the majority. When the majority makes decisions, they often do so to benefit just the majority at the expense of the minority. A white guy is hired because the white boss is more comfortable with the white guy because he looks like him, talks like him, etc. A civil society takes this into consideration and says that race, religion, etc should not factor in. 

In Hollywood, they have always tried to make a buck and even make art, too. As the professional pool of actors becomes more diverse, opportunity abounds for those actors if and only if Hollywood produces films that reflect diversity. There are plenty of films made that are mostly cast with white folks or even all. There are fewer films with an all ethnic cast and there could be more. So celebrating a film that has all Asians is cool because it opens a window to see a part of our diverse culture that many may never see. It opens a window to those of that heritage to see that they too are represented in Hollywood as people...not just some martial arts cardboard character, for instance.

The majority always see something of themselves in art. Now, when you see a black guy playing the Human Torch and you go...Where the heck is Chris Evans? Johnny Storm is white! That happens a lot more often to an American Indian, an Asian person, any person from a diverse background. That is what Antibody goes on about. Personally, I think of an actor as a person who is paid to be someone else and the further it is from what they are, the harder the role to play. Denzel Washington playing Robert McCall is not that much a leap as race is not a huge factor in the original TV series. But try putting a bunch of white people in Crazy Rich Asians...and suddenly, that is a lot harder but certainly not necessary. American audiences got exposed to Toshiro Mifune, an amazing Japanese actor, because Hollywood actually gave important Japanese roles to him rather than casting an American like Warner Oland as Jackie Chan.

Giving voice to minorities is good. It is what a gracious, fairminded majority does. Globalism is good. Diversity is good. Homogenization is boring. But that seems to be a driving force in conservatism today...the homogenization of the US. 

THR on the making of [CRASN] author turned down a gigantic payday and greenlighted trilogy from Netflix so it would be seen in theaters Antibody Aug 01, 08:58

No Caucasians, blacks, Latinos, or visibly disabled in this movie. Where's the outrage? {nm} Chimpmuck Aug 01, 09:05

Umm, no Asians in 95% of other Hollywood movies. {nm} Antibody Aug 01, 09:08

If it was an all white cast you'd be rioting in the streets, but an all Asian cast is A-OK because diversity {nm} Chimpmuck Aug 01, 09:10

There have been all-white cast for decades. Hilarious how 1 in 25 years get you all riled up. {nm} Antibody Aug 01, 09:15

Amusing how you ignore your own hypocrisy and dodge the questions that expose it {nm} Chimpmuck Aug 01, 09:18

Nope. You're the one exposing your own prejudice and racism. {nm} Antibody Aug 01, 09:21

Typical SJW drone. When you have exhausted the script, shut down the conversation and call them a racist {nm} Chimpmuck Aug 01, 09:27

Typical racist, seeing diversity as a threat to their supremacy. {nm} Antibody Aug 01, 09:31

When did this board fall to race bating harassment? The first reply from this guy was to start this garbage. Are there no mods anymore? {nm} TerenceHill Aug 01, 09:33

It all started with Baron_Darcon2017. Mercifully it seems he has maybe been banned. People like him and this idiot make the board unusable. {nm} MiyazakiFan Aug 01, 09:40

I've been coming here for 15 years and I don't recall it ever being this bad. It feels like every other post now. {nm} TerenceHill Aug 01, 09:50

I apologize for posting this subject to the Movies forum. It belongs in the Life forum. {nm} Chimpmuck Aug 01, 09:54

not really {nm} slipping jimmy Aug 01, 10:03

its never been this bad, they just feel empowered b/c the GOP allows this extremism to stay in power. These morons have always been morons {nm} Moviesnob Aug 01, 10:34

You sound like a stale-thinking, disaffected bigot, Chippie. Quit whimpering. {nm} DTXbro Aug 01, 09:42

Circular argument...Limbaugh has used this for years. So, because you utilize a racist viewpoint and get called out for it, you attack the Catzan Aug 01, 12:41

SJWs strike again by [checks notes] faithfully adapting a popular novel about Asian families! {nm} slipping jimmy Aug 01, 09:20

Given it's a story about Asians, ya, an all-white cast should lead to riots in the streets. {nm} dubord.s Aug 01, 09:21

I didn't mean an all-white cast for this movie, just movies in general {nm} Chimpmuck Aug 01, 09:28

Movies 'in general' should have casts that represent the population 'in general'. {nm} dubord.s Aug 01, 09:41

Most Hollywood movies have all-white or nearly all-white casts. You just don't notice because you think it's normal. {nm} parthm_ Aug 01, 09:51

The outrage is it took 25 YEARS for a major studio to make another movie about Asian-Americans. {nm} Antibody Aug 01, 09:10

Sigh. Look at this person's post history. Please ban them. Why are there no moderators on here? {nm} MiyazakiFan Aug 01, 09:39

Ban me? Am I not allowed to have an opinion? {nm} Chimpmuck Aug 01, 09:41

Disaffected, spectrum-inhabiting, intolerant, half-educated, backward right-wing goobers have speech rights, too {nm} DTXbro Aug 01, 09:43

ill-informed racist opinions? yes. a platform to spew them online? no {nm} slipping jimmy Aug 01, 10:04

So you and Antibody can spew any political or SJW opinions you want, but if I offer an opinion I am attacked, called names... Chimpmuck Aug 01, 10:14

Maybe change your opinions? Since they’re like wrong. {nm} islndr Aug 01, 10:44

they're not even opinions. just ****posts made in bad faith to "own the libs" on an internet movie board slipping jimmy Aug 01, 11:33

its scary that we have to think that way now {nm} Moviesnob Aug 01, 11:38

Echo chambers gotta echo Pepe_Nolan Aug 01, 14:29

I don't think this is true. Here's the quote from his interview with the Guardian RogerMore Aug 01, 16:09

+1 {nm} dubord.s Aug 01, 09:41

the thing is, if this one makes bank, some channel/network will probably still pay for a series {nm} slipping jimmy Aug 01, 09:13

I hope we all reward their decision. Great way to see any comedy - on the big screen as a shared experience with lots of laughter. {nm} PhoneHome Aug 01, 10:42





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


Vanessa Kirby (VKIRB) 4 54.34 (+0.16)          Monkey Man (MNKYM) 200 23.37 (+0.06)          Maggie Smith (MSMTH) 4 37.81 (+0.12)          Challengers (CHALN) 6657 31.84 (+0.29)          The Fall Guy H$50 Call (FALGY.CA) 25000 3.45 (+1.45)          Toy Story 5 (TOYS5) 500 250.89 (+0.74)          Emily Blunt (EBLUN) 5 138.63 (+0.66)          Lewis Tan (LTAN) 6 126.66 (+0.66)          Sydney Sweeney (SSWEE) 14 74.75 (+1.03)          The Down Under Fund (AUSIE) 3 90.04 (-0.01)          The Ministry Of Ungentlemanly Wa (TMOUW) 9887 29.44 (+1.80)          Challengers - Opening Weekend (CHALN.OW) 1000 12.09 (+0.28)          Beverly Hills Cop: Axel F (BHCP4) 9999 0.07 (-0.07)          Monopoly (MONOP) 49999 15.43 (+0.27)          Civil War (CVLWR) 150000 62.66 (-0.95)          In The Land Of Saints And Sinner (ILSAS) 150000 2.22 (-0.07)          The Ministry Of Ungentlemanly Wa (TMOUW) 109887 29.44 (+1.80)          Inside Out 2 (INOU2) 1000 256.83 (+1.15)          Downton Abbey 3 (DWTA3) 10 28.68 (-0.28)          Blue Lock The Movie - Episode Na (BLULK) 150000 15.00 (0.00)          Cleopatra (CLEOP) 5 58.74 (+0.24)          The Nickel Boys (NICKB) 150000 8.08 (+0.01)          Inside Out 2 (INOU2) 10 256.83 (+1.15)          The Nickel Boys (NICKB) 150000 8.08 (+0.01)          Bum's Rush (BUMSR) 3500 0.17 (+0.03)          Monopoly (MONOP) 150000 15.43 (+0.27)          Sydney Sweeney (SSWEE) 100 74.75 (+1.03)          Monopoly (MONOP) 150000 15.43 (+0.27)          The Ministry Of Ungentlemanly Wa (TMOUW) 50 29.44 (+1.80)          Robert Downey Jr. (RDOWN) 300 210.32 (-0.51)          Blitz (BLTZ) 57 2.58 (-0.01)          Challengers - Opening Weekend (CHALN.OW) 100 12.09 (+0.28)          Robert Downey Jr. (RDOWN) 675 210.32 (-0.51)          Dracula - A Love Tale (DRALT) 149999 18.46 (-1.09)          Legally Blonde 3 (BLON3) 5 19.12 (-0.08)          Legally Blonde 3 (BLON3) 5 19.12 (-0.08)          Trap (TRAP) 500 56.16 (+3.44)          Aang: The Last Airbender (ATLA1) 100000 45.05 (-0.80)          Batgirl (BATGR) 40 4.11 (+0.13)          Bambi (BAMBI) 49 35.84 (-0.03)          Are You Afraid of the Dark? (AYAFD) 9000 0.07 (+0.02)          Inside Out 2 (INOU2) 1 256.83 (+1.15)          Challengers - Opening Weekend (CHALN.OW) 15 12.09 (+0.28)          Bag Man (BAGMN) 8 1.58 (-0.01)          Will Smith (WSMIT) 86 96.24 (+0.50)          Legally Blonde 3 (BLON3) 200 19.12 (-0.08)          Inside Out 2 (INOU2) 7 256.83 (+1.15)          Dev Patel (DPATE) 10000 11.46 (-0.24)          Bad Moms' Moms (BADM3) 90700 0.20 (-0.03)          Pedro Pascal (PPASC) 25000 25.39 (+0.13)