HSX Forum

Movies

TLJ works as a movie you don't think too much about, but as part of an existing universe is where it falters

Posted by: Silverblue76 on Dec 29, 08:16 in response to RoBoGuru's post Nature of the beast in the internet age...A lot of people...

If your expectations are to watch the movie and walk out of the theater without ever giving it another thought, then TLJ is fine. It's visually amazing. 

The problem is fitting TLJ as part of an existing franchise and wanting to dig into it like it's Game of Thrones or the Song of Ice & Fire books for clues about a deeper story.

Rian wasn't given a roadmap of what the story was. There isn't a story, they're making it up as their going along and it's readily apparent from the TLJ.  

What really surprised me was watching TFA after TLJ and how much they clash with how one ends and the other begins.  Mark said he had to tell Rian about some continuity issues that needed to be fixed but it doesn't even seem like Rian watched TFA.  

I feel like a sucker wasting money reading the books Lucasfilm released that were supposed to be in-continuity now because TLJ doesn't match them. There's no one at Lucasfilm trying to actually build a world, they're just making a movie and then trying to piece them together.

No one is complaining about plot holes and universe building with Jumanji. It's a fun movie you watch and forget. The same might be said of TLJ.  Where Disney will be hurt is all the sales of related merchandise (like the books and comics) and the subsequent movies because SW fandom took a major hit. 

I do understand the SW fans who feel like Rian was making fun of them and mocking them.  All that stuff you want? That thing you think is sacred - I'm going to toss it over my shoulder and make fun of you for thinking it's important. 

Wednesday BO numbers: STAR8 $21.5m (down 22.4%)/$444.8 total; JUMNJ $15.1m (down 11.7%) $104.2m total tomcat90 Dec 28, 08:50

If STAR8 falls only 50% weekend/weekend (it fell 65.7% 1st to 2nd W/E), and only 30% weekdays (school back in), it would delist $584 tomcat90 Dec 28, 09:07

Tom, what a math wiz. PJ going to SW now with the family. {nm} tradermark Dec 28, 09:35

Haha, PJ :) {nm} tomcat90 Dec 28, 10:04

Weekend 3 wont drop much, should easily top rogue one's $50m 3rd wkend {nm} MattW Dec 28, 09:46

why would it drop 50% this WE? Rogue One dropped 22.5% and TFA 39.5% in their 3rd weekends, and this is NYE weekend {nm} numbersix_99 Dec 28, 09:47

STAR8 should increase this weekend, though not as much as other films. {nm} RollingThunder Dec 28, 09:49

I know you're using past data but increase? With the mix WOM, is doubtful, no? ROG fell 59% and STAR7 40% on Christmas, this one fell 67% {nm} mexgoer33 Dec 28, 10:07

And yes the calendar. But Last Year ROG fell 29% from Christmas to New Year's. Passengers and Sing increased {nm} mexgoer33 Dec 28, 10:08

Only reason the WOM is mixed is a small group of trolls trying to ruin everyone’s fun. {nm} austpow Dec 28, 13:33

I'm not a Troll and I'm a fan (not huge, but fan) and didn't like this one. Liked it less than Attack of the Clones. Neither my family {nm} mexgoer33 Dec 28, 14:34

Definitely not a small group. Everyone I work with will not shut up complaining about everything wrong with TLJ. Silverblue76 Dec 28, 15:22

I'm less and less convinced that this is completely true. Too many people I have talked to and too many other folks in other forums that albrown Dec 28, 15:41

Nature of the beast in the internet age...A lot of people loved 'La La Land', some thought it was trash. Many have hailed 'Blade Runner RoBoGuru Dec 29, 06:41

TLJ works as a movie you don't think too much about, but as part of an existing universe is where it falters Silverblue76 Dec 29, 08:16

the Star Wars subreddit seems about 50/50 whenever I glance at the threads...some even re-watched it tealfan Dec 28, 19:04

Rian Johnson killed the story, sorry, it's just awful.. Almost fell asleep the first 2 hours, then wanted a refund. {nm} TJNFL1 Dec 30, 01:33

Even if you split the difference, and it falls 31%, that puts W/E#3 at $49.38 (let's call it $51m to top RO), that still delists at $599 {nm} tomcat90 Dec 28, 09:58

Solid for JUMNJ. {nm} RollingThunder Dec 28, 09:43

Those Jumanji gains tho 🤗 {nm} MattW Dec 28, 09:46

BOG Estimating $200m+ by end of run tomcat90 Dec 28, 10:01

If it follows more or less the Night at the Museum route, this will delist at more than 200M {nm} mexgoer33 Dec 28, 10:13

Apparently people really like Amy Pond's stomach. :P {nm} DTravel Dec 28, 12:28





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


The Odyssey (ODYSE) 10000 292.71 (+0.30)          Sniff (SNIFF) 25000 0.09 (0.00)          Melania (MLNIA) 150000 14.79 (-0.09)          Scream 7 (SCRM7) 10000 81.89 (+0.35)          The Riders (RIDER) 50000 33.56 (-0.93)          Doctor Strange 3 (DRST3) 10000 94.96 (+0.26)          Iron Lung (IRONL) 3000 24.37 (+0.01)          The Custom of the Country (TCOTC) 150000 18.11 (+1.44)          The Great Beyond aka Ghostwriter (ACRNS) 10000 113.34 (+0.41)          The Raid (RAID1) 25000 0.05 (0.00)          Highlander (HIGHL) 1166 36.24 (-0.03)          Man of Tomorrow (SPMOT) 10000 266.37 (-0.54)          The Social Reckoning aka The Soc (SOCI2) 10000 63.24 (-0.11)          Moana (MOAN1) 10000 219.43 (+0.36)          Zootopia 2 $285M Blockbuster War (ZOOT2.BW) 100 22.15 (-0.07)          Dolly (DOLLY) 75000 2.26 (+0.08)          Rebecca Hall (RBHAL) 25000 43.89 (+0.16)          Dracula (DRALT) 150000 3.99 (+0.01)          Wicked: For Good $315M Blockbust (WCKD2.BW) 100 13.95 (+0.03)          Practical Magic 2 (PRAC2) 10000 49.03 (+0.06)          Kokuho (KOKUH) 150000 1.02 (+0.02)          The Custom of the Country (TCOTC) 50000 18.11 (+1.44)          FOX: Memory of a Killer (MEMOAK) 100 10.58 (+0.07)          A Minecraft Movie II (MINE2) 10000 308.06 (-0.30)          CBS: Boston Blue (BOSBLU) 100 15.13 (0.00)          Magic: The Gathering (MGCTG) 10000 36.07 (+0.07)          Samara Weaving (SAWEA) 1000 31.99 (0.00)          The Custom of the Country (TCOTC) 20000 18.11 (+1.44)          Shelter (SELTR) 150000 12.45 (-0.81)          Evangeline Lilly (ELILL) 25000 165.79 (+0.50)          FOX: Best Medicine (BESMED) 100 8.86 (0.00)          Supergirl (SUPGR) 10000 181.39 (+0.20)          Shelter (SELTR) 150000 12.45 (-0.81)          Avatar: Fire and Ash $345M Block (AVAT3.BW) 100 13.82 (+0.07)          Andrew Stanton (ANSTA) 25000 184.94 (-0.50)          Wuthering Heights (WUTHR) 10000 87.78 (-0.14)          Clayface (CLAYF) 114602 72.17 (+0.19)          J.J. Abrams (JABRA) 25000 187.36 (+0.50)          The Mummy 4 (MUMY5) 5000 76.72 (+0.25)          Robert Downey Jr. (RDOWN) 25000 230.29 (-1.50)          Clayface (CLAYF) 114602 72.17 (+0.19)          Zendaya (ZENDA) 24999 135.52 (-1.00)          Frankenstein - Adapted Screenpla (A6EFRN) 90 2.18 (0.00)          Reenactment (RNACT) 75000 6.78 (+0.06)          Francis and the Godfather (FGODF) 25000 0.04 (+0.01)          Clayface (CLAYF) 150000 72.17 (+0.19)          Wonka 2 (WONK2) 10000 65.13 (+0.06)          Leonardo DiCaprio - One Battle a (A6ALDC) 90 5.14 (-0.03)          Coyote vs. ACME (CVACM) 150000 35.53 (+0.06)          The Cat in the Hat (TCATH) 10000 80.49 (-0.10)