HSX Forum

Movies

But the Uncharted games are more cinematically inclined than most games, whose popularlity stemmed in large part from characters and story.

Posted by: Paul2k on May 26, 15:38 in response to tawdryhepburn's post And this is a problem because...?

It's understandable to "revision" a video game for the cinema when the game is just quest, quest, quest, or level, level, level with only tenuous plot and uninteresting characters.

V: David O. Russell leaves 'Uncharted: Drake's Fortune' medusa May 26, 13:01

I think that's good news for fans! {nm} Antibody May 26, 13:14

His fans or the game's fans? Because this would have been the first time a real auteur took a shot at a video game film. tawdryhepburn May 26, 13:19

An auteur who sounded like he had never even played the game before. {nm} CS May 26, 13:20

Game's fans. His ideas had nothing to do with the actual game. {nm} Antibody May 26, 13:22

And this is a problem because...? tawdryhepburn May 26, 15:33

Because if you bastardize the film beyond reconition, you will lose the built in fanbase. {nm} Antibody May 26, 15:37

Because Godfather, Apocalypse Now, Of Human Bondage, The Iron Giant, Frankenstein and countless other book-to-films all sucked, right? tawdryhepburn May 26, 17:04

Yes, there are probably many book adaptations that sucked as that succeeded, so what. {nm} Antibody May 26, 17:24

Those were all book adaptations that were NOTHING like the novel. Hell, Of Human Bondage is litterally just one chapter of the book. tawdryhepburn May 26, 17:31

Was there a fanbase for that? The videogame movies that've suceeded are those that its fans considered respectful Antibody May 26, 17:53

Resident Evil is NOTHING like the games. And I didn't say that SMB was good. I said it was one of the best video game adaptations. tawdryhepburn May 26, 18:49

But the Uncharted games are more cinematically inclined than most games, whose popularlity stemmed in large part from characters and story. Paul2k May 26, 15:38

No one has EVER bought a video game for the story. It can be a bonus, but it is NEVER the deciding factor. tawdryhepburn May 26, 17:07

*correction* A video game has never been SUCCESSFUL because of the story. They live and die by gameplay. {nm} tawdryhepburn May 26, 17:08

I agree, gameply absolutely trumps story/character in determining a successful (critical and commercial) game. But, story/character can aid Paul2k May 26, 17:19

Eh, fair enough. But Uncharted could never turn a profit by appealing to the game's fans. tawdryhepburn May 26, 17:30

I wonder if Mark Wahlberg will also leave the project. Alot of fans wanted to see Nathan Fillion. {nm} Nightfury82 May 26, 13:33





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


Sense and Sensibility (SNSNS) 2110 15.69 (-0.41)          Insidious: Out of the Further (NSID6) 9 40.94 (+0.26)          Hershey (HERSH) 150000 9.27 (-0.24)          Escape From New York (ESCNY) 150000 5.30 (+0.43)          Seance on a Wet Afternoon (SOAWA) 149996 4.93 (-0.09)          Hershey (HERSH) 150000 9.27 (-0.24)          The Weight (THEWT) 149996 7.76 (-0.06)          Mutiny (MUTNY) 4 24.11 (-0.02)          Project Hail Mary $260M Blockbus (PRJHM.BW) 25000 5.86 (+0.20)          PAW Patrol: The Dino Movie (PAWP3) 5 39.93 (-0.15)          Teen Titans (TEENT) 150000 34.50 (-0.16)          Metal Gear Solid (MTLGR) 150000 15.41 (+1.46)          A Place In Hell (APHEL) 150000 6.69 (-1.02)          Metal Gear Solid (MTLGR) 150000 15.41 (+1.46)          One Night Only (ONTON) 4 22.26 (+0.04)          Passenger (PSNGR) 149996 26.70 (+0.29)          Ice Cream Man (ICREM) 15 14.31 (+0.17)          Gladys aka Weapons prequel (WEPN2) 100000 56.41 (-0.88)          Moana (MOAN1) 25 222.39 (-0.16)          The Invite (TINVT) 8 16.07 (+0.10)          Supergirl (SUPGR) 10 156.68 (+0.11)          Parallel Tales (PRLLT) 4 1.70 (0.00)          The Death of Robin Hood (TDORH) 350 25.51 (-0.03)          Green Hornet and Kato (GHKTO) 149999 8.09 (-0.03)          Disclosure Day (SKIES) 4 161.43 (+0.11)          The Death of Robin Hood (TDORH) 4 25.51 (-0.03)          Disclosure Day (SKIES) 4 161.43 (+0.11)          Scary Movie 6 (SCAR6) 4 69.36 (+0.05)          Ice Cream Man (ICREM) 4 14.31 (+0.17)          Pressure (PRSUR) 9 17.67 (+0.12)          Metal Gear Solid (MTLGR) 149999 15.41 (+1.46)          Hot Wheels (HOTWH) 149996 20.74 (+0.06)          In the Grey (NGREY) 100 20.94 (0.00)          Hope (HOPE) 149998 4.73 (-0.08)          Exit 8 (EXIT8) 150000 3.06 (+0.19)          The Wizard of the Kremlin (WZKRM) 5 5.11 (-0.02)          Hope (HOPE) 149996 4.73 (-0.08)          Lizard Music (LZMUS) 58651 19.05 (+1.16)          The Devil Wears Prada 2 (PRAD2) 5 209.08 (-0.49)          Desert Warrior (DSRTW) 550 2.39 (0.00)          Exit 8 (EXIT8) 150000 3.06 (+0.19)          You, Me & Tuscany (ITLIA) 200 21.33 (-0.07)          You, Me & Tuscany (ITLIA) 8 21.33 (-0.07)          Logan's Run (LOGAN) 149999 3.38 (-0.03)          Bunnylovr (BNYLV) 2000 0.06 (0.00)          The Furious (FURIS) 4 5.73 (+0.04)          Gambino (GMBNO) 10 11.69 (+0.95)          Fatherland aka 1949 (FTHRL) 4 1.77 (-0.06)          Chili Finger (CHILF) 100004 3.35 (-0.03)          Sense and Sensibility (SNSNS) 150000 15.69 (-0.41)