Market Announcement: NominOptions for the leading Oscar contenders will begin trading on Thursday..

HSX Forums: Movies Board

My question is, is there such a thing as "comedy fatigue", where too much of a particular genre in too short a timespan lowers BO? {nm}

Posted by: Paul2k on Jul 17, 18:33 in response to lobogotti's post that number is bad for CHNUP imo. FWBFT of course is...

RS: [CAPAM] high 40s [FWBFT] low 20s   TheWeekendWarrior on Jul 17, 17:48

high 40s??? really??? {nm}   David_Francis on Jul 17, 17:56

Could Potter's dominance of all things cinema cause the tracking for Captain to be pushed lower than it should be? {nm}   David_Francis on Jul 17, 17:57

I asw the trailer for CAPAM, in front of TF3, and found it utterly uninteresting. {nm}   Facto on Jul 17, 18:01

i agree, looks rly bad and boring. {nm}   kalelanalang on Jul 17, 18:12

^ +1 but then I'm not much for superheroes. Prefer to watch ape revenge! :) {nm}   Jane_Citizen on Jul 17, 18:26

they should play moar trailers that make u feel sad for the ape (the reason he gets put in a cage) and less apes going wild in the city. {nm}   kalelanalang on Jul 17, 18:35

The trailer in Australia shows the reason he gets put into a cage, but the one on HSX doesn't seem to.   Jane_Citizen on Jul 17, 18:44

i disagree. looks like an excellent action packed film. marvel is on a roll afterall. {nm}   Nightfury82 on Jul 17, 19:43

I think it looks horrible. Chris Evans is terrible as well. What a horrible pick. {nm}   Juiced on Jul 18, 04:36

I'm surprised they have the Apes going higher than Captain and Cowboys. {nm}   Paul2k on Jul 17, 17:59

Hasn't predicted the Apes opening considerably stronger than CBALN for a long time.. ? {nm}   Facto on Jul 17, 18:02

Their long-term page currently guesses 33M for CBALN and 32M for RSAPE. {nm}   second gary on Jul 17, 18:13're right, up until this week, they did have the damn dirty apes far outpacing the Cowboys. I just think that recent trailers and   Paul2k on Jul 17, 18:17

But "comedy" isn't a genre in the same way that "superhero-with-cape, forgetting-the-warning-of-Edna-Mole" is a genre. So, ....   second gary on Jul 17, 18:40

Oops. How did this get here? {nm}   second gary on Jul 17, 18:41

completely agree. as long as they remain funny, people will go. laughs don't get tired like genre conventions can. {nm}   Jane_Citizen on Jul 17, 18:45

The trailer for Apes looks pretty great to me. {nm}   Jane_Citizen on Jul 17, 18:15

Planet of the Apes adjusts to a $95m OW. Nothing unreasonable about RS's number. {nm}   Rolling_Thunder on Jul 17, 19:08

does it come out on a holiday weekend? (Apes)   Jane_Citizen on Jul 17, 20:48

go RSAPE...and thanks for the numbers {nm}   lobogotti on Jul 17, 18:16

Im definitely more interested in RSAPE than the cowboys and aliens movie. {nm}   Dorfman on Jul 17, 18:27

yeah, I find myself wanting to see it (Apey) for the CGI....similar to Avatar. though I will see CBALN, just not really digging it. {nm}   lobogotti on Jul 17, 18:29

that number is bad for CHNUP imo. FWBFT of course is playing to a younger, hipper crowd, but still. {nm}   lobogotti on Jul 17, 18:27

My question is, is there such a thing as "comedy fatigue", where too much of a particular genre in too short a timespan lowers BO? {nm}   Paul2k on Jul 17, 18:33

if it is FWBFT, CHNUP and 30MOL will suffer (at least one). they all look equally decent....i think 30MOL looks better than the other two. {nm}   lobogotti on Jul 17, 18:36

No; see above. Audiences are pretty good at tuning in to the difference between generic features and derivative features. {nm}   second gary on Jul 17, 18:45

Interesting numbers for both Cap and FWBFT, but I want to see MTC before I say anymore. As for CHNUP I'm betting the low tracking numbers    wrongturn687 on Jul 17, 18:54

I'm a little surprised that CAPAM dropped from last week (high 50s), as I'd thought this phase of the ad-campaign was doing a good job.   second gary on Jul 17, 20:11

Or will the summer of comedies keep rolling with FWBFT, CSLOV, CHNUP etc...haven't the long-range estimators been low on all the comedies? {nm}   Paul2k on Jul 17, 18:35

normally, but i think MTC was very close on HRBOS, way off on BRDSM and a bit low on BDTCH {nm}   lobogotti on Jul 17, 18:38

Could Smurfs be the next Alvin and the Chipmunks? Seems like Smurfs have been around longer and have more awareness than the Munks.   skamanfu on Jul 17, 21:02

Chipmunks have been around since the late 50's {nm}   stevenj1127 on Jul 17, 21:23

Had no idea the Chipmunks had been around that long. {nm}   skamanfu on Jul 17, 22:22

They've both been around since the late 50's {nm}   owen111 on Jul 18, 08:15

Donnie Darko never pointed out the illogic of the chipmunks. So, no, the Smurfs could not be the next Alvin and the Chipmunks, despite...   second gary on Jul 17, 21:54

The Smurfs cartoon has been in regular rotation on Boomerang for awhile   alfpaul on Jul 17, 23:59

No one outside the US knows the chipmunks, the smurfs have a bigger international audience   petz on Jul 18, 01:20

If no one outside the US knows about the chipmunks than how come the squeakqual did 4m more international than domestic? {nm}   Dorfman on Jul 18, 06:05

And the first one did a respectible 144m international {nm}   Dorfman on Jul 18, 06:06

I meant prior to the films, it doesn't mean that they couldn't have been a success {nm}   petz on Jul 18, 06:56

n 3 grammys had a platinumPrior to the films back in the 50's and 50's they wo record. 4 gold records in the 80's. I'm sure they were known.   Dorfman on Jul 18, 07:54

Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!

Mouse Guard (MOUSG) 10000 47.72 (-0.96)         Mouse Guard (MOUSG) 100000 47.72 (-0.96)         Mouse Guard (MOUSG) 100000 47.72 (-0.96)         The Six Billion Dollar Man (6MILL) 100000 32.25 (-0.06)         Bird Box (BRDBX) 100000 1.72 (+0.18)         Write When You Get Work (WWYGW) 6500 0.99 (0.00)         48 Hours (48HRS) 100000 9.60 (+0.68)         Guava Island (GUAVA) 100000 19.51 (+0.42)         Shoplifters (SHPLF) 6500 1.82 (0.00)         Run (RUN) 100000 26.45 (-0.68)         24/7 (247) 100000 16.93 (-0.42)         Roma (ROMA) 6500 0.53 (-0.01)         Garrett Hedlund (GHEDL) 20000 37.98 (-0.08)         The Sound of Silence (SOSLN) 40000 3.72 (-0.18)         Mouse Guard (MOUSG) 100000 47.72 (-0.96)         Bumblebee (TFRM6) 99999 127.89 (+0.24)         Charlie Hunnam (CHUNN) 20000 33.17 (-0.08)         Wrong Answer (WRANS) 100000 11.08 (+0.80)         The Sound of Silence (SOSLN) 10000 3.72 (-0.18)         Run (RUN) 100000 26.45 (-0.68)         Toff Guys (TOFFG) 100000 28.70 (+0.33)         Guava Island (GUAVA) 100000 19.51 (+0.42)         Cruella (CRULA) 25000 42.04 (+1.35)         J.C. Chandor (JCCHA) 20000 9.04 (-0.04)         24/7 (247) 100000 16.93 (-0.42)         Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Vers (ASPDR.OW) 100000 39.02 (-0.10)         Jonathan (JONAN) 6500 0.57 (0.00)         Mouse Guard (MOUSG) 100000 47.72 (-0.96)         Latino Fund Nueve (LATIN) 10000 20.11 (0.00)         At Eternity's Gate (ETRNG) 6500 1.93 (0.00)         Black Hole (BLKHO) 1000 0.48 (0.00)         Transformers 7 (TFRM7) 100000 42.15 (+2.16)         Transformers 7 (TFRM7) 100000 42.15 (+2.16)         The Clovehitch Killer (CLVHT) 6500 1.67 (0.00)         Maya Rudolph (MRUDO) 19998 38.26 (-0.08)         Transformers 7 (TFRM7) 100000 42.15 (+2.16)         55 Steps (55STP) 6500 0.47 (+0.01)         Fantastic Beasts Crimes of Grind (FBST2.BW) 20000 5.04 (+0.04)         Beetlejuice 2 (BEET2) 1000 2.18 (-0.01)         Fantastic Beasts Crimes of Grind (FBST2.BW) 20000 5.04 (+0.04)         Avatar 3 (AVAT3) 1000 290.68 (0.00)         Mortal Engines H$20 Put (MENGN.PU) 20000 3.43 (+0.01)         Mortal Engines H$20 Put (MENGN.PU) 20000 3.43 (+0.01)         Mortal Engines H$20 Call (MENGN.CA) 20000 1.02 (-0.02)         Mortal Engines H$20 Call (MENGN.CA) 20000 1.02 (-0.02)         Mortal Engines - Opening Weekend (MENGN.OW) 100000 16.03 (-0.12)         Mortal Engines - Opening Weekend (MENGN.OW) 100000 16.03 (-0.12)         Apollo 11 (APO11) 1000 1.65 (0.00)         Mortal Engines (MENGN) 100000 41.34 (-0.26)         Mortal Engines (MENGN) 100000 41.34 (-0.26)