HSX Forum

Movies

I rewatched it last year and felt the opposite. Despite the flaws it's the only decent one of the new trilogy

Posted by: numbersix_99 on Dec 30, 12:48 in response to shipwreckedcrew's post Watched STAR8 last night on TNT for first time since...

I agree with the criticisms about its structure - splitting the main cast into 3 storylines feels too much, particularly when their re-connection is so contrived. Floating Leia is also pretty awful. 

 

But everything done with Luke was incredible and some of the best things I've seen int he franchise since Return of the Jedi. To humanise him, to give him flaws, was incredible. It's amusing to watch the fanboys explode at the idea of giving their hero flaws. That's the point, and he redeems himself in such a beautiful way. In fact, a film about flaws is pretty intriguing as a blockbuster. 

 

It's also visually the best SW film since Empire. Beautiful shots and sequences, inspired by Kurosawa. 

 

I'd take all this over TFA which has Kasdan yet managed to be a pale imitation of A Hew Hope, and just felt tired and pointless. And don't get me started on Rise, a film that is so poorly told and such nonsense that it makes TLJ look like a masterpiece. 





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


Ben Stiller (BSTIL) 25000 54.19 (0.00)          Will Poulter (WPOUL) 25000 60.65 (+0.25)          B.J. Novak (BJNOV) 25000 100.55 (-0.33)          Tony (TONY) 150000 15.66 (+2.72)          White Elephant (WELEP) 129711 18.00 (0.00)          Fleur (FLEUR) 50000 7.40 (+0.51)          Tony (TONY) 150000 15.66 (+2.72)          Last Friday (FRID4) 150000 7.38 (+0.02)          Last Friday (FRID4) 150000 7.38 (+0.02)          The Princess Diaries 3 (PDIA3) 40000 35.79 (+0.10)          Fleur (FLEUR) 50000 7.40 (+0.51)          Fleur (FLEUR) 50000 7.40 (+0.51)          Cut Off (CUTOF) 70000 33.08 (-1.24)          The Kidnapping of Arabella (TKOAR) 5000 0.75 (+0.03)          Night of the Living Dead (NOTLD) 150000 2.77 (0.00)          Night of the Living Dead (NOTLD) 150000 2.77 (0.00)          Fleur (FLEUR) 50000 7.40 (+0.51)          Fleur (FLEUR) 50000 7.40 (+0.51)          The Catch (TCATC) 1000 58.58 (+4.59)          Them (THEM) 50000 41.14 (+1.14)          Fleur (FLEUR) 50000 7.40 (+0.51)          Crime After Crime (CACRM) 150000 2.46 (-0.02)          Crime After Crime (CACRM) 150000 2.46 (-0.02)          Scream 8 (SCRM8) 1000 77.92 (+0.33)          The Catch (TCATC) 15000 58.58 (+4.59)          The Sheep Detectives (3BAGF) 25000 46.92 (-1.90)          Them (THEM) 30000 41.14 (+1.14)          Jurassic World sequel (JURA8) 10000 238.22 (-0.06)          Incredibles 3 (NCRD3) 1000 377.61 (-0.52)          Moral Capacity (MORLC) 50000 5.01 (+0.03)          White Elephant (WELEP) 150000 18.00 (0.00)          The Devil Wears Prada 2 (PRAD2) 149999 199.82 (-6.28)          The Bourne Dilemma (BORN6) 1000 81.13 (+0.66)          White Elephant (WELEP) 1132 18.00 (0.00)          A Colt Is My Passport (ACIMP) 1000 7.69 (-0.08)          The Bookie & the Bruiser (TBATB) 149998 7.66 (+1.03)          Good People Bad Things (GPBT) 50000 14.40 (+1.11)          The Sun Never Sets (TSNVS) 2 2.52 (+0.79)          Good People Bad Things (GPBT) 50000 14.40 (+1.11)          The Bookie & the Bruiser (TBATB) 150000 7.66 (+1.03)          The Bookie & the Bruiser (TBATB) 150000 7.66 (+1.03)          Tony (TONY) 2 15.66 (+2.72)          Good People Bad Things (GPBT) 50000 14.40 (+1.11)          Good People Bad Things (GPBT) 50000 14.40 (+1.11)          Them (THEM) 149998 41.14 (+1.14)          Them (THEM) 10000 41.14 (+1.14)          The Catch (TCATC) 10000 58.58 (+4.59)          Oceans (OCEN5) 149975 47.34 (+0.44)          Bad Fairies (BFAIR) 149975 35.24 (+0.09)          Good People Bad Things (GPBT) 50000 14.40 (+1.11)