HSX Forum

TVStocks, MusicStocks and Life

Yeah, that part about the Dutch.. Unexplored territory, so far :-) However, I think that article made good and fair points. Holland may be

Posted by: Facto on Jul 12, 06:44 in response to JMT's post I stand in awe of all this fact-digging. Your name is...

the commercial and most famous part of the Netherlands, and the Netherlands Bureau of Tourism is of course not helping things when they establish a site called Holland.com, etc. All explained in the article. I like the analogy that calling all of the Netherlands Holland, is like calling all of Great Britain England. The English may really like it, but the Scots and the Welsh, not so much.. Cool

The part about wrongful learning in schools (especially within Holland proper, I'm sure) is also covered by the eloquent article. Also, the English speaking Wikipedia, which is not a bad source at all, in most cases, points in the same direction. There seems little doubt that Holland is an unofficial name of the country officially known as The Netherlands.

This article also explains some points

"All these counties (called provinces today, together with some new ones) are now called "The Kingdom of the Netherlands."
dot
dot Today the province of Limburg still has a Governor and to say to someone from Limburg or Friesland that he or she is from Holland, is considered an insult. They are not! They consider themselves to be from the Netherlands. They even have their own language.
dot
dot People from other Provinces (except North and South Holland) will perhaps not consider it a real insult, but still they're not from Holland."

(I recommend reading through all of it - it's only 4 times more than the above.)

I also lived with two people from Holland proper until last christmas. They were from the Holland-region, and were university/academical students. They said Netherlands is the official name, but quickly changed to say that "no, strike that, say Holland!", laughing out loud. So it's quite clear that it's a matter of regional/nationalist pride, but not, for most, a serious matter - more like an in-joke. But for those who come from Limburg or Friesland, it seems it's not so much of a laughing matter.

Either way, there's no disputing that the official name of the country is The Netherlands. It's interesting to hear you've been taught otherwise, but not knowing much about you, other than that you are from the Holland-part of the country - the part that we hear by far the most about abroad, as Amsterdam, Rotterdam and Den Haag are all there - it's hard for me to put this anecdotal piece of input into much context, so far.

Otherwise, thanks for your commendations on my research - and feel free to post an authoritative and credible article which cogently makes the case that Holland should be the official name for all of the country, and not The Netherlands Smile

The Hollands/the Netherlands debate -first off,I'm wondering if other constituent countries within the kingdom have their own national teams Facto Jul 09, 15:19

Seems all the countries have their own national football teams - witness the Caribbean countries' membership in the CONCACAF Facto Jul 09, 15:31

How many of you had thought that the EU (European Union) is well represented within the Americas? Well, seems it is: Facto Jul 09, 16:21

I learned something else new from that link - Greece has an "autonomous monastic region" How cool is that. {nm} daveart Jul 09, 16:24

Haven't checked it, but lemme guess - Macedonia? {nm} Facto Jul 09, 16:32

Disregard that; it's Mount Athos, *within* the Greek region of Macedonia... {nm} Facto Jul 09, 18:16

Holland and The Netherlands are both correct. The confusion is due to... JMT Jul 10, 01:24

I don't get this logic. Both regions named Holland are to the west, facing the coast. All the rest of the Netherlands is to the north, east Facto Jul 11, 02:25

Or actually, in English it's called "The Flying Dutchman", but the original title seems to have been Der fliegende Hollânder. Facto Jul 11, 02:33

Alright, check this out - Holland or Netherland is easy to google, it actually even comes up as a suggestion, when you type "holland or.. " Facto Jul 11, 04:23

And a powerful appeal is also found within the article I linked to above: Facto Jul 11, 04:56

I stand in awe of all this fact-digging. Your name is aptly chosen. But... JMT Jul 12, 04:16

Yeah, that part about the Dutch.. Unexplored territory, so far :-) However, I think that article made good and fair points. Holland may be Facto Jul 12, 06:44

Let's also for instance see what Berkeley University (and various other sources, including official Dutch ones) state on the issue: Facto Jul 12, 07:34

Haha... you are obsessed ! Thanks anyway. Good research {nm} JMT Jul 12, 11:36

I love this kinda stuff :-) Facto Jul 12, 12:56





Post a Reply

To post to the forums you must first login!


Klara and the Sun (KLARA) 267 2.34 (-0.03)          Clayface (CLAYF) 2000 63.06 (-0.33)          Brianna Hildebrand (BHILD) 1999 148.66 (0.00)          Brianna Hildebrand (BHILD) 1999 148.66 (0.00)          The Haunting of Hotel Transylvan (HTRN5) 150000 96.48 (-1.00)          The Haunting of Hotel Transylvan (HTRN5) 150000 96.48 (-1.00)          Diego Boneta (DBONE) 2999 21.82 (0.00)          Clay (CLAY) 150000 113.37 (-1.61)          Diego Boneta (DBONE) 2999 21.82 (0.00)          Clay (CLAY) 150000 113.37 (-1.61)          Ralph Ineson (RINES) 5000 85.60 (0.00)          Ralph Ineson (RINES) 16000 85.60 (0.00)          Hollow (HOLOW) 150000 50.00 (0.00)          Mark Duplass (MDUPL) 15000 43.10 (0.00)          Chang Chen (CCHEN) 7000 22.41 (0.00)          Renee Zellweger (RZELL) 5000 19.87 (0.00)          Marion Cotillard (MCOTI) 8000 13.90 (0.00)          George Lopez (GLOPE) 10000 27.89 (+0.01)          Russell Crowe (RCROW) 1 9.99 (+0.05)          Russell Crowe (RCROW) 24999 9.99 (+0.05)          Tim Heidecker (THEID) 10000 7.07 (+0.05)          Sarah Polley (SPOLL) 10000 7.40 (+0.05)          Esme Creed-Miles (ECREE) 5000 5.20 (+0.10)          Jeff Nichols (JENIC) 1999 12.15 (+0.10)          The Family Disappears (TFAMD) 150000 13.93 (+0.07)          The Family Disappears (TFAMD) 150000 13.93 (+0.07)          Gina Prince-Bythewood (GPRIN) 3999 34.75 (+0.12)          Storm Reid (SREID) 10000 51.84 (+0.16)          Bad Influence (BNFLU) 150000 10.11 (+0.11)          The Family Disappears (TFAMD) 100000 13.93 (+0.07)          Xochitl Gomez (XGOME) 25000 105.16 (+0.10)          Xochitl Gomez (XGOME) 25000 105.16 (+0.10)          Kevin James (KJAME) 1993 88.53 (+0.25)          Werner Herzog (WHERZ) 24999 21.64 (+0.49)          Timothy Spall (TSPAL) 25000 3.52 (-0.10)          Timothy Spall (TSPAL) 25000 3.52 (-0.10)          Michael 2 (MJAC2) 51231 185.66 (+0.17)          River (RIVE1) 150000 20.02 (+0.10)          The Family Disappears (TFAMD) 49999 13.93 (+0.07)          Maggie Gyllenhaal (MGYLL) 24999 19.87 (+0.09)          Michael 2 (MJAC2) 62640 185.66 (+0.17)          Kogonada (KOGON) 25000 2.43 (-0.02)          Joel McHale (JMCHA) 6000 30.43 (+0.25)          Kogonada (KOGON) 1 2.43 (-0.02)          Donkey Kong aka Untitled Nintend (DKONG) 13852 144.33 (-0.94)          The Family Disappears (TFAMD) 150000 13.93 (+0.07)          Julianne Moore (JMOOR) 24999 9.08 (-0.11)          Jemaine Clement (JCLEM) 24999 138.63 (-0.33)          Jack Black (JBLAC) 25000 150.27 (+0.99)          Jack Black (JBLAC) 25000 150.27 (+0.99)